Brief Summary
This video examines the durability of the iPhone 17 Pro's anodised aluminium camera plateau, specifically focusing on the sharp corners. It highlights that these corners are vulnerable to chipping and wear due to the thinness of the anodised coating at these points. While the flat surfaces of the plateau are scratch-resistant, the sharp edges are prone to cosmetic damage from everyday objects like coins and keys.
- Sharp corners on the iPhone 17 Pro's camera plateau are susceptible to chipping.
- Anodising is thin and weak at sharp corners, making them vulnerable to damage.
- Everyday objects like coins and keys can cause cosmetic damage to these corners.
- The damage is purely cosmetic and does not affect the phone's functionality.
The Achilles Heel of Anodising
The video begins by explaining that the sharp corners on the iPhone 17 Pro's camera plateau are the weakest points of the anodised coating. This is because there isn't enough aluminium substrate at these sharp corners to securely hold the aluminium oxide in place. The presenter notes that the steep, unchamfered edge that Apple has created is particularly vulnerable. He then tests the corner's resistance by rubbing the phone on a table, which doesn't cause any immediate damage.
Everyday Wear and Tear
The presenter simulates everyday wear and tear by placing the phone in a pocket with a coin. While the flat anodised surface resists scratches, the sharp corner of the camera plateau immediately shows signs of wear. The anodised coating is rubbed off, exposing the bare aluminium underneath. The same test is repeated with keys, yielding similar results: the keys scratch the corner of the camera plateau, removing the anodised layer, while the flat surfaces remain unscathed.
Microscopic Examination and Design Flaws
A microscopic view reveals that the anodised coating is intact everywhere except for the damaged corner, where the silver aluminium shines through. The presenter suggests that the deep blue anodising may be even more prone to this type of damage. He reiterates that while the flat surface of the plateau is scratch-resistant, the lack of a radius or curve on the corner makes it vulnerable. This design choice, he argues, will likely lead to cosmetic damage over time because the anodising doesn't adhere well to sharp corners. The presenter finds it surprising that Apple would overlook this issue, given that it's a well-known phenomenon with established international standards for anodising sharp corners.
Cosmetic Damage and Final Thoughts
The video shows an example of a blue camera shelf where a significant portion of the anodising near the edge has sheared off. Despite this, the presenter expresses his appreciation for the new iPhone design, particularly the increased use of aluminium over glass for improved durability. He emphasises that the chipping is purely cosmetic and won't affect the phone's functionality. He concludes by reassuring viewers that if they experience this type of damage, it's not their fault or their imagination, but rather a consequence of Apple's design choice, as anodising simply doesn't adhere well to sharp corners.
