"The One Skill That Makes AI 10x Better": promises a clear payoff@rajshamani

Brief Summary

Strong non-consensus bets often come from asking worthwhile questions that others have not thought to ask. This skill can be learned, and a promising idea should be explainable to a thoughtful, open-minded person using evidence, its potential impact and a clear account of why the approach might work.

  • Education should give more attention to asking questions, not only answering them.
  • Asking children what questions they asked at school can help foster curiosity.
  • A good way to test a contrarian idea is to explain it to a smart, disciplined non-expert and see whether the reasoning persuades them.

Finding Non-Consensus Bets by Asking Better Questions

The speaker says that learning to identify non-consensus bets—ideas that differ from the prevailing view—came largely from getting better at asking questions. School taught people mainly to answer questions set by others; opportunities to pose their own questions often came later, such as during doctoral study. The speaker argues that education should help young people identify what is interesting to investigate and what remains unknown. In their experience, this ability was the most useful route to finding promising ideas that others might overlook, and they believe many people can learn it.

A possible way to encourage this habit is for parents to ask their children what question they asked at school, rather than only asking about the day’s highlights. The speaker is unsure which country or culture practises this, though Israel is mentioned as a possibility, and jokes about trying it with their own children.

To distinguish a sound bet from wishful thinking, the speaker suggests explaining it to an optimistic, enthusiastic and mentally disciplined smart friend who is not an expert. The explanation should cover the evidence, why the idea might work, why success would matter, and why the approach has potential. The speaker recalls that people were initially strongly sceptical about OpenAI, but that some intelligent non-experts found the case convincing after hearing the reasoning. The transcript ends before their response is fully given.

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

YouTube Transcript Generator

0:00 How do you decide that? How do you find a non-consensus bet? >> Uh good question. I I like My own experience of this was this was one thing that just no one ever taught me. And you know, like very little of my experience in school was figuring out what questions to ask. Um you got to like answer other people's questions and then at some point, I think like when you become a PhD student or whatever, you get to start asking more questions and then eventually do more and more of that, but um I I think we should focus much more on teaching people teaching very young people to figure out what questions to ask and what things are interesting to explore that we don't already know. And I think

0:46 getting good at that skill was the best way that I figured out the sort of non-consensus bets to take. >> Just figuring out how to ask good questions. >> Figuring out how to ask good questions. >> Can you learn that? >> I think so. Yeah. Uh I mean like all of these things, maybe not everybody's going to have equal aptitude for everything, but I think this is one that a lot of people seem to be able to learn. >> You know, there's I forget which which culture which country has this rule where the kid when when he comes back from school, the mother asks the kid that what's the question that you asked today. >> Really? >> Yeah. >> Do you know what culture that's very interesting. Do you know what culture? >> I think it's I think it's Israel or something like someone in Israel. I I'm not sure, but there is some culture where

1:32 mothers just ask the kids. They don't ask about the highlight. They ask about the what's one question did you ask today? >> That's cool. >> Is that a good habit that we should >> I'm going to start that with my kids. I'll I'll I'll report back in 15 years or something. >> But how do you know that it's not wishful thinking? Is there a sign? Is there some something that you can pin down to and be like, okay, if these are the signals in the thinking that I'm the way I'm thinking, probably this makes sense. >> Yeah. Um I mean what one example one thing is can you explain it to a optimistic enthusiastic but kind of mentally disciplined smart friend and can you update them about why it might be a good bet? So, I remember when we were starting OpenAI, the the default was like

2:18 strongly skeptical. But I would talk to people and I would say, you know, here is the evidence. Here's what we've seen. Here's why this might work. Here's why it'd be huge if it worked. Um and here's why this is an approach that we think has legs and and then, you know, if we can make superintelligence, it was kind of obvious why that would be valuable to make. Um and and you know, not every time but enough of the time when we talked to somebody who was like a smart person but a non-expert, they would say, "Okay, that seems you can

Share

YouTube Video Summaries