Marx's Theory of Alienation - Richard Wolff on Economic Update

Brief Summary

The video discusses the concept of alienation as described by Marx in "Das Capital." It explains how workers become separated from the products they create due to the capitalist system, where employers take possession of the output and control its distribution and use. This separation leads to psychological stress and a sense of loss for the worker, who is denied the ability to participate in decisions about the use of their labor. Marx argues that workers should have a say in how their work contributes to the community.

  • Workers are alienated from the products they create.
  • Employers control the distribution and use of the workers' output.
  • This alienation causes psychological stress and a sense of loss.
  • Workers should have a say in how their work benefits the community.

Introduction to Alienation

The video introduces the concept of alienation, which refers to the feeling of being separated from something. Marx discusses this concept in "Das Capital," focusing on the experience of workers in a capitalist system. When workers put their effort and skills into producing something, they expect to have some control over what happens to it.

The Worker's Loss

The video explains that at the end of the workday, the employer takes possession of what the worker has produced. The worker is then sent home without any say in what happens to their output. This separation from their creation is a crucial point, as the employer decides where the product goes, to whom it goes, and for what purpose it is used, excluding the worker from these decisions.

Psychological Impact

The video draws an analogy to a child losing a toy in a sandbox to illustrate the sense of loss experienced by workers. Unlike the child, however, the adult worker receives no comfort and must accept this disconnection as part of the system. This alienation from their own product is painful and psychologically stressful.

The Question of Control

The video raises the question of why workers are not in charge of deciding what happens to the products they create. Marx argues that workers should have a say in how their labor is used to strengthen the community. The current system allows a small minority, the employers, to take the workers' output and do whatever they want with it, which results in a loss that affects the worker's personality.

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

Full transcript of “Marx's Theory of Alienation - Richard Wolff on Economic Update”. Click a timestamp to open the video at that moment. Need another video? Use the YouTube transcript generator.

0:00 I want to get to an idea that is covered by the word "alienation." Alienation in the sense of being separate from something. Alienated from it. Marx has a wonderful discussion in his "Das Capital" about all this, and I can summarize it. It's a dense summary, I apologize for that, but I can summarize it as follows. Something happens to a human being when you pour your brains, your muscles, into producing something. You're a worker. You make a beautiful object, you make a service that really helps people, whatever it is. And then something happens at the end of the day. It's five o'clock, you're done for the day,

0:47 and then something happens which you may not think is important but Marx says it's crucial. Because of the relationship between the employer and the employee (that boss / worker relationship that is full of struggle) the capitalist takes from you what you produced, and tells you, "Go home. You're done here. Go home, eat something, sleep, and come back tomorrow, do it all again." But what you've produced is taken from you. It's alienated from you. And someone else who didn't work with you to produce it will decide what happens to it: where it goes, to whom it goes,

1:33 for what purpose it is used. That's none of your affair. There the employer is going to take it, sell it, make money off of it, and you're not involved. This is, for the adult, something like the little lesson learned by the three-year-old in the sandbox when another child comes over and snatches your doll, or your truck, and takes it away and you discover loss. And you're gonna have to come to terms with it, maybe bursting out crying, maybe needing to be comforted by the adults in your life, and so on. But when you're an adult no one comforts you. It's the way the system works and you become disconnected from your own product,

2:23 from something you've poured yourself into. And that is painful, and that is psychologically stressful, and it's one of the ways that the capitalist system (Marx argues) affects your psychology through this struggle. Why aren't the workers (Marx asks) in charge of the disposition of what they have made? That's part of what work ought to be. That's part of what a human being needs to complete the work he or she has done: to be part of the decision of how to use it, how to make the community stronger by virtue of what you have added to it through your labor. And breaking that down, making a small

3:16 unaccountable minority (the dictators inside the enterprise, the employer) have them take your output, take your work, and do whatever they want with it is a loss to you. And that loss ramifies inside your personality. And Marx says all that in poetic language.

Share

More video summaries