Premier League clubs vote to cover legal costs if Man City sponsors sue competition's board members

Sky Sports News www.youtube.com

Brief Summary

Premier League clubs voted to cover the legal costs of five league board members if they are sued personally by Manchester City sponsors Etihad Airways or Etisalat. The vote followed an independent commission’s finding that City had breached financial rules over nine seasons and entered into sham sponsorship contracts; City are appealing.

  • Eighteen clubs supported the change, while Manchester City and Nottingham Forest voted against it.
  • The new protection addresses a possible gap in the Premier League’s rules on indemnifying board members.
  • A decision on City’s appeal, and any possible sanctions if the appeal fails, was expected in the early part of the following year.

Why Premier League Clubs Voted to Protect Board Members

At a Premier League shareholders’ meeting in central London, clubs voted to cover the legal costs of the league’s five board members if they are sued individually by Manchester City sponsors. In September, an independent commission found City guilty of breaching more than 100 Premier League financial rules across nine seasons, from 2009 to 2018. The commission also found that City had entered into sham sponsorship contracts, though City are appealing the findings.

Etihad Airways and Etisalat, an Abu Dhabi-based communications company, were not named in the commission’s 40-page decision. However, both sponsors issued statements saying they were considering their options, which was understood as a possible threat of legal action. They could argue that claims of sham contracts harm their business reputations and amount to defamation.

The Premier League’s Articles of Association were not clear about whether board members would be protected if they faced personal legal claims. Clubs therefore voted to provide an indemnity—a commitment to cover legal costs—in case the chair, chief executive or non-executive directors are sued. The change passed by 18 votes to two; Manchester City and Nottingham Forest were understood to have opposed it. A two-thirds majority, or 14 clubs, was required.

The vote creates the possibility that the Premier League could use members’ contributions to defend itself against a claim brought by one of City’s sponsors. As a league member, City could therefore indirectly contribute towards the league’s legal costs, although the sponsors are separate companies. The discussion noted that this scenario remained hypothetical. The league had taken legal advice and identified a potential gap in its rules, prompting the vote to protect its board members.

City’s appeal was expected to be heard the following month, with a decision and any possible sanctions—if City lost the appeal—anticipated in January or February.

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

YouTube Transcript Generator

0:00 Um, look, let's talk about the Premier League clubs because they met, didn't they, today? All of them? Did they meet all in central London? >> complicated story to another complicated story. >> were they talking about? >> was a Premier League shareholders meeting this morning in central London, and Premier League clubs have voted to cover the legal costs of their five board members if they are sued individually by Manchester City's sponsors. Of course, you know that in September an independent commission found City guilty of breaking more than a hundred of the Premier League's financial rules across nine seasons. City are appealing uh after the commission found they'd entered into sham contracts with their sponsors. Now, two of their sponsors, Etihad Airways and Etisalat, a Abu Dhabi

0:47 headquartered communications company, have threatened the Premier League with legal action because even though they weren't named in the 40-page decision, if you're accusing Manchester City of having entered into sham contracts, then the companies they have contracts with can argue, well, you're defaming us because you're accusing us of signing sham contracts. Now, at the meeting today, clubs voted by 18 to two to provide the five board members with this indemnity in case they're sued individually in any potential defamation suits. Now, we understand City and Nottingham Forest were the two clubs who voted against.

1:34 And to change the Premier League's rules, you need a two-thirds majority, so 14 clubs to vote in favor of something. 18 clubs voted in favor of this change today. >> Now, Premier League clubs have voted to cover the legal costs of five board members if they are sued individually by Manchester City sponsors. Now, in September, an independent commission found City guilty of breaking more than of the Premier League's financial rules between 2009 and 2018. City are appealing after the commission found they'd entered into sham contracts with sponsors. So, Carve, just explain how this has come about. >> Well, look, it's come about basically because in the decision which we got

2:21 from the independent commission, Manchester City were accused of Well, they were found guilty, sorry, of breaking the Premier League's financial rules for nine seasons, and the commission found that they had entered into sham contracts, sham contracts. Now, two of their main sponsors are Etihad Airways and Etisalat, a communications company headquartered in Abu Dhabi. Now, they weren't named in the decision, but they feel that they potentially have a legal case against the Premier League because they don't like the fact that they've been accused potentially of entering into sham contracts. They believe it is bad for their business image.

3:06 So, what they have done is they both issued statements saying that they were considering all options, and that has been read as a potential threat to sue the Premier League. Now, what happened today is there was a Premier League shareholders meeting of all 20 clubs, and there was a vote because the Premier League clubs wanted to vote to make sure that the legal costs of their five five board members were covered if they were sued individually by Manchester City's sponsors. So, for instance, Etihad or Etisalat could say to the individual board members, you have defamed us. We are going to take

3:52 you to court. And as things stand, the Premier League's Articles of Association weren't clear. They didn't give indemnity to the individual five board members. So they had a vote today to provide the board members with that indemnity, and the vote was carried 18 to two. The only two clubs who voted against it, we understand, were Manchester City and Nottingham Forest. Of course, you just needed a two-thirds majority, so you just need 14 clubs to vote in favor of making a change. So that change is going to be made, potentially if the five board members are sued individually, then their legal costs would be covered by the Premier League. >> You say that we covered. So this brings

4:38 about an extraordinary possibility that even though Manchester City voted against it, I'm guessing it will be split equally between the Premier League clubs. Could Manchester City end up funding the league's defense against Manchester City? >> I like the way you're thinking there. >> [laughter] >> Against one of their sponsors. >> Yeah, yeah. I think what Manchester City would say is that Etihad Airways and Etisalat are separate companies. They are not Manchester City, but you are right in the sense that we could have a situation where one of Manchester City's or more than one of Manchester City's sponsors could sue the Premier League, and then the Premier League, which Manchester City are a

5:23 member of, they would have to pay 1/20th of the legal costs to defend the Premier League in a potential action bought by one of Manchester City's sponsors. So so you are right, but we are getting into the realm of hypothe- >> Yeah, I >> hypotheticals. I like the way you're thinking. >> [laughter] >> It's How So for me, how would have come Was it would it have been common knowledge that they wouldn't be covered by the Premier League's own like from >> it it it's it's obviously, you know, the Premier League has taken legal advice and they've they've discovered that there's this potential loophole, and they want to make sure that the chair and the chief executive and the non-executive directors are protected going forward in case

6:08 there is a potential legal action. >> Just finally and very quickly I'm sure you have an answer to this or you might not. When do we expect a decision on on the sanctions for City? >> I I would think probably in January or or February. I think we are going to have the appeal next month and then we should get the decision from the appeal and any potential sanctions if City lose that appeal in the early part of next year. >> Fantastic stuff. Right. The

Share

YouTube Video Summaries