Kurze Zusammenfassung
Dieser Video-Test befasst sich mit dem Maya M1S, einem günstigen 4-Bay NAS mit M.2 NVMe-Laufwerken und einem Intel N100 Prozessor. Das Gerät ist für 149 Dollar erhältlich und bietet eine Reihe von Kompromissen, die im Video ausführlich diskutiert werden. Trotz des niedrigen Preises bietet das M1S eine gute Leistung für Aufgaben wie Plex-Server, Container und virtuelle Maschinen. Allerdings gibt es auch einige Nachteile, wie z. B. die geringe Größe, die zu Problemen mit der Kühlung führt, und die schwierige Installation.
- Das M1S bietet eine gute Leistung für den Preis, aber es gibt einige Kompromisse.
- Das Gerät ist klein und hat Probleme mit der Kühlung.
- Die Installation ist schwierig und erfordert viel Sorgfalt.
Der Rezensent stellt das Maya M1S vor, ein 4-Bay NAS mit M.2 NVMe-Laufwerken und einem Intel N100 Prozessor. Das Gerät ist für 149 Dollar erhältlich und bietet eine Reihe von Kompromissen, die im Video ausführlich diskutiert werden. Der Rezensent betont, dass der Preis des Geräts viele Kompromisse rechtfertigt, aber es ist wichtig, diese Kompromisse zu verstehen, bevor man sich für den Kauf entscheidet.
Das M1S ist mit einem Intel N100 Prozessor ausgestattet, einem Quad-Core-Prozessor mit 4 Threads und integrierter Grafik. Der Prozessor ist für Plex-Server, Container und virtuelle Maschinen geeignet und bietet eine gute Leistung für den Preis. Der Rezensent erwähnt, dass der N100 Prozessor in der ersten Jahreshälfte 2025 mit der neuen Twin Lake-Version aktualisiert wurde.
Das M1S unterstützt DDR5-Speicher, aber es wird ohne zusätzlichen Speicher oder Laufwerke geliefert. Das Gerät verfügt über vier M.2 NVMe-Schächte, die jeweils mit Gen 3x1 ausgestattet sind. Der Rezensent hat mit Unraid überprüft, dass die Schächte tatsächlich mit Gen 3x1 ausgestattet sind.
Das M1S verfügt über einen fünften M.2-Schacht im 2230-Format, der mit einem 64 GB E2 M2230-Laufwerk ausgestattet ist. Dieses Laufwerk dient in der Regel als Systemlaufwerk für die Windows-Installation. Der Rezensent erwähnt, dass der Schacht auch mit einem anderen Laufwerk belegt werden kann, aber er ist sehr klein und die Verwendung eines Adapters kann schwierig sein.
Der Rezensent führt Leistungstests mit den M.2 NVMe-Laufwerken durch und erzielt Lesegeschwindigkeiten von 780 bis 790 MB/s und Schreibgeschwindigkeiten von 680 bis 685 MB/s. Diese Ergebnisse sind für ein System mit einem N100 Prozessor typisch. Der Rezensent ist auch mit der Geschwindigkeit des Datentransfers zwischen den Laufwerken zufrieden, die zwischen 390 und 500 MB/s liegt.
Der Rezensent kritisiert, dass das M1S ohne Wärmeleitpads geliefert wird. Er findet, dass dies ein Kompromiss ist, der nicht notwendig gewesen wäre. Der Rezensent erwähnt auch, dass das Gerät mit einigen zusätzlichen Füßen für die Basis der Laufwerke, einer englischen Bedienungsanleitung und einem externen Netzteil geliefert wird.
Der Rezensent stellt fest, dass das M1S sehr klein ist und nur wenig Platz für Wärmeleitpads bietet. Er befürchtet, dass die Wärmeleitpads den Luftstrom behindern könnten, wenn sie zu dick sind. Er empfiehlt, dünne Wärmeleitpads zu verwenden, um die Kühlung zu optimieren.
Der Rezensent führt weitere Leistungstests mit den M.2 NVMe-Laufwerken durch und bestätigt die zuvor erzielten Ergebnisse. Er ist mit der Leistung der Laufwerke zufrieden und betont, dass die Ergebnisse für ein System mit einem N100 Prozessor typisch sind.
Der Rezensent misst die Geschwindigkeit des Datentransfers zwischen den Laufwerken und erzielt Ergebnisse zwischen 390 und 500 MB/s. Er ist mit diesen Ergebnissen zufrieden und betont, dass das M1S mit seinen vier M.2 NVMe-Schächten eine gute Leistung bietet.
Der Rezensent erwähnt, dass es möglich ist, einen M.2-to-10GbE-Adapter zu verwenden, um die Netzwerkgeschwindigkeit zu erhöhen. Allerdings würde dies einen der M.2-Schächte belegen und die Verwendung des oberen Panels des Geräts verhindern.
Der Rezensent misst die Leistungsaufnahme des M1S unter verschiedenen Lasten. Im Leerlauf verbraucht das Gerät etwa 12 bis 13 Watt, während es unter Last mit zwei aktiven Windows 11-VMs etwa 28 bis 29 Watt verbraucht. Der Rezensent ist mit der Leistungsaufnahme des Geräts zufrieden und findet sie für die Leistung, die es bietet, angemessen.
Das M1S bietet eine Vielzahl von Anschlüssen und Konnektivitätsoptionen. Auf der Vorderseite befinden sich drei USB 3.2 Gen 2-Anschlüsse (Typ A und Typ C) und ein 10 Gigabit-Ethernet-Anschluss. Auf der Rückseite befinden sich zwei weitere USB 2.0-Anschlüsse, zwei 2,5 Gigabit-Ethernet-Anschlüsse, ein DisplayPort und ein HDMI-Ausgang (4K 60 Hz). Im Inneren befindet sich ein weiterer USB-Anschluss, der für die Installation von Unraid verwendet werden kann.
Der Rezensent kritisiert die Installation des M1S als schwierig und umständlich. Er findet, dass die Anordnung der Komponenten die Installation von Speicher und Laufwerken erschwert und die Wartung des Geräts schwierig macht.
Der Rezensent ist besorgt über die Überhitzung des M1S. Er stellt fest, dass das Gerät bereits im Leerlauf eine Temperatur von 44 bis 45 Grad Celsius erreicht. Unter Last steigen die Temperaturen schnell auf über 60 Grad Celsius. Der Rezensent empfiehlt, das Gerät in einer gut belüfteten Umgebung zu betreiben, um die Überhitzung zu vermeiden.
Der Rezensent führt Stresstests mit dem M1S durch und verwendet eine Wärmebildkamera, um die Temperaturverteilung des Geräts zu beobachten. Die Ergebnisse zeigen, dass das Gerät stark überhitzt, insbesondere die M.2 NVMe-Laufwerke. Der Rezensent ist besorgt über die fehlende Kühlung der Laufwerke und empfiehlt, das Gerät in einer gut belüfteten Umgebung zu betreiben.
Der Rezensent betont die Notwendigkeit eines guten Wärmemanagements für das M1S. Er empfiehlt, das Gerät in einer gut belüfteten Umgebung zu betreiben und die Verwendung von Wärmeleitpads zu berücksichtigen, um die Kühlung der Laufwerke zu verbessern.
Der Rezensent betont, dass der Preis des M1S viele Kompromisse rechtfertigt. Er räumt ein, dass das Gerät einige Nachteile hat, aber es bietet eine gute Leistung für den Preis. Er empfiehlt, die Kompromisse zu verstehen, bevor man sich für den Kauf entscheidet.
Der Rezensent empfiehlt das M1S für Aufgaben wie Plex-Server, Container und virtuelle Maschinen. Er findet, dass das Gerät für diese Aufgaben eine gute Leistung bietet und für den Preis eine gute Wahl ist. Er erwähnt auch, dass das M1S gut geeignet ist, um mehrere Geräte zu einem Cluster zu verbinden.
Der Rezensent fasst seine Gedanken zum M1S zusammen und betont, dass es ein gutes Gerät für den Preis ist, aber es einige Kompromisse bietet. Er empfiehlt, die Kompromisse zu verstehen, bevor man sich für den Kauf entscheidet. Er gibt auch Links zu den Online-Shops an, bei denen das M1S erhältlich ist.
Fasse jedes YouTube-Video in Sekunden zusammen
Hol dir Zusammenfassungen wie diese für jedes Video, in deiner Sprache, mit der kostenlosen Summ-App.
Transkript
Vollständiges Transkript von „Is $149 TOO CHEAP for a 4 SSD NAS? (Maiyunda M1S NAS Review)“. Klicke auf einen Zeitstempel, um das Video an dieser Stelle zu öffnen. Du brauchst ein anderes Video? Nutze den YouTube-Transkript-Generator.
0:00 hello and welcome back and today I want to talk about a Naz I've got real mixed feelings about today I want to talk about the Maya m1s this tiny little 4 B m.2 mvme Intel power with nas rocks out at $149 that is crazy cheap for an Intel powered 4bay Nook naaz and with it comes a lot of compromise I will say I guess the point I'm making is at what point when you're trying to save money does compromise actually really affect you and when I'm reviewing this I'm going to talk about all the things I didn't like all the things I liked as well but we have to frame it in that price tag there
0:47 for you again now rocking out with that n100 CPU very very recently refreshed in q1 2025 uh with the new Twin Lake version this AO Lake CPU the n10 is a quad core 4 thread processor there it also has integrated Graphics as well on board it's great for Plex we tested it all the way up to 8K implex media server and with VM deployment and it's done reasonably well for its rather efficient stature the system was arrives with support of ddr5 so dear memory and again that 149 price tag has no additional storage no additional memory it's not in there you just get the unit the CPU already put inside and you got four Bas of m.2 mvme at gen 3times one each by the way we went in with terminal via
1:33 unraid to double check that was correct to play with there down the road alongside that there's actually a fifth Bay inside there's a 2230 Bay as well which arrives with a 64 gig uh E2 m222 um 30 small drive there that 64 gig Drive in the case of the unit I've got here had the Windows installation system there so there is the opportunity of course to occupy that bay with another drive if you choose keep in mind of course it's 2230 and it's very limited in space if you're going to try to use an adapter the drive that was supplied inside this was a gen sorry Gen 2 * 1 drive at speed there so again that was a 5 Giga transfers times 1 I I tried to
2:19 find out what the limitations were to the buy because according to the official documentation I looked online on my's um Alibaba page that listed that that additional Bays also gen 3 * 1 unfortunately I don't have a 2230 SSD or an adapter to slot inside and find out so we have to trust the brand on that PDF there but nonetheless we're still coming back to 150 nicker for a four technically 5 Bay flash system so let to dig into the m.2 MVM inside this system um again as mentioned three times one on each of them so you're looking at a maximum potential 88 to 900 megabytes per second throughput on each of the drives um I will say some of you might think this is a small gripe I don't like that this system doesn't arrive with any
3:07 thermal pads it didn't have any thermal pads in the kit it arrived with a couple of extra feet to go on the base of the drive it arrived with an EXT extraction manual no English in there and it arrived with the external PSU that we'll talk about in a moment but no thermal pads yes it's time to one speed so there is a question of just how hot they're going to get and we'll get on to heat later on but nonetheless again that's one of those small areas of compromise or hurdle that shouldn't bother too many people but I did think it was worth highlighting also space is incredibly thin inside this device the drives live underneath this panel here and when we had all four drives inside the amount of space inside for the thermal pad you're going to choose to use is very small now again there's going to be the obvious
3:54 counterargument there that you want the drives to connect via the thermal pads onto the dissipating panel and you're absolutely right but what you don't want is thermal pads jelling up the vents cuz the afforded space really is quite small and when we had all four covered in thermal pads we had to use especially thin ones cuz most of the average thermal pads that I have got because remember they didn't Supply any when I put them on there completely gunged up this panel here at the bottom covering it entirely so again there is a distinction between connection with the metal chassis and over thermal pasting and ruining air flow all that said the performance numbers that I achieved on the drives inside this were pretty good
4:40 each of the drives reported around 780 to 790 megabytes per second repeated 1 gig uh tests over um SSH we're using an UNR those are read tests there so we did 100 1 gig test files then we did the same with right it dropped down to 680 685 which is quite typical I would say for the majority of n100 systems I've used so not too bad there I will say I was quite impressed with the performance of transferring data between the drives as well we achieved this low was around 390 up to about 500 megabytes per second transfer in data for one SSD to another so again all pretty impressive stuff and also keep it in mind because this has four technically 4 and a half I'm going to say m.2 mvme inside you could occupy one of those perhaps with an m.2 to
5:26 10gbe adapter there again you would be limited to about 800 mix You' never fully saturate the 10g but it is an option you have but if you did that you wouldn't be able to operate the system with that panel there on the top now let's talk about power consumption when we had the system running with two windows 11 11 VMS and active processes on both of the drives we saw reported numbers of around 28 to 29 wat power utilization that's pretty impressive for the amount that we were battering for drives and running the CPU way above 50 to 60% now when it came to idle that was with the array dismounted in unraid we still had a single 2.5 gig connection inside but the CPU idle nothing really going on and all the drives just off the array we got it down to around 12 to 13
6:13 Watts so again pretty nice numbers I know some of you don't really like uh seeing idle numbers in the double figures but again it's got 4 M do2s even in idle they're still going to be sat there so I was happy with what I saw and the system arrives with a 60 W Barrel PSU would have liked to have seen USBC but again much like I've repeated throughout this video at this price point it makes it very hard to overtly criticize when they really have paired things to the Bone to keep this as affordable as possible in terms of ports and connections I will say they've clammed a lot into this and again not withstanding the price point I've dealt with a lot of DIY nases in the last 12 18 months that have arrived with this CPU that haven't included this many
7:00 ports and connections on the front panel we have three USB 3.2 Gen 2 10 gig Connections in type A and type c and on the rear of the device we have not only two more usb2 ports there but we also arrive with two * 2.5 GB ethernet ports and a display port and a HDMI output there at 4K 60 frames per second inside there's even another USB located inside which you could use for a compact USB B for your UNR install this is actually giving quite a lot more than a lot of the n100 nazes that I talked about on the channel that have arrived at 250 299 maybe even 350 and given there's an n350 uh n305 version of this rocking out
7:47 as well very soon I've got to say that in terms of connectivity this device does very well even if you didn't factor in that price point however we got to Circle back to some of those compromises within that price point number one and again this is going to sound really really Petty but the installation inside this is just whack I don't installing a sodum memory slot in this required way too much disassembly and the while all the components are stacked inside makes it very very difficult to do a lot of troubleshooting and in terms of highy and M uh DIY uh maintenance on this device you shouldn't be doing that regularly anyway but I don't like that installing um you know upgrades
8:34 installing storage media in this it didn't feel smooth I get it 149 compromise blah blah blah blah blah blah but nonetheless just be aware to be very delicate if you get one of these for yourself when installing your memory when installing your drive media cuz the way the component Arrangement inside this has been done it's very easy to disconnect to ribbon cable and speak to anyone who's ever tried to reconnect those with e if it is not smooth but this leads me to probably my biggest criticism about this device during the course of my reviewing and testing and that is much like us politics right now this thing's getting very hot very quickly what do I mean by that well even when I had the system set up with four drives in idle booting it for the very
9:20 first time just going in to the Windows installation I hadn't done anything I hadn't installed anything I wasn't doing anything this thing was sat at 44 to 45° now that's not outlandishly high but I haven't done anything on the device and it was already a slightly higher than I would have liked temp now keep in mind that was when the top of this device has an active cooling fan beat uh on top of the CPU you can see the vents there at the top those vents lead into a small laptop style calling fan that keep the CPU running C in this rather compact But Metal dissipating chassis there and it was obviously drawing as much heat as
10:07 it could hence why the external chassis was getting warm with our thermal images again shout out again to hick micro and that thermal camera they lend us but I don't like how hot this got and when I was running some of the performance testing and running the VMS that got way too warm it got into the 60s very very quickly there now that's not necessar necessarily a deal breaker obviously I was stress testing this I was hitting this quite hard in a way that a number of you might not but I would not feel comfortable with this device outside of an open air not in an open air environment I would want this in a nice open air environment near a window I'd like it somewhere cool I'd like it somewhere where active airf flow can keep things running cuz we are talking about four m.2 MVM that are faced down
10:54 with no cooling underneath there and again there's the rubber feet you can use but this will only raise this I think barely a millimeter maybe two so keep that in mind that one of the biggest compromises I could find at this price point which is still nonetheless impressive is that in terms of thermal management this thing has got a lot more work to do
11:52 as I mentioned in the introduction it's incredibly difficult to criticize a device harshly at this price point I can give you you know a public service announcement that if you go for this keep in mind that is priced that way for a reason and list all of the things that I found that I did not gel with but nonetheless this is giving you a base level experience of a 4 Bay 4 and a half Bay flash Nas system at 150 that you just can't find anywhere else online and you'll be paying close to double this price tag for the similar level of Hardware elsewhere and that is the main thing about the m1s it is designed to be an affordable flash system is it perfect F no this thing is you know barely
12:40 tipping into the side of good but once you factor in and look at it in the profile of that price tag and if you want to Cluster a few of these or you want to use one of these alongside a larger Dumber storage array so the storage array maybe like that unraid unaz thing and you want to run containers or VMS or the most compact mobile home Plex Media Server for 4 8K you're going to need in that framework this thing is beyond beautiful but let me know what you guys think in the comments the written review should hopefully be finished soon and linked below over on NAS Compares if you're thinking of buying this device and if you found this video helpful make sure those two things are true please use the links in the description to get a hold of one for yourself over on uh I believe
13:25 Amazon AliExpress and Alibaba will be linked below again make sure those things are true don't buy if you're not happy thank you so much for watching and I will see you next time
