Your Notes Aren't Helping You Learn. Here's Why.

Odysseas www.youtube.com

Краткое содержание

В видео обсуждаются аспекты эффективного ведения заметок и их значение для обучения. Обсуждаются основные ошибки, которые могут помешать продуктивности, и предлагаются советы для улучшения процесса.

  • Не все заметки равны.
  • Заметки — это средство, а не цель.
  • Важно выбирать правильные книги для заметок.
  • Нужно периодически удалять устаревшие заметки.
  • Организация заметок важна для усвоения.
  • Создайте систему для повторного изучения.
  • Не забывайте о свободном мышлении.

Заметки = copium?

Автор делится своим мнением о ведении заметок, ссылаясь на известных философов, таких как Сократ и Монтень, которые критиковали зависимость от записей. Несмотря на это, он утверждает, что ведение заметок полезно для обучения, если правильно подходить к процессу и избегать распространенных ошибок.

Не все заметки равны

Обсуждаются две основные категории заметок: вербатим и генеративные. Первый тип подразумевает переписывание источников, что не всегда способствует пониманию. Второй тип требует переработки идеи своими словами, что улучшает усвоение материала и помогает лучше его понять.

Заметки — это средство, а не цель

Автор подчеркивает, что ведение заметок не является концом саморазвития, а лишь инструментом для мышления и обучения. Он предостерегает от метаний между идеальными записями и реальным усвоением знаний, акцентируя внимание на том, что заметки должны быть временными и помогать в процессе раздумий.

Правильные книги

Автор рекомендует выбирать книги, действительно заслуживающие внимания, такие как классические произведения, которые формировали западную мысль. Он подчеркивает важность качественного содержания заметок и их связь с глубокими концепциями.

Удаляйте заметки

Необходимо Delete старые заметки, так как они могут стать нерелевантными по мере роста и изменений в личной жизни. Удаление поможет освободить пространство для более актуальной информации, вместо хранения устаревшего материала.

Организация имеет значение

Эффективная организация заметок помогает лучше усваивать сложные темы и сохранять порядок в информации. Приведены примеры создания структур и схем, которые помогают визуализировать связи между идеями и концепциями.

Система пересмотра

Автор подчеркивает важность повторного изучения заметок для поддержания их актуальности. Применяются психологические концепции, такие как эффект Зейгарника, чтобы объяснить, как незавершенные задачи остаются в памяти, и приводит способы, как можно лучше взаимодействовать с прошлыми заметками.

Не забывайте о свободном мышлении

Обсуждается необходимость предоставления себе времени для осмысления идей, а не просто записи информации. Автор предостерегает от чрезмерного количества заметок, так как это может привести к фальшивой продуктивности, когда идеи не развиваются и не переходят в практическое применение.

Краткое содержание любого видео YouTube за секунды

Получайте такие пересказы для любого видео на своём языке в бесплатном приложении Summ.

Загрузите в App Store
Доступно в Google Play

Расшифровка

Полная расшифровка видео «Your Notes Aren't Helping You Learn. Here's Why.». Нажмите на таймкод, чтобы открыть видео с этого момента. Нужно другое видео? Воспользуйтесь генератором расшифровки YouTube.

0:00 I love note taking, but a lot of it is And I'm not alone in saying that, because there's so many famous thinkers and philosophers who criticized the act of writing. For example, in Plato's Phaedrus, Socrates tells a story of these students who rely too much on their notes. How they are doomed to be hearers of many things while having learned nothing. They have the show of wisdom, but without the reality. And if we turn to Michel de Montaigne, the essay guy, he describes how we only labor to stuff the memory and leave the conscious and the understanding unfurnished and void. And in 2026, nothing's changed. We mock the PKM second brain cultists, and maybe for good reason. Because modern note taking feels more like a neurotic circle jerk rather than a

0:46 real education. And you know, maybe this is how Linux users feel all this time. I kind of understand the racism they have to go through. But look, in all seriousness, note taking is still worth it. Obviously. I mean, even these famous figures, despite their criticisms, they still wrote. And the research today shows that note taking is invaluable for your learning. It all just depends on how you approach it. And of course, if you can avoid the common mistakes that, you know, maybe feel productive, but will screw you over in the long run. So, coming up, I have six tips to make note taking truly productive without all of the nonsense and wasted effort. And look, some of these I borrowed from my philosopher friends from earlier. Why I'm saying friends? That's so sad. No, I borrowed them from the philosophers from earlier. And others, I've just picked them up

1:32 through my own experience, jumping through systems, trying new things, making lots of mistakes, so you don't have to do it the hard way. First up is that not all notes are equal. Now, from what I've read, the research splits them into two broad types. And it could be the case that if you're writing loads and you're still not understanding or remembering anything, well, it could be that you're focusing too much on the verbatim style of notes, which arguably is the inferior of the two. Now, before we get to the better one, what is the verbatim style? Well, this is where you take direct clippings of the source material. You pluck out quotes, you copy passages, you copy paste, you you do things word for word. And listen, I do this. There's a time and place for it. You know, sometimes I want to take a quote that's punchy, or I want to, you

2:17 know, steal a passage and use it as an example of something else, or I don't know, maybe the passage is is just aesthetically pleasing. It's cinema, and I want to copy it out. But the research shows that on its own, it's just not good enough, at least in most cases. Because ultimately, you are copying, and you're not thinking. You can pick out something that sounds important, but can you explain it? Can you truly understand what is being transmitted to you? That's another story. And you don't need a paper to understand that, it's just kind of obvious. It's like calling yourself an artist when you trace a portrait. I mean, sure, but if I remove the portrait and ask you to reproduce it yourself, you can't. You get kicked out of art school, and we all know what happens

3:03 when you get kicked out of art school. One thing leads to another. This is why the best note-taking stresses the generative style. This is where you take ideas from somewhere and transform them. You give them your own words, you give them commentary, you elaborate on them, you draw diagrams, you create, you know, mind maps. You visualize it in a way that no one else can, in a way that is unique to you. Because you're creating something, it forces you to truly integrate what you read. There's no hiding. You have to face it head-on and be able to prove to yourself that you've understood something. And if you do it with pencil or pen, even better. Because there is evidence to show that this, you know, it slows down your thinking, it allows for deeper processing, better attention, I think. And the lads I mentioned earlier, they

3:49 back me here. Because Seneca, in letter 84, for example, he likened our learning to bees. They flit about and cull the flowers that are suitable for producing honey, and then arrange and assort in themselves all that they have brought in. He says we should copy these bees, that we should gather from many different sources, and that we should blend those several flavors into one delicious compound, aka some new commentary of your own, something that you can call your understanding. And that is done through the generative note-taking style. Just be yourself. And that leads us nicely to the next point, which is something that most people in the note-taking sphere don't seem to understand, and it pisses me off. I say that like there's a official rulebook or a canon. There isn't, but whatever.

4:36 Point is note-taking is not the end of knowledge. It's not the ultimate goal. It's the means. It's the method in which you get there. Let me explain that. Now, people will spend hours making these perfect museums of their notes with all the tags and links and colors and fancy properties and displays, whatever. Now, that's fine, but not when you spend more time doing that than actually thinking, than learning, which is the entire point of this. You do not spend so much time writing notes so that you can add one more note to the pile and and keep piling them up over the hours and days and years. No. You write notes so that you can think. They are an outlet for your ideas and your reflection. And yes, I'm not saying that you should scraggle your notes out like

5:21 a toddler. Because yeah, you're going to use these in the future. You want them to be nice. You want your writing to be polished. But at the same time, they're not the end product. The end product is up here. It's the wisdom and knowledge you will walk away with. Think of it like the sketch of an artist. An artist may produce thousands of sketches in their lifetime, and many of them I'm sure will be beautiful, but many of them will go straight to the the Gone immediately. And to second brain Steven over here, he might be outraged. He might see that as sacrilege. No, how dare you destroy something you produced? And it's like, no, the sketch is not the end product. It's not what we're aiming for. It's the byproduct of the process. It's an arena for practice, for

6:07 reflection, for honing skills that will ultimately lead up to the bigger picture, maybe a a project they're working on. And I see notes as sketches. Yes, maybe I'll use some one day, but most of them they really are just temporary outlets for my thoughts. And they are a way for me to practice what I've learned, to revise things, to think about something more deeply than if they were just stuck in my head. And actually, tip number three is going to help you apply this piece of advice, because you know, I get it. It's difficult. I'm a hoarder. I like to keep things, but we have to get over it at some point. Now, good notes are meaningless unless they come from insightful books that truly deserve your time. The Right Books, today's video partner, has you covered there. They curate the most impactful books of history, of

6:53 politics, of philosophy, and the classics. The books that have shaped Western thought for thousands of years. Think Nietzsche, Spengler, Evola, Homer. The list goes on. Now, I can't show everything here, but you will also find books that you won't find anywhere else. Certainly not in the banned book section of your local bookstore. The Right Books gives you unfiltered access to the confusing, the controversial, the intellectually challenging, and you are left to evaluate them for yourself, which I appreciate. [snorts] Many of these books are also rare primary sources, which is great for my history fans out there. The catalog is constantly growing, so have a browse for yourself. Click the link in the description or scan the QR code on screen. And if you use code Odysseus at checkout, you'll get a nice 10% off. So, thank you to The Right Books, and I hope you enjoy. Now, earlier I mentioned that notes are not the end goal, but to means

7:39 of getting there. And that comes with a harsh but important step that I put off for ages, and I don't want you to get stuck in that same hole. You need to delete notes more often. Oh, I know. [snorts] I know. It's like strangling a puppy. It's like crushing its neck and, you know, seeing all the life come out of its eyes. It's horrible. I hate deleting notes. I feel like I put so much effort into them, and I want to keep them, and now you're asking me to delete them. Yes. Seriously. Because the thing is, you change and grow. You're a person, but your notes don't. Your notes are a static snapshot of the past, of who you once were. They are, you know, in a way, a museum of your interests, all the rabbit holes you dived into. They don't represent the

8:25 new, current you. And just like anything old and forgotten, they become irrelevant. You forget about them. They don't represent you. They don't speak for you. They don't resonate with you anymore. And that is why we have to shed them sometimes. We have to kill them. Kill your darlings. And a lot of these old, decaying notes, they're not necessarily meaningless, but a lot of them are just obvious to you now. You know, for example, I used Obsidian in the early days to learn about writing. I wrote about writing, ironically. And I would, you know, pick up the theory, the techniques, the grammar, the, you know, different prose techniques, and all that. And going back to read them now, I I just think, like, yeah, no This is obvious to me. And, of course, it wasn't at the time, but after years

9:11 and years of practicing and integrating things, it's like, I don't need this note anymore. I don't need a note to tell me how to use a semicolon, or, you know, when to or how to describe something with emotion. It's like, I I know how to do that. So, I think that as you grow as a person and move on in life, your notes should reflect that. They should evolve with you, or be left in the past. And you should willfully cut them off and leave them there. Deleting them more often will clean up your massive pile. It will give you some breathing room. It will make your notes collection focus more on quality rather than quantity. And above all, it will keep things relevant. It will be who you are now, not who you were 5 years ago. Now, if this is still too far, you know, I

9:57 understand deleting notes it hurts. It's hard. Well, luckily you have two alternatives. First, you can archive them. You can instead of deleting them for good, you can create a separate folder or drive or something and put them there. So, they are out of the way. They're gone, but they're not gone forever. Now, fair enough, that actually makes more sense. But, I don't know. I feel like this is a low aura half measure. You are not committing to it, you know. You just have to You have to commit to it. You have to put the the boot down and say, you know what, you're gone. You're you're done. Delete it. Okay, that's just me, but it is wiser, in fairness. The second alternative is to update your notes. Now, some notes are old, but not because they are no longer interesting, but because

10:42 they are underdeveloped or immature. They just don't have enough information or they haven't, you know, captured something new that you've learned, whatever. And here, you will not delete it, but you will actually just edit it. You will add to it. You will update it. You will refresh it. You will maybe rewrite it completely. And that way, your notes will technically be deleted. You're deleting an old version, but you're giving it a fresh breath of life. And it was it's more current. It's more useful to you now. And look, sometimes it's nice to see your history of thought. You read notes from a few years ago and you think, man, I was And I probably will think the same thing about myself today. And it puts you in your place. It makes you feel nice and small in the world. You know, I don't know much, but that's fine. I'm growing, you know. It's a good

11:27 experience. It's almost meditative. So, maybe don't delete your past notes, just add something new to them. See the different versions of yourself throughout time. Isn't that cool? Either way, the overall point is to see your notes not as a static bank of interests or whatever ideas, but as a growing organism that evolves with you, that sheds old things and gives birth to new ones. Huh, it's a bit of a creepy example, but yeah, it makes sense. Now, earlier I said that too much planning and organization is a detriment. And that's true. But it can also be a good thing. Sometimes the organization of your notes is just as good for your learning as the writing itself. And I know that sounds like a cope or I'm backtracking. It's

12:12 not, I promise you. Let me explain. If you are writing a lot about a complicated topic that is very specific, it can get overwhelming fast. You know, like philosophy, politics, whatever. There are so many different perspectives and angles and, you know, evaluations of the same thing that you write a lot and you just lose track of the conversation. You don't understand where it's going. Every, you know, every answer opens 50 more questions. It's a mess. And to navigate this mess and to almost give myself a bird's-eye view of these notes, I like to create a super structure. So, for example, and I know I bang on about this a lot, but I was reading about fascism recently. And this is, you know, a complex topic, lots of debate. It gets messy. And so, to help me understand how all of

12:57 these ideas fit together, ideas which I wrote from the book, I created an index with subheaders, descriptions, uh, you know, tags, links. And this allowed me to mentally categorize every single idea and how they relate to each other. And it made me sort of apply a linear structured order to what was otherwise very chaotic and scattered. And this is my in- index. It's not something I asked AI to make. I didn't steal it from the author. It's something I had to form out of nothing. And that act that act of organization is very difficult and it makes you think and it makes you have to justify why this note belongs here. Why does this belong there?

13:44 And you know, it can be boring, I admit, but it's so good for your thinking and your overall understanding of the topic as a whole. And it doesn't have to be, you know, some boring index. I'll be honest, a bit dry. You could do a long-form essay that brings in many different ideas and gives them some sort of flowing logical narrative. You could do mind maps that connect many different things. You could do you know, you can go full schizo and get a cork board, get the thumb tacks, the strings, print stuff, you know, attach them, connect them. Whatever works for you. But the point is to take this big topic, this scattered mess, and give it order. Give it structure. Give it authority. And not authority. Be the authority. And that way you will understand it better. Just don't spend too much time

14:30 on this. You also need to write and, you know, read. It's not just sorting stuff out. Also, I don't know if you've heard, but the newsletter is back. Sign up down below. It's totally free and I am posting regularly again, I promise. I will not let you down again. I'm experimenting with different topics, different, you know, themes that you will not see here on YouTube. So, it's kind of exclusive. It's bonus content. So, have a look through it down below. Send me an email. I'll try and respond. No promises, but I'll try and respond. And then I'll see you there. Next up is something that people know they should do, but they just struggle to find out how. And by people, I mean me. This was me. You need in your notes some way to revise. And I don't mean crazy plugins. I don't mean flowcharts. I don't mean German bureaucracy. Just a simple way to resurface old

15:15 notes, give them some love, and ultimately remember them. So, they don't be they're not left in the past, forgotten, and dusty. Once again, this is a form of maintenance. You are keeping your notes fresh and relevant. But, of course, it's also good for your recollection. You know, the forgetting curve and all that. You are remembering old things that were once forgotten. There's also this concept in psychology called the Zeigarnik effect, which states that we find incomplete tasks easier to remember because they create this subtle cognitive tension in the background. And once we finish the task, once we get it out of the way, it fades from memory. And this is maybe why you feel this tension or stress at, you know, unfinished chores that are looming in

16:02 front of you. Or maybe you have something planned later that day, and you just can't get it off your mind because it's it's not finished. It's still there. It's still waiting for you. And of course, once you do it, it's gone. And I don't say this with any certainty, but it might also be why you forget everything you write, even though you put a lot of effort into it. You know, I tend to see my notes as a task to finish. You know, I'll finish this note. I'll get it out of the way. I'll file it away. Gone. It's mentally discarded. It's like it never existed. And because we rely so much on the second brain, we forget to use the first one. That complacency is inevitable, and it's hard to avoid, especially if we're talking about, you know, every day for the rest of our life. That's why you need a system to hold you accountable, a way to revise. There are many ways to implement this, and none of them are correct. So, I'm just going to

16:48 list a few here, and I want you to choose something that works for you. First, you can use a function or a plugin that just gives you random notes. I press this every now and then. I read something I haven't read in ages. It refreshes me. Simple as it gets. Second, you can use your notes in larger projects. I often scroll through my atomic notes list and use them to inspire videos or newsletters or just something I'm working on. And that means I have to re-engage with them. I have to explore them as if it's the first time. I have to add to them. I have to polish them. It helps you learn so well, trust me. Yes, it's higher foot, but it works. I recommend this one. Number three is that whenever you're writing new notes, try your absolute best to connect them to old notes. To use that as a sort of bridge to

17:33 something that you haven't read about in a while or something you wrote in the past. You will find connections and it's so satisfying when you do. Because you think, "Okay, I did this for a reason. I didn't waste my effort, but it's actually come back to help me now." Number four is something I used to do, but I don't like it anymore. And I'm just saying this in case you find it useful. You can actually add properties or tags to your notes that denote the status or the maturity level. And that way you can see what you need to work on and what maybe has enough attention and what is, you know, solid to you. There's many ways to do it. Those are just some ideas. I want you to go out and explore because ultimately what works best for you is something that only you know. Tip number six has us escape something which Schopenhauer warned us about in one of his essays. He said that when we read,

18:19 someone else thinks for us. We repeat merely his mental process. As if he goes over with his pen the strokes made in pencil by the teacher. He warns that with excess thinking, we gradually lose our ability to think for ourselves. Because there's this constant input that just blocks out thoughts. Schopenhauer related it to eating too much and never allowing time to digest it. Or maybe writing layers upon layers on top of each other on a blackboard without ever stopping to just look at it and understand it. What is it saying? I'm guilty of this in my notes. You know, atomic notes and notebooks, whatever you do, they're quite segmented and rigid. And while that's useful in some ways, it just doesn't reflect the openness and the fluidity of real life thinking. And listen, notes are a good

19:04 start. You need to write. But you're also not a monkey just born to type them away and produce a thousand of them. You need to engage and use these ideas in the real world, in debates, in you know, long-form pieces, in essays, in real conversations and real experiences, and you need to let them breathe, give them space beyond the the software you're using or the paper on the table. You also need to give yourself time to think. If you're constantly writing and watching and consuming, you never just let your brain do its work, do its best work, in fact. You never let it uh come up with ideas and process what it's taking in. Too much writing is fake productivity, because you never allow those ideas, those raw materials, to

19:51 blossom into something bigger than themselves. I talk about this more in one of my videos about how endless notes are pointless. So, if you want some methods and tips and you know, techniques for that, check it out on screen, and thank you so much for watching. I want to hear your thoughts in the comments below. Let me know what you thought. I'll get engaged in discussion, and just yeah, thank you so much for watching.

Share

Другие пересказы видео