Brief Summary
The video discusses the potential future of "Doctor Who" novel adaptations by Big Finish, following the release of "Goth Opera." It explores which Virgin New Adventures and Virgin Missing Adventures novels are most likely to be adapted, considering factors like writer availability, story appeal, and rights issues. The video suggests "Human Nature" as the most promising candidate due to its popularity and connection to the TV series, with "Blood Harvest" and "The Scales of Injustice" as other strong possibilities. The ultimate decision hinges on the sales performance of "Goth Opera."
- "Goth Opera" success is crucial for future novel adaptations.
- "Human Nature" is highlighted as the most likely next adaptation.
- Rights issues and writer interest are key factors in selection.
Intro
The video begins by addressing the uncertainty surrounding future "Doctor Who" novel adaptations by Big Finish, despite the successful release of "Goth Opera." The author emphasizes that the continuation of these adaptations depends heavily on the sales performance of "Goth Opera," which will determine if Big Finish sees enough value in pursuing further adaptations.
Unlikely Adaptations
The video rules out the possibility of adapting any BBC books due to rights issues, making it unlikely for past Doctor Adventures, Doctor Adventures, and new series books to be adapted. The author sets aside personal preferences to focus on realistic possibilities, emphasizing quality over quantity with a limit of one release per year. The goal is to remain faithful to the original material while appealing to new listeners unfamiliar with the Virgin New Adventures or Missing Adventures.
Virgin New Adventures
The video assesses the Virgin New Adventures for potential adaptation. The author expresses doubt about adapting series like Time R and CS Cradle due to their format and the impracticality of adapting only parts of a series. While acknowledging the appeal of "Exodus" and "Revelation," their connection to a series makes them less likely. The alternate time cycle Arc, featuring books like "Blood Heat," "The Dimension Riders," "The Left-Handed Hummingbird," "Conundrum," and "No Future," is considered a strong choice, offering a compelling arc for the Seventh Doctor. The author notes that writer agreement is crucial, highlighting Jim Mortimore as a potential asset.
Blood Harvest
The video discusses the possibility of adapting "Blood Harvest," acknowledging the hurdle of securing rights from Terrance Dicks' estate. Despite this challenge, it remains a viable option, especially given the success of "Goth Opera." The adaptation could alter the original continuity, as "Goth Opera" was made self-contained and didn't reference "Blood Harvest." The author places "Blood Harvest" second on the list of likely adaptations.
Human Nature
The video identifies "Human Nature" as the most likely Virgin New Adventure to be adapted. Its popularity and connection to the Tenth Doctor's story in the TV series make it highly appealing. The author notes that Paul Cornell, who wrote "Human Nature," is happy to do these adaptations. While "Happy Endings," also by Cornell, is considered, it lacks the broad appeal needed for a successful adaptation. "So Vile a Sin" is mentioned as a possibility only if Big Finish decides to continue the Chris and Roz box sets.
Lumaro
The video addresses the possibility of adapting "Lumaro," stating that it is unlikely due to Mark Platt's lack of interest. Despite its controversial reputation and cult following, Platt's disinterest, dating back to 2015 and 2016, seems to be the primary obstacle. The author acknowledges that adapting "Lumaro" would likely be commercially successful.
Virgin Missing Adventures
The video shifts focus to the Virgin Missing Adventures, deeming adaptations of the "plotters" unlikely due to Gareth Roberts' involvement. A reference to Grant Marker in "The Quinn Dilemma" is noted, suggesting a potential adaptation of "Time of Your Life" and "Killing Ground" if Steve Lyons is willing. "The Scales of Injustice" is highlighted as a strong contender, especially with Daisy Ashford now playing the role of Liz Shaw. The author considers it a "no-brainer," given Gary Russell's involvement and the story's quality. "The Sands of Time" is also mentioned due to Sutehk's return in the TV series.
Final Thoughts
The video concludes by ranking the most likely adaptations: "Human Nature" at number one, followed by "Blood Harvest" and "The Scales of Injustice." The author reiterates that the future of these adaptations depends on the sales performance of "Goth Opera." Positive reviews are a good sign, but the possibility remains that "Goth Opera" could be a one-off celebration.
