COVID is not a racial bio-weapon (duh)

Debunk the Funk with Dr. Wilson www.youtube.com

Σύντομη Περίληψη

Το βίντεο αναλύει τους λόγους για τους οποίους ο RFK Jr δεν είναι κατάλληλος για επικεφαλής του HHS, εστιάζοντας σε μια δήλωσή του ότι ο COVID-19 είναι ένα βιολογικό όπλο που στοχεύει συγκεκριμένες φυλές. Ο Δρ. Wilson αποδομεί αυτή την ιδέα, εξηγώντας πώς ο Kennedy παρερμήνευσε μια επιστημονική μελέτη και αγνόησε άλλες έρευνες που αντικρούουν τον ισχυρισμό του.

  • Ο RFK Jr ισχυρίστηκε ότι ο COVID-19 είναι ένα βιολογικό όπλο που στοχεύει συγκεκριμένες φυλές.
  • Η δήλωση βασίστηκε σε μια παρερμηνεία μιας επιστημονικής μελέτης.
  • Άλλες μελέτες αντικρούουν τον ισχυρισμό του RFK Jr.
  • Οι φυλετικές ανισότητες στις κλινικές εκβάσεις του COVID-19 οφείλονται σε κοινωνικοοικονομικούς παράγοντες.
  • Ο RFK Jr δεν έχει την ικανότητα να διαβάζει και να ερμηνεύει σωστά την επιστημονική βιβλιογραφία.

Εισαγωγή

Ο Δρ. Wilson ξεκινά το βίντεο εξηγώντας ότι θα παρουσιάσει έναν ακόμη λόγο για τον οποίο ο RFK Jr δεν είναι κατάλληλος για τη θέση του επικεφαλής του HHS. Αυτός ο λόγος σχετίζεται με μια δήλωση που έκανε ο Kennedy σχετικά με τον COVID-19.

Η Δήλωση του RFK Jr για τον COVID-19

Στην ακρόαση επιβεβαίωσής του, ο RFK Jr ρωτήθηκε αν είχε πει ότι ο COVID-19 είναι ένα βιολογικό όπλο που στοχεύει συγκεκριμένες φυλές. Αρχικά αρνήθηκε ότι το είπε σκόπιμα, αλλά παραδέχτηκε ότι ανέφερε μια μελέτη που χρηματοδοτήθηκε από το NIH. Στη συνέχεια, παρουσιάζεται ένα απόσπασμα όπου ο Kennedy υποστηρίζει ότι ο COVID-19 στοχεύει συγκεκριμένες εθνότητες, αναφέροντας διαφορές στη γενετική δομή των υποδοχέων ACE2 μεταξύ διαφορετικών φυλών. Ισχυρίστηκε ότι οι Καυκάσιοι και οι μαύροι είναι πιο ευάλωτοι, ενώ οι Εβραίοι Ασκενάζι και οι Κινέζοι είναι πιο ανθεκτικοί.

Η Επιστημονική Βάση του Ισχυρισμού

Ο Δρ. Wilson εξηγεί ότι ο RFK Jr βασίστηκε σε μια μελέτη του 2020 με τίτλο "New insights into genetic susceptibility of covid-19 and ace2 and Tempest 2 polymorphism analysis". Αυτή η μελέτη χρησιμοποίησε ένα υπολογιστικό μοντέλο για να αναλύσει τα γονιδιώματα 81.000 ανθρώπων και να προσδιορίσει εάν τα γονίδιά τους κωδικοποιούν υποδοχείς στους οποίους ο SARS-CoV-2 θα μπορούσε να συνδεθεί πιο εύκολα. Το μοντέλο εντόπισε μεταλλάξεις που φαινόταν να συνδέονται πιο εύκολα με τον ιό, οι οποίες βρέθηκαν κυρίως σε άτομα αφρικανικής καταγωγής και μη-φινλανδούς Ευρωπαίους. Αυτές οι μεταλλάξεις δεν βρέθηκαν σε Εβραίους Ασκενάζι, κοινότητες Amish, Νοτιοασιάτες και Λατίνους.

Η Παρερμηνεία της Μελέτης από τον RFK Jr

Ο Δρ. Wilson τονίζει ότι ο RFK Jr παρερμήνευσε τη μελέτη, η οποία ήταν μια προκαταρκτική ανάλυση βασισμένη σε υπολογιστικό μοντέλο. Αυτές οι μελέτες χρησιμοποιούνται για να ενημερώσουν περαιτέρω εργαστηριακά και κλινικά πειράματα. Οι συγγραφείς της μελέτης προειδοποίησαν ότι τα αποτελέσματα υποδεικνύουν "πιθανούς συσχετισμούς" και ότι τα δεδομένα τους "μπορεί να σημαίνουν κάτι, αλλά πραγματικά δεν το γνωρίζουμε". Επιπλέον, οι μεταλλάξεις που εντοπίστηκαν ήταν εξαιρετικά σπάνιες, εμφανιζόμενες σε περίπου 0,1% του πληθυσμού, και δεν υπήρχαν στοιχεία που να υποδηλώνουν ότι μεταφράζονται σε κλινικά αποτελέσματα.

Άλλες Μελέτες που Αντικρούουν τον Ισχυρισμό

Ο Δρ. Wilson αναφέρει μια άλλη μελέτη που διεξήχθη αργότερα, η οποία περιελάμβανε εργαστηριακά πειράματα για να συμπληρώσει το υπολογιστικό μοντέλο. Αυτή η μελέτη διαπίστωσε ότι οι μεταλλάξεις που θα μπορούσαν να αυξήσουν την ευαισθησία στον SARS-CoV-2 ήταν εξαιρετικά σπάνιες και δεν συγκεντρώνονταν σε συγκεκριμένους πληθυσμούς. Αυτή η μελέτη αντικρούει άμεσα την ιδέα ότι ο COVID-19 είναι ένα βιολογικό όπλο που στοχεύει συγκεκριμένες φυλές. Επιπλέον, άλλες μελέτες έχουν δείξει ότι οι φυλετικές ανισότητες στις κλινικές εκβάσεις του COVID-19 οφείλονται κυρίως σε κοινωνικές και οικονομικές ανισότητες, όπως η πρόσβαση σε ποιοτική υγειονομική περίθαλψη.

Η Ακαταλληλότητα του RFK Jr

Ο Δρ. Wilson καταλήγει στο συμπέρασμα ότι ο RFK Jr είναι ακατάλληλος για τη θέση του επικεφαλής του HHS επειδή δεν έχει την ικανότητα να διαβάζει και να ερμηνεύει σωστά την επιστημονική βιβλιογραφία. Βλέπει κάτι που υποστηρίζει μια προκατειλημμένη ιδέα και το υιοθετεί αμέσως, χωρίς να λαμβάνει υπόψη την αλήθεια ή τα δεδομένα. Επιπλέον, ο Δρ. Wilson επισημαίνει ότι η μελέτη που ανέφερε ο Kennedy δεν ήταν μια μελέτη του NIH, αλλά μια μελέτη που χρηματοδοτήθηκε από το NIH. Αυτή η βασική παρανόηση δείχνει περαιτέρω την έλλειψη κατανόησης της επιστημονικής βιβλιογραφίας από τον Kennedy.

Επίλογος

Ο Δρ. Wilson ανακοινώνει ότι θα κάνει μια ζωντανή ροή το Σάββατο για να απαντήσει σε ερωτήσεις και να σχολιάσει από υποστηρικτές του RFK Jr.

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the Apple Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

YouTube Transcript Generator

0:00 hey I just want to make this quick video to demonstrate yet another reason why RFK Jr is unfit to serve as head of HHS so yesterday at his first confirmation hearing he was asked whether or not he has ever said that Co is a bioweapon that is racially targeted against certain races so I'm asking you yes or no Mr Kennedy did you say that covid-19 was a gen genetically engineered bioweapon that targets black and white people but spared ashkanazi Jews Chinese people I I didn't say it was deliberately targeted I just I just quoted an NIH funded an NIH uh published study this is an absolutely ridiculous idea but here's

0:45 the clip of him making an argument that this is an idea that makes sense covid-19 there's an argument that it is ethnically target covid-19 attacks certain races disproportionally the are the the races that are most IM immune to pan are because of the as the structure of he the genetic structure genetic differentials among different races of the um of The receptors of the H2 receptor um co9 is targeted to attack Caucasians and and black people the people who are most

1:33 immun are asking and and Chinese and but night we don't know that whether was deliberately targeted that or not but there are papers out there and that show the you know the the racial and ethnic differen and of impact to that like I said this is an absolutely ridiculous idea this is not true in the slightest so where is he getting this idea he's getting it from this paper that was published early in the pandemic in 2020 it's called new insights into genetic susceptibility of covid-19 and ace2 and Tempest 2 polymorphism analysis so essentially what these researchers did was they looked at the genomes of 81,000 humans and tried to determine whether or not their genes code for receptors that SARS KOB 2 might bind to more readily than

2:19 other people this was a completely ins silico based study meaning it was all done in a computer model so in other words the researchers just use a computer model to guess whether or not humans with specific mutations in The receptors that stars K2 uses to enter cells would bind stars kov to better than others and their computer model did identify mutations that the computer model thought would bind SARS K2 more readily than others and they found that these mutations cluster mostly around African people and non-finished Europeans meanwhile these mutations were found to not be present in those of ashkanazi Jewish descent or Amish community as well as South Asian and Latino populations so Robert feny Jr someone who claims to be very good at

3:06 reading and interpreting scientific data which would be an absolutely essential skill for a head of an HHS to have saw this paper and said that Co is a bioweapon used to Target black people and people of non-f finish European descent this shows that he is incompetent and not fit to serve as head of HHS it's one of many things that show that but in this case someone who is actually good at reading scientific literature and is careful about reading and interpreting the data would see this paper and immediately acknowledge that it is a computer modelbased study this is typically an early phase study that biologists will often do in order to inform Downstream experiments so they might do a computer model based experiment that could inform experiments

3:51 that could be done in a lab or in the clinic in order to narrow down a window of where they want to search for answers so speak for example if we wanted to do something like design a drug to specifically bind an enzyme that might be unique to a person's cancer we could use a computer model to design a theoretical drug that could bind that particular enzyme and then scientists could try that prediction in the lab to see if it works rather than just starting pretty much blind and trying a whole array of options that have a low likelihood of working but the absolutely crucial part is doing those laboratory or clinical experiments to actually see if the computer model got anything right

4:37 so someone reading this paper alone would have Extreme Caution in their interpretation that's why the authors themselves wrote in the paper quote this comprehensive comparative genetic analysis of approximately 81,000 human genomes suggested possible associations of A2 and tempers 2 DNA polymorphisms with covid-19 susceptibility severity and clinical outcomes especially in this context this is science be for our data might mean something but we really don't know it's also important to point out that these mutations that these authors did identify with this computer program were present in about 0.1% of the population so these mutations are not only extremely rare but they had no evidence to suggest that they actually translate to any clinical

5:22 outcomes when it comes to different races but that didn't stop Robert of Kenny Jr from treating this paper like it was reason to believe that Co was a bioweapon someone who is good at reading scientific literature and careful in interpreting the results would also look for other papers to see were these results Vindicated anywhere but this computer model and you know this clip surfaced in 2023 so he probably had enough time to read this paper human A2 receptor polymorphisms and altered susceptibility to SARS kovy 2 the researchers in this paper did similar work to the last paper but they also included some Laboratory based experiments in order to supplement and test the model that their computers were generating their results found that any

6:07 mutations that they identified that might increase susceptibility to SARS K2 were extremely rare and were not clustered among certain populations of humans so this study is directly rejecting the idea that Co is a bioweapon targeted at specific races yet Kennedy did not seem to read or even acknowledge this paper in any of what he has said about Co being a supposed bioweapon against certain races and yet more studies done even after that have further shown that any racial disparities in clinical outcomes of covid-19 were due almost entirely to structural differences in social and economic inequities including but not limited to access to Quality healthare

6:54 someone who is careful in reading and interpreting scientific literature before they communicate it to the public which would be very important in a leadership position would have read these papers and have immediately recognized that Co is not a bioweapon and would not have pushed the idea that it is one specifically targeted at specific races but that's not who Robert F Kenny Jr is he is incompetent he has no experience reading and correctly interpreting scientific literature he sees something that supports a preconceived agenda or preconceived notion and he immediately runs with it without any any regard to what the truth is or what the data actually say that is one of the many reasons why he is unfit to serve as head of HHS and it's also why if he does get confirmed we are in

7:40 for a long four years and a decline in American public health oh and one more thing that just really annoys me he said that this was an NIH study no it was not an NIH study it was funded with a grant given out by the NIH but that's not what an NIH study is the NIH has its own Labs that produce its own work and it's own studies that's an NIH study this was a study coming from scientists collaborating from places like the Cleveland clinic Columbia University and Case Western this is a basic misunderstanding that I see a lot of people who have no clue how to read scientific literature make and it just shows again that Kennedy has no idea how to read and interpret scientific literature sorry that's just another petty little thing I have to point out so yeah that's going to be it for this video I'm going to try to do a live stream this Saturday afternoon so that I

8:27 can answer questions and address comments ments from people who support RFK Jr or hear from people who are looking to inform people so it should be a fun stream call in if you want there will be information in the post coming later this week about that I'll see you in the next video and good luck to us [Music] all big the hey DRS big the

Share

YouTube Video Summaries