Benarkah Tasawuf Itu Sesat dan Bid'ah [BEDAH MASALAH]

Brief Summary

The video addresses the question of whether Sufism can be practiced and whether it is considered deviant or heretical. It explains that Sufism, as an effort to cleanse the heart and mind by following the Prophet's Sunnah (Sharia Sufism), is acceptable. However, Sufism that involves rituals not exemplified by the Prophet is considered heretical. The video emphasizes the importance of adhering to the practices of the Prophet Muhammad and orienting worship towards purifying the heart.

  • Sharia Sufism involves cleansing the heart and mind by following the Prophet's Sunnah.
  • Heretical Sufism includes rituals not exemplified by the Prophet.
  • Acts of worship exemplified by the Prophet are oriented towards purifying the heart.

Introduction to Sufism

The video begins by addressing the question of whether Sufism can be practiced and if it is considered deviant or heretical. The speaker explains that the permissibility of practicing Sufism depends on its form. If Sufism is an effort to cleanse the heart and mind by following the Prophet's Sunnah, it is considered Sharia Sufism, which is acceptable.

Sharia Sufism

Sharia Sufism, as explained by the late Buya Hamka, is derived from the word "sofi," meaning clean or holy. It involves practices that purify the mind, heart, speech, and behavior. Examples include performing Tahajud and Duha prayers, reading the Quran, listening to religious advice, and avoiding gossip, slander, and provocation in conversations.

Heretical Sufism

Heretical Sufism involves rituals not exemplified by the Prophet Muhammad. An example is praying all night while shaking one's head until becoming unconscious, with the belief that it signifies meeting God. The speaker emphasizes that the Prophet never engaged in such practices, distinguishing between Islamic Sufism and Bidi Sufism.

Purification of the Soul

All acts of worship exemplified by the Prophet are oriented towards Sufism, which is the purification of the soul. According to the Prophet, sins are forgiven between prayers, between Ramadan observances, and between Fridays. Attending religious assemblies erases sins, and giving zakat, infaq, and alms cleanses wealth. Sufism is essentially an effort to cleanse the heart, mind, and soul through practices aligned with the Prophet's teachings.

Practices to Avoid

The speaker cautions against engaging in deeds not exemplified by the Prophet, such as Sufi recitations accompanied by music and bodily contortions, which are considered heretical. It is important not to generalize that all Sufism is heresy or misguided. Instead, one must clarify the specific practices involved.

Conclusion: Identifying True Sufism

The speaker concludes by distinguishing between misguided Sufism and Sharia-compliant Sufism, which aligns with the Sunnah of the Prophet. Practices such as performing Tahajud prayers and reading the Quran after the Subuh prayer are examples of Sufism. As long as one stays within the practices exemplified by the Prophet and aims to cleanse the heart, thoughts, speech, and behavior, it is considered Sharia Sufism.

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the Apple Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

Full transcript of “Benarkah Tasawuf Itu Sesat dan Bid'ah [BEDAH MASALAH]”. Click a timestamp to open the video at that moment. Need another video? Use the YouTube transcript generator.

0:00 [Music] Assalamualaikum, Ustaz. Waalaikumsalam warahmatullah. Permission to ask about Sufism. Can we practice Sufism and is it true that Sufism is deviant and heretical, Ustaz? yeah it depends. So, if what you mean is that Sufism is an effort to cleanse the heart and mind by following the Prophet's sunnah, then it is

0:45 called sharia Sufism. Yes, the late Buya Hamka wrote a book on modern Sufism. In that book, he gave a very good narrative that Sufism was taken from the word saofi. Sofi means clean , holy. Well, Sufism is a practice of charity that makes our minds, our hearts, our speech, our behavior clean.

1:31 So if you do tahajud, you do duha, you read the Quran, you listen to religious advice, and when you meet friends, you always make sure that in your conversation there is no gossip, no slander, no provocation, then you are practicing Sufism. Sharia is like that. Well, secondly, there is heretical Sufism, namely Sufism in which rituals are created

2:18 that were not at all exemplified by the Prophet. For example, praying all night while shaking your head. There is no god but Allah. There is no god but Allah. Until he became unconscious, he said that meant he had reached the peak of meeting God. Well, that's wrong. It's like the Prophet never did that, right? Well, so there is Islamic Sufism, there is Bidi Sufism. Yes, Islamic Sufism. All the worship exemplified by the Prophet was oriented towards Sufism, purification of the soul. Yes, if you look at all the acts of worship

3:05 exemplified by the Prophet, then truly he was oriented towards purifying the heart. This means that according to the Prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam, Sufism means that between one prayer and the next prayer sins are forgiven. Between Ramadan and Ramadan, the following is the forgiveness of sins. Between Friday and the following Friday, the forgiveness of sins. If we come to the religious assembly, every step will erase our sins. If we give zakat, infaq, alms to cleanse our wealth. That's Sufism, right? So Sufism is an effort to cleanse. I said that Sufism was taken from the word sofi. Sofi

3:50 means clean, holy. Ah, Sufism means practices, exercises that make our hearts, minds and souls clean. So, we must be careful not to do any deeds that were never exemplified by the Prophet. There is Sufism that is recited accompanied by music, right? There's a twist in his body like that. He said that Sufism is heresy. The Prophet never exemplified such practice. That's what you call misguided Sufism. So

4:37 we cannot generalize that Sufism is heresy, that Sufism is misguided. Yes, it depends on what Sufism was like before . So we have to clarify what kind of Sufism is misguided, but there is also Sufism that is sharia which is in accordance with the Sunnah of the Prophet, that's it. Are there any of you who performed Tahajud this morning ? Well, that is the practice of Sufism. Are there any of you who read the Quran after the Subuh prayer? That's the practice of Sufism, yes. Maybe later before doing activities at Duha time we will pray Duha, that's Sufism, that's it. So as long as we are in the

5:24 area exemplified by the Prophet and the orientation is to cleanse our hearts, cleanse our thoughts, cleanse our speech, cleanse our behavior, that is sharia Sufism, yes. Only God knows. [Music]

Share

More video summaries