0:05 so now it's my great pleasure to welcome the amazing dr. Jeffery Schwartz a research psychiatrist at the University of California and one of the world's leading experts in neuroplasticity particularly as it relates to obsessive compulsive disorder it was his work that demonstrated how thoughts can actually change brain chemistry and his work has actually formed a lot of mine and he's the author of several groundbreaking books he's also a Hollywood adviser on characters with mental disorders such as Howard Hughes portrayed by Leonardo DiCaprio in the movie The Aviator and you can see some of these interviews on his website this morning dr. Schwartz will speak about the neuroscience of habits and how we can reframe our thinking to overcome them please give him a warm welcome thank you
1:01 home that was I really appreciated that and thank you very much and thank you to Beth and Tony for inviting me and it's always great to be in Sydney and every time I come here I love the place more so hopefully you'll be seeing more me as time go by um the subject matter for today is a very significant one and a pretty serious one to the neuroscience of habit for many years I have been representing the position you are not your brain not in a mainstream position in neuroscience at the margin
1:48 that might be changing a little bit I hope it is um but this subject matter for today the neuro the neuroscience of habit is really where the rubber meets the road because those who think you are your brain which really does represent the majority of people who are in high bureaucratic positions in the fields of neuroscience habit is one of the strongest things they have to fall back because if there's anything that really does say you are your brain it's habit so what I'm going to try to do today is show you just how powerful a thing habit is in the brain and it's very very powerful as hopefully you're going to
2:34 get a good appreciation from in this presentation but also the fact that our old friend mindfulness is still the way to get beyond the neuroscience of habit so that in the end hopefully we'll all still be able to be very confident of the fact that in the final analysis you are not your brain but the neuroscience of habit is so powerful that it takes work and effort to accomplish that so this picture which I've been using for many years shows diagrammatically it's obviously a very famous drawing by pressure the great
3:20 Dutch artist that I just mocked up to be the mind in the brain well for many years I've been defining the mind for scientific purposes as the choices and decisions we make about the information that our brain sends us so there's no question that we're getting a constant stream a constant steady stream that doesn't even really stop when we're asleep of information from the brain so it's there's no controversy that the brain is extremely powerful what's left is the choices and decisions that you still can make about the information that your brain is sending you the
4:06 reason why the neuroscience of habit is such a powerful an important subject is because the nature of habit and the way it's wired into the brain basically detaches it in very significant ways from choices and decisions so it takes an extra effort to bring the mind into habit and the brain takes over the mind very significantly in the neuroscience of habit so habit is if you can learn how to beat habit you really really really can say I have a powerful mind because the choices and decisions that I'm making are changing my brain and changing how I respond to information
4:52 but the bottom line of the power of the brain in habit is that it really does hide itself from choices and decisions habit really does in some ways operate on something that's very close but very importantly not fully automatic but very close to automatic and that very automaticity really makes it hard for choices and decisions to penetrate into the process so the neuroscience of habit is a very important subject William James one of the fathers of modern psychology and one of the greatest if not the greatest of American philosophers wrote in a book called talks to teachers the following very
5:40 profound statement about habits he said we are mere bundles of habits imitators and copiers of our past selves habits are the stuff of which behavior consists what he was taking into account here is just how much automaticity there is in how we act we're largely run on automatic pilot where the mind comes in and William James of all people was extremely aware that the mind can enter into this process because in in fact even in this essay which was talks to teachers about how to teach their students how to teach their students about what how to teach their students how to form good habits that's really the point William James
6:28 for me his most important line was one that stated volitional effort willful effort the effort that we make by choice is the effort of attention so here is William James simultaneously saying that we're mere bundles of habits imitators and copiers of our past selves and yet there still remains this issue of how do we pay attention and paying attention with mindfulness takes effort and paying attention in ways that make its aware of whether a habit is a good one or a bad one takes effort so William James is a very good model for the fact that the neuroscience of habit is very powerful that habit is an
7:16 extremely powerful thing that's more than capable of making us act basically like robots very sophisticated robots but robots but that with effort we can pay attention and learn how to enter into and change those habits but how that that is the big question I spent a lot of time in earlier parts of my career studying obsessive-compulsive disorder and I have a little model of the brain here I'm going to enter a part of this talk now where there's going to be a fair amount of neuroscience and I'm going to try very very very hard to make this neuroscience understandable so please bear with me and I'm going to be presenting sophisticated experiments all of which were done in the last three
8:01 years so this is new neuroscience and hopefully I'm going to be able to convey to you some very powerful and very interesting information but this is anything but new this is a study that was done almost 30 years ago now on obsessive-compulsive disorder and this top slide here shows that people with obsessive-compulsive disorder have an overactive orbital frontal cortex and in this brain model you can see that the orbital frontal cortex is the bottom of the front of the brain that sits right over the eye sockets the big part of the brain that we're going to be hearing a lot about today is called the striatum the striatum which is human beings is
8:48 made up of two structures called the caudate and the putamen but just known as the striatum because that's the name that it goes by in humans as well as in all other mammals um and also actually in rodents and birds and reptiles and birds and it's a it's a very very powerful part of the brain that also gets called the habit center and it's it's deep in the core of the brain this section that you're looking at is basically slice this way and so when we open up the brain and look inside we're looking right through the caudate nucleus but as I should say right through the striatum
9:36 now here's another picture but I want you to see just how deeply imbedded in the core of the brain this structure is this is actually a picture that appeared the year before last in an article in Discover Magazine about my work called in defense of free will and it's right on the homepage of my website Jeffrey M Schwartz calm and here we see a very nice artist rendering again of a half of the brain and you can see in three dimensions how the striatum is right in the core of the brain it's it's really right there's one on each side but they sit right in the core of the
10:22 brain so there's one on this side and one on this side and here you see that area that was in red that deep red area on the other in the other picture I just showed you this is the orbital frontal cortex the orbital frontal cortex is a part of the brain among many other things that reminds us or gives us a feeling that something is wrong it's also involved as we're going to hear more about in a few minutes in making decisions about value it's become a very key area in the study of neuro economics how the brain interacts with the field of economics and what we're looking at today is the relationship between this whole outer structure here called the
11:09 cortex and how that cortex interacts with the striatum and basically what happens in OCD in ways that are pathological and inhabits in ways that can be very normal and extremely adaptive is that this the striatum this part right here acts like an automatic transmission in an automobile it's pretty analogous to that it actually takes over the gearing of the cortex which is the advanced outer surface of the brain and runs it automatically but when those when the when the circuits that it's running automatically are adaptive we call those good habits and
11:56 that's what we want good habits but when the circuits that it's running are not so good we call it bad habits or even worse because this area of the brain is very involved in obsessive-compulsive disorder it's very involved in drug addiction it's very involved in a lot of problematic human states where people's behaviors get out of their control and the reason why they their behaviors get out of their control is because they're running on automatic now this is actually a reasonably good cross section through the striatum and what it shows is that even though it's obviously schematic is that the striatum has three main sections in it the habit section
12:44 the section that is wiring goal-seeking behavior circuitry and reward circuitry the reward circuitry is largely run by a neurotransmitter that has become very famous in the last quarter century dopamine dopamine I think many people now know is related to the feelings of pleasure the feelings of reward it's also the a transmitter that largely mediates the abducens II of the drugs of abuse like cocaine because because when cocaine strengthens dopamine signaling it gives feelings of pleasure and as we all know that can rapidly lead to very bad habits so it's worth knowing right away that
13:32 reward can be a very two-edged sword it can be good but it also can be bad and one of the reasons why it can be bad is because it can wire in it's right next to and has a we're going to see in more detail in a moment a very profound effect with the habit circuitry that's out of our conscious control so feelings of pleasure and feelings of reward are very powerful but they're also very dangerous potentially because if they're not hooked in to behaviors that are adaptive and and good that they can cause a lot of problems and also what happens and another core part of what habits are is that as the habit center
14:19 and this habit part of the striatum gets more and more and more wired in it becomes less and less and less connected to goal seeking so one of the reasons why habits are so powerful is because they actually detach themselves from decision-making they detach themselves from goal seeking and so habits this is what we mean when we say habits are largely automatic what's really been learned in the last 20 years with major advances in the last five years that I'm going to tell you about right now is how does that happen the actual physical mechanisms of how that happens have been
15:05 very significantly well understood and the laboratory of Ann Graybiel at Massachusetts Institute of Technology MIT has been a central place where that has happened now I've been very honored and fortunate to be a friend of Han graybles for 20 years because very early we both realize that the striatum which she is essentially the world's leading authority on is involved in obsessive-compulsive disorder and in fact it was AI got cleared from her over 20 years ago calling the striatum the habit center for presenting obsessive compulsive disorder now I'm going to show you some work that she has had done in her laboratory in the last three years very recent work most of which was
15:53 done by Kyle Smith who is now at Dartmouth College but was a postdoctoral fellow at MIT and Ann Graybiel and I'm in and I'll show you some experiments that were done by Kyle Smith as a postdoctoral fellow working in and graybles lab and Grabeel for many years now has defined what is a habit as a chunk of actions what do we mean by that we mean that a habit is a sequence of actions that is treated by the brain as a single unit of behavior a sequence of actions treated by the brain as a single
16:40 unit of actions and it's the striatum that makes that happen and the reason why these brackets here are in red you're going to see in real scientific data in one moment and raviel coined the term task bracketing for what the striatum does it actually has the habit forms the striatum as you're going to see in one moment brackets the neural circuitry of the behavior that then is treated by the brain as a single unit of action let me give you a very concrete example of that from my own life thirty years ago or so just about 30 I stopped a 1 to 2 pack a day cigarette smoking
17:28 habit so just a little humorous here yes I was smoking cigarettes when I was in seventh and eighth grade No older than that but but um I was I was a college student and even into medical school I was I had to see a significant sea rat smoking habit so I know from very personal experience that the extremely complex action of taking a cigarette out of a pack putting it in your mouth taking it out either a pack of matches or a lighter lighting it holding a fire about two inches from your nose lighting the cigarette putting it away and you
18:13 know taking that puff and breathing it out all of that can happen without you even knowing it happened that is a chunk of actions the whole act of taking out the path taking out the cigarette taking out the light or taking out the matches lighting the match and then the key the thing that makes you realize just how powerful this is is that you're now holding a flame about this far from your nose and you don't even know it you're not even aware of it it's all happening automatically you smoke the cigarette you put everything away and if somebody then asked the chronic smoker of which thankfully there are a lot less than there used to be but there are still plenty um are you aware that you just lit a cigarette sir no I'm not because
18:59 it's it's all been done by the striatum it's a chunk of actions that entire process of many complex intricate actions including holding a fire right in front of your nose it's done without being aware of it at all automatically habits are powerful so how does that happen okay this is a key experiment that was done a set of experiments a actually large set of experiments that were done over several years by Kyle Smith working under the direction of an Grabeel in the Graybiel lab at MIT and this is work that was done in rats but as you're going to see it's work that has a lot of relevance to humans basically what this
19:46 is this is called a teammate's and what happens is the rat runs down the maze and then of tone sounds and the poem tells the rat either turn left to get chocolate milk or turn right to get sugar water and rats like both chocolate milk and sugar water and so over several hundred trials the rat actually learns to recognize the the sound and the sound it turns left turns left and when it does turn left and it gets the chocolate milk and another sound a distinctly different sound it learns to turn right and gets the sugar water all of that is called gold seeking behavior it's not a habit that's all gold seeking behavior and I'm going to come back and forth
20:32 between these two slides a few times now to show you how this works in the brain this area down here in the midbrain is where the dopamine lies now and this area up here is the frontal cortex so frontal cortex and then down here in the midbrain dopamine what's the relationship because in this process of learning a new behavioral habit we get the frontal cortex strongly interacting with dopamine in the striatum what happens is when the rat follows the instruction correctly turns the left on
21:18 the signal that tells it to turn left drinks the chocolate milk dopamine comes out and the rat gets this feeling of we assume the rats going this is great chocolate milk and and similarly turning the other way to get the sugar water when it doesn't on the proper signal this is all the gold sticking part of learning this is not habit yet this is learning it involves the frontal cortex and it involves reward signals from dopamine but they are interacting in the striatum in that special zone of the striatum that's involved in goal directed behavior ok takes a couple hundred tribes now the
22:04 RAC knows how to do that then Kyle Smith over trains the rats and this over training part is very important now he runs the rats on this hundreds and hundreds of times hundreds and hundreds of times and as the rat is running that task again and again and again habits develop and and what happens and this is really shows you how powerful habits are to show that a habit is formed this is how they do it scientifically they actually associate one of the rewards with a small dose of a drug that causes nausea now the rat is going to be
22:52 associating what was a reward with a feeling of nausea the thing that shows just how powerful habits are is that when the tone sounds the rat will keep running to the thing that now causes nausea habits are powerful once they get embedded after hundreds and hundreds of trials notice the goal seeking and the reward don't even matter anymore we see this in eating all the time we see this in cigarette smoking we see this in so many behaviors you know you eat you eat candy dish take the candy put it in your mouth eat cigarette there's so many examples we've heard many of them in this meeting the thing to remember the
23:38 key here is that the habit no longer depends on the reward the habit has a life of its own these animals will run to the these animals will run to the side of the maze that causes them now to become nauseous just because they've done it hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of times and it's now wired in to their habit center what has happened in the brain there is that by the way this picture is from it you can easily get this picture on this picture and the last one - is from an article that was published in 2014 by Kyle Smith and Ann Graybiel in Scientific American it's very easy to
24:24 get you can purchase it from Scientific American or even look for it on the internet and you can find um but it's a Scientific American picture so you can get this diagram easily it's from an article in Scientific American and what's happened when the right now is no longer running in a goal-directed way now the rat is running in a habitual way and when and when its habit it moves from the front of the brain the so called executive brain the decision-making part of the brain to a much more automatic part of the brain that's about right over here called the sensory motor cortex so now the behavior is being run just by body circuits it's
25:10 no longer really being run by decision-making circuits so now the striatum is actually running the behavior connected to just physical movement basically detached from reward this is where the task bracketing comes in because if we look at how this rainbow array here shows the activity of nerve cells firing in the striatum and what you can see is that as the rat is just exploring and learning the behavior on all the cells in the striatum are pretty active very much including the goal-directed circuits in the striatum as the habit starts to form you can see
25:55 the test bracketing starts to occur and you see very intense firing of the striatum nerve cells as the rat makes the decision which way to turn and gets right by the reward this area now in blue is much quieter however the goal-directed area of the striatum is actually still active here so as a habit is forming the goal-directed part is still active and the habit part of the striatum is getting quiet and required and when the habit gets fully imprinted where the animal will run or we as animals will literally run to things
26:41 that we basically know aren't good for us anymore the habit has become imprinted into a chunk of actions and here you see the bracket because what the striatum does now is basically set apart the behavior beginning and end you see very high firing and what and what's in between is this complex brain circuitry that is now being treated and run like an automatic transmission by an automatic habit center that basically is making the brain run on automatic there's one more very important part of this there's an area of the cortex this advanced area of the brain that sits
27:28 right here near the bottom in the middle of the brain it's called ventral towards the bottom medial in the bit in the middle prefrontal cortex that area of the brain in human beings is clearly now related we worked on just in the last decade two things that are viewed as relevant to ourselves and valuable to ourselves and in an amazing expert set of experiments that was done in this Kyle Smith and raviel set of studies they showed with advanced technological intervention which is now being widely used in
28:15 neuroscience research that you can inactivate very small discrete areas of the brain and what they show is that when you in to make this area it immediately breaks the habit so now the rack is running to the thing that makes it nauseous because it's just a habit but all you do is just once or twice in a inactivate this area of the cortex and I have it immediately breaks immediately breaks it's shocking actually here is a habit immediately being broken just by inactivating one little area of the brain but it gets even more amazing than that because the thing that really
29:01 is profound and a little bit scary actually is just realize that habits don't just come and go when habits form they get deeply embedded and they're still there and the thing that shows that is that a couple of days later to have it now has still been broken the route is no longer running to the thing that makes it nauseous in fact it develops a new habit now no matter what tone sounds here the rat always runs to the reward to the thing that it still liked the thing that is not associated with being nauseous so now the tone doesn't matter anymore the habit is broken and no matter what tone sounds
29:46 the rat runs to the reward it's learn to a new habit no matter what type tone sounds run to the reward it's not running to the thing that makes it nauseous anymore but six days later or a week or so later if this little area of the brain gets inactivated again immediately the habit comes back immediately the rat starts running again to the thing that makes it nauseous just by once or twice in activating this area of the brain the habit was always still there and it can come back immediately just by having that area of the brain being activated once or twice now how's
30:31 this relevant to humans it's actually very relevant because just think of the cigarette smoking example think of the person who has an alcohol problem example think of a person who has a chocolate eating problem example and on and on and on they work they train they do behavioral modification they quote unquote break the habit now they're not smoking too much they're not drinking too much they're not eating too much of bad foods but what happens they get under stress they get with friends who are still into those things they get into an environment they have how many does it take we all know one cigarette how many cigarettes does it take for the habit to come back that's about reading one cigarette and boom it comes back you can see that this study in rats is showing something
31:18 that's absolutely the same in human beings to have it still there the whole time one or two little miscues and boom that have it comes back full blast habits are powerful we think we have them beat they're still there ready to start bothering us again it's powerful stuff I'm going to now finish I have 15 minutes to go hopefully the neuroscience stuff is almost done so hopefully you all look basically awake um thanks for math the ones who are sleeping or good at hiding it and you probably show that when you're in school and probably learn that in school but I know that you all got good conduct grades in school everybody in this
32:03 audience so now I'm going to show you another troop sets of experiments that are a little easier to understand I think this is one is really fast this is actually just from two years ago this is a paper that's been moved cited many many times even though it was only published in 2013 and what is it show it shows that the subjective value what does that mean subjective value is summarized by step simple terms it's valuable to me and it's relevant to me things that are valuable to me and relevant to me we'll look at that they activate that same area that's area this is a very important area that
32:49 same area and what else that's the dopamine area that area is this these are two completely different studies and actually honestly these two lines of research have never quite been tied together yet so they're it's new research and I think it's rather exciting because we're now tied together it's the subjective value part of the brain with a habbit part of the brain and we're showing that this part of the brain is very very powerful because in subjective value on experiments many many many subjective value experiments that's what the word meta-analysis means in this paper by Bartra he reviewed many many studies looking at what happens in the brain when we see something that's valuable to us and relevant to us and
33:35 what happens is those same two areas I've been talking about dead activated this area right here the so-called ventral medial prefrontal cortex and the dopamine area that's what you're seeing right there now let's get into an experiment that really brings home the mind in its potential part this is the part that's really relevant to this meeting what can we do about this well there's a study that was published this very year this paper was published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Science in 2015 this year first or third but I Emily Faulk and what she shows is that self-affirmation alters the brains response to health messages and then leads to behavior change and this is how they did it self affirmation
34:23 we've heard a lot about that in this meeting and that's very relevant to this organization as a whole self affirmation is very very powerful and what this experiment shows is there's been a fair number of experiments in the last ten years showing that if you if you show health messages to people who live too sedentary life they don't exercise enough it's always you know sitting at work driving back and forth to work and they don't get enough exercise if you show health messages too those people to try to say you need to exercise more because if you don't exercise more you're going to get diabetes if you don't exercise more you're going to have high blood pressure etc etc etc people tend to go like you
35:08 know later for that Jack I don't want to give these bad messages and so it's well known that health messages don't change people's behavior very much so the science of this has been trying to say well what can we do to improve that and the thing that's been discovered that improves it is self affirmation and a very specific kind of self affirmation this is the kind of self affirmation where you ask people to reflect on their core values their core values and so the way this experiment was done is they put a now fairly well understood experimental method into people who are sitting and lying in lying in not sitting in lying in brain scanners and so we can see what happens to their brain as they do self affirmation and
35:55 self affirmation you basically ask people what are the kinds of core values that are the most important to you and the general categories are things like creativity family and friends of faith and religion um the sometimes money um spontaneity even politics I do like to say that at least now in America the people who is politics as their core value for self affirmation they might not belong in the study for normal people but maybe we should go down to like one less core value for normal people but certainly I would say creativity spontaneity humor family and
36:41 friends and I myself will put in my vote for faith because I think faith is a great core value and and when you ask people and here it is whatever your chief core value is they ask people to think about your chief core value and then they play them health messages it's already been discovered that when people are reflecting on their chief core value dissent is the thing that gives them a sin so ah you know my life is valuable my life other people care about me um I'm a part of my community my faith is very important to me I'm close to other people who share my faith and then have
37:27 them listen to health messages they respond better to the health messages they don't just ignore them what this study shows is that those self affirmations done prior to listening to health messages look at the brain area that gets activated these are people who are changing their habit the ventromedial down bottom of the brain middle prefrontal cortex the ventral medial prefrontal cortex gets activated by self affirmation messages and look what happens their activity increases because this says sedentary they get less sedentary they the self affirmation activates the part of their brain that
38:12 says this is valuable to me this is relevant to me self affirmation helps them realize this is important for me and they actually listen to the health message and over the next month they actually exercise more and we're less sedentary it's powerful stuff now we're starting to see how do you change a habit you got to change your values but how do you change your values by thinking about the things that are really and truly and genuinely important for you healthy self affirmation activates the part of the brain that allows us to change habits that's the big take-home message of this talk and so let's now just spend the last few minutes here on our old friend
38:57 mindfulness because mindfulness really helps us do that and what is mindfulness okay I'll just read the list and there's going to be a workshop later with a lot more detail it's an activity it's a state of mind it's an awareness it's a focus it's an acceptance all true but the common denominator of all of those things and what the activity of mindfulness is is having an outer perspective on inner experience what we sometimes call I use this term from Adam Smith the great Scottish philosopher and father of modern economics founder I suppose you should say nowadays founder of modern economics um the impartial spectator the impartial
39:44 spectator the part of us the part of our minds that can look with a clear minded fair-minded perspective on our inner experience that is mindfulness I use in my work in the and you are not your brain I use the term wise advocate other words that can describe the kinds of plain English words that are very consistent with using mindfulness helper inner helper comforter advocate counselor encourage room strengthener friend every person has access inside of them to help her comforter advocate counselor
40:30 encourage ur strengthener friend impartial spectator all of these are words that I think are clearer now than even the word mindfulness itself which is let's be a little candid has become a little over popularized and has lost its meaning in that over popularization process and the components of mindfulness are direct knowing deep experience where 'no speak knowledgeably about what's happening in the moment approaching your experiences and observations outside in observation rather than just cloudy fuzzy thoughts and concepts but I say consult your wise advocate consult your inner help or comfort or advocate counselor encourage or strengthen or friend get that impartial spectator supportive
41:16 perspective now there's one other really important thing that I want to bring home in this talk about mindfulness the question comes up is mindfulness judgmental or non-judgmental and the answer is yes and I'm going to show you why right now this might be the most important thing in this whole talk because this is a message that's easy to understand but hasn't been well enough understood mindfulness is certainly non-judgmental in the sense that you have to examine the the thoughts urges impulses preferences and so on that come in you can't edit them you have to be honest with yourself it's about
42:02 transparency it's about seeing what's actually going on so you can't have an inner editor I actually have a video a four minute video on this right on the home page of my website Jeffrey M Schwartz calm just describing this process you have to pay attention to what's really there that is genuinely non-judgmental you can't be editing you can't be going no I shouldn't be thinking that no that couldn't be me who's thinking that it's you who's thinking that own it it's yours but that doesn't mean you should keep it and nothing to mean it's great because it's yours and that's probably the biggest part of this message just because it's yours don't mean it's great I'm really assertive about that my New York accent really comes out when I say that and and
42:48 that's where the corner quote judgmental part comes because it's not judgmental in scare quotes it's not like don't be judgmental it's how discernment it's used assessment don't think it's great just because it's yours what's key honest all of us all of us all of us have a lot of things going on inside of us that aren't so good we need to do something about it change those habits true self Alfred's true self affirmations consulting the inner wise Advocate helper comforter advocate encourage or strengthen or use discernment use assessment judgmental in the good sense using good judgment why
43:33 has that term gone out of style let's bring back good judgment let's hear it for good judgment right so you need to use both and with mindfulness going back to texts that are two thousand years old describing oral teachings that are 2500 years old yes started by Gautama who is called the Buddha which means awakened one but equally so by Jesus who is called the Christ we can use mindfulness to both bridge and extend the connection between non-judgmental observation and using assessment and discernment and that kind of self affirmation use of wise advocate
44:20 strengthens our capacity to change habits become aware of what those habits are and so we want to bridge that gap you don't edit the content but you use judgment and discernment and ask is this a helpful song is this a helpful behavior become aware of behaviors that you're otherwise unaware of because they become so automatic when you see what they are you can do things that will help you change them by consulting your inner wise advocate so deceptive brain messages now I'm going to finish up really fast deceptive brain messages are bad messages that come into our brain from the habit center there's a cycle of deceptive brain messages this is all from my book you or not your brain that lead to habitual one-half and healthy responses that happen again and again
45:07 and again and again hopefully it's clear why that's true now mindfulness practice I like this picture because it shows all the extraneous stuff that is constantly coming through our minds that's what you learn when you practice mindfulness there's a lot of nonsense that's running through everybody's mind and that's why you have to have a lot of assessment and discernment about what those things are so that they don't hold your attention that's volitional effort is effort of attention mindfulness is the effort to not have your attention be determined by all these things that are running or in your mind so I'm just going to skip right away this I didn't have time for this I'm going to say very good work done by Wendy hasson camp about what happens in your brain when you do breath
45:53 awareness we'll have to do it another time um use your wive's advocate I told you about that the mind is passive the brain um I'm sorry I said that backwards the brain is passive the mind is active the mind is the choices and decisions that you make about the things that your brain puts in your your conscious awareness and you have to use the brain and the mind together as a team by using this method that I called the four-step method we label reframe refocus revalue that is the core of my book but the term wise advocate is really I think the most important term now so the brain puts out the call the mind decides whether to listen that's the big message the
46:40 metamodel will have to wait for the workshop we're trying to get to a true self which we will by following these kinds of principles and I guess I'm just going to skip to the end and say we have a webinar series Josie Thompson and I are doing a workshop this afternoon on all of this on how to put it into practice and we also have a webinar series on that you can sign up for and watch and hopefully what you've heard today is of interest and you'll follow up on how to practically apply the principles I've described for you today in changing the way we actually live our life so that we no longer are run by habits we're not robots we're intelligent mindful people
47:27 making choices and decisions about what to do with our brains information thank you very much you