Brief Summary
This video explores why "A Goofy Movie" is not only a nostalgic favorite but also a surprisingly sophisticated musical film. It examines the film's clever use of musical numbers to advance the plot and develop characters, comparing it to other Disney Renaissance films and highlighting its unique strengths. The video argues that the film's structure, character motivations, and integration of music into its cartoonish world make it a standout in the Disney catalog.
- The film uses musical numbers to establish the world, reveal character motivations, and drive the plot forward.
- Goofy functions as the antagonist, with his "villain song" highlighting his obstruction of Max's goals.
- The film's cartoonish setting allows for a seamless integration of musical numbers, enhancing the narrative.
- The movie's themes of compromise and mutual understanding are communicated through its musical structure.
- The film's dated artifacts and musical sophistication contribute to its nostalgic appeal and enduring quality.
Intro
The video introduces "A Goofy Movie" as a film that is not only enjoyable but also surprisingly well-crafted. The video aims to explain why the film has experienced a resurgence in popularity and why it stands out as a remarkable piece of cinema. The video posits that "A Goofy Movie" is built to be a nostalgic experience and is possibly one of the best Disney films ever made.
The Establishing Number
The video discusses the importance of the opening musical number, "After Today," in establishing the world and characters of "A Goofy Movie." It draws parallels to other Disney Renaissance films and their opening numbers, such as "Belle" from Beauty and the Beast, which serves multiple functions by introducing the setting, the protagonist's desires, and the antagonist. "After Today" effectively introduces Max's desire to impress Roxanne and escape his father's shadow, functioning as both an establishing number and Max's "I want" song. The video emphasizes that this makes the film structurally stronger than many other Disney films.
How to Stand Out
The video analyzes the song "Stand Out" and its role in the film's narrative. It contrasts "A Goofy Movie" with "Home on the Range," where only the villain sings, highlighting the importance of characters being integrated into the musical structure. Max lip-syncing to Powerline's "Stand Out" reinforces his desire to be noticed by Roxanne, serving as a secondary "I want" song. This technique of using a song to clarify a character's motivations is unique within the Disney catalog.
This Is a Cartoon
The video explores how the film's setting in a cartoon world enhances its musical numbers. Unlike other animated films that adhere to some level of realism, "A Goofy Movie" exists in a world where anything can happen, similar to the old Silly Symphonies. This allows the musical numbers to blend seamlessly into the narrative without questioning their possibility. The video argues that "On the Open Road" functions as Goofy's villain song, detailing how he is obstructing Max's life and desires, making Goofy the antagonist of the film.
Silence
The video discusses the absence of musical numbers after "Lester's Possum Park" and the fight between Max and Goofy. This silence mirrors a similar choice made in "Mulan" to draw attention to the emotional weight of the story. The lack of music highlights the tension and conflict between Max and Goofy, emphasizing the seriousness of their situation before they reach a compromise.
Compromise
The video analyzes the song "Nobody Else But You" as a love song between a father and son, highlighting the theme of compromise. It contrasts this with the final song, "Eye to Eye," which demonstrates the success of their compromise. Max and Goofy both get their way through mutual respect and communication, a more nuanced resolution than typical Disney films. The musical structure of these numbers reinforces the message of understanding and compromise.
Nostalgic Time Bomb
The video concludes by explaining why "A Goofy Movie" has become a nostalgic favorite. The film's musical sophistication, combined with its dated artifacts and themes of family and compromise, resonates with audiences who have grown up with Disney musicals. The film's ability to tell a developed story through its music, packaged in a relatable narrative, makes it better than many remember.
