Youtube WON'T PAY me / WARNING to Content Creators

The Crockers www.youtube.com

Brief Summary

The Crockers’ channel has recently seen YouTube withhold a significant share of its advertising revenue, apparently because the platform suspects some views may be fraudulent. The creator says the channel has not bought views or comments and has received no clear evidence or explanation from YouTube. He asks viewers to leave genuine comments and encourages other creators to check whether their paid views match their analytics.

  • YouTube appears to be paying for only a portion of the channel’s reported views, costing the family about a third of its usual income.
  • The creator believes the low number of comments compared with daily vlog views may have triggered YouTube’s suspicion, though this is unconfirmed.
  • He says the channel will continue posting and will not resort to buying engagement or promoting products just to replace the lost income.

YouTube Withholds Part of the Channel’s Revenue

The creator explains that YouTubers earn money when adverts appear on their videos. Advertisers pay YouTube, and creators receive a share of that revenue. CPM refers to the amount paid per thousand ad impressions, while RPM is the creator’s revenue per thousand views. He also notes that fake views and comments can be generated by bot farms, which may make it difficult for YouTube to distinguish genuine audience activity from fraudulent engagement.

The Crockers’ view counts had declined over time as their content and filming locations changed, and the creator says this was not due to being shadowbanned. The current concern is different: during the past few months, the channel’s revenue has fallen, and recent videos appear to earn money for only some of their views. For example, a video showing 60,000 views in analytics might be paid as if it had received only around 25,000; other videos with 30,000–50,000 views were reportedly paid for roughly 18,000.

After contacting YouTube, the creator received a generic response saying the channel might have fraudulent viewership. He says YouTube has not provided proof, identified a specific cause or given a timeframe for resolving the issue. He denies buying views or comments and says the channel rarely promotes products. YouTube’s response also mentioned possible fraudulent activity involving promoted products, but the creator says the channel does not normally run paid product promotions.

He suspects the mismatch between view counts and comments could be contributing to YouTube’s concern. The channel’s older, popular videos can attract many comments, while newer daily vlogs might receive 50,000–60,000 views but only around 100 comments. He acknowledges that the channel’s content has changed and may be less entertaining than before, but says those changes were not the issue he was trying to raise.

The creator estimates that the channel is losing about a third of its usual income. He describes this as YouTube effectively retaining a larger share of the advertising money than before, while stressing that the family can still manage financially and will keep making videos. He asks viewers who genuinely watch the channel to leave ordinary, authentic comments—without posting repetitive or artificial messages—and invites other creators to compare their analytics with the views for which they are paid and report similar problems to YouTube.

He thanks regular viewers for their support and says he will continue to avoid buying engagement or promoting products he does not believe in just to make up the shortfall. He hopes genuine comments might help clarify that the channel’s audience is real, but accepts that the revenue reduction may continue. He closes by encouraging people to comment on channels they support, since engagement can make a meaningful difference.

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

YouTube Transcript Generator

0:01 All right, guys. So, no building, no nothing in this video. This is going to be straightforward. You guys saw the title, thumbnail. It's not clickbait. YouTube is withholding our money. And uh didn't really give us a real explanation why. Uh it's a very weird concept. And I guess in a very short amount of time, I'm going to try to explain it to you guys and uh kind of need y'all's help to hopefully get it back. I'm also doing this video so hopefully other content creators won't have to go through this or maybe they've kind of noticed it and uh they can help start to

0:47 get some of the revenue back. Uh, I guess a quick brief way of how YouTubers make money for those that don't know. Obviously, our job is to post videos. It doesn't really matter what the content is. All YouTube really cares about is we're making a video and it keeps people on YouTube and Google owns YouTube. So, Google is the one putting the ads into the videos and then the ad revenue that they are making off of these ads, paying Google to put them in the YouTube videos, we get paid and it is called CPM and RPM. Uh there's different uh ways of thinking with it, I

1:32 guess. I'm trying to break this down as easy as possible, but YouTube will pretty much pay a content creator per thousand views. Uh they'll call it, you know, the RPM or whatever. So, say YouTube is charging, I'm just making this number up, $40, um you know, per thousand views for these people to put their ads in, YouTube will then pay the content creator, say $20. And so one is CPM, one is RPM, and YouTube is always changing the algorithms and metrics and this and that. And with AI coming into the picture and and fake accounts, bot accounts, fake people, there's there's YouTubers out there that pay bot farms

2:22 to watch their videos to get views and they comment to get comments, interaction, and um it's very obvious and easy to see. Uh, all you got to do is if you see somebody that doesn't get a lot of views, all of a sudden they're getting just an insane amount of views and say they're getting, you know, I'm just making numbers up here, 20,000 views when they normally would get 200. And there are uh 85 comments when they normally would get eight comments, but all the comments are literally uh people from India and saying the same thing. It just doesn't add up, right? um it it's just doesn't add up. Our channel over the years uh was

3:10 massive. And I'm not blaming YouTube for any of that. Our views going down. Uh we at one point were getting hundreds of thousands of views a day. We were just gaining subscribers like crazy. This was a couple of years ago when our channel was just blowing up and uh it did really well. And over the time it slowed down. We changed our content a little bit. We changed scenery where we were and over the years our view started to drop. We're very much aware of that. We're not blaming YouTube one bit. We're not shadowbanned. We're not uh blaming YouTube at all. It was us changing our content and drama and this and that. That is not what this video is about. Um, but over the last three months, our

3:56 revenue kind of has been going down and I was like, well, let's kind of see what happens. And I started posting more videos the last week, two weeks, and I was like, all right, I'm kind of looking at the analytics and stuff, and I was like, for my view count, I should be getting paid double. What is happening here? This is crazy. my my I'm looking at my RPM, CPM, stuff like we talked about earlier. And per thousand views, I should be getting paid double. I'm losing a lot of my paycheck, about a third of my paycheck. And I know you're saying if, well, if it's double and they're not paying you that, how's it a third? We do have videos in the background again when our channel was really big and on and

4:41 popping. Those videos are still making money. Um, videos from a year ago are still making money. So, a lot of our monthly income is old videos and then we have our normal videos and our normal videos in our analytics are showing this is just for instance say we have a video that has 60,000 views. they're only paying us for 25,000 views and it literally is in our analytics and I started using chat GBT to kind of run it through and being like, "Hey, is something wrong here?" And ChatG was like, "Yeah, this does not make sense. Uh, you should reach out to YouTube and and really check it out." Because if you look at the analytics, it's literally saying

5:27 that uh you're getting say 60,000 views, but they're only paying you. It literally says you they're only paying you for half of those views. And um you know there's been videos that were getting 30, 40, 50,000 views and they're paying us for 18,000 views and it's crazy. We're literally losing a third of our paycheck. And so, um, I wrote YouTube and I got a generic response back and it was kind of like a copy and paste, didn't really address the issue back and just said, "Due to um, things happening on YouTube, it looks like there's fraudulent

6:14 uh, viewership on your channel." And I was like, well, this is kind of odd. Um, I'm not I What did I do something wrong? And I'm I'm not sure what's happening. Like I don't pay for bots to get views. If we were doing that, we'd get a lot more views than we were. I don't pay for comments. I don't pay for anything. And then it said, be careful whenever you promote products in your videos. We don't promote products that it can be like bots acting like that product is getting clicked on, all this type of stuff. And I was like, well, one, we kind of pride oursel in not doing ad reads in our videos. We don't promote products. We don't get paid for any of that. So, that's not it. We don't pay for views. We don't pay for comments. We

7:00 don't do any of that. Ironically, when our channel used to get crazy views, all the haters out there were like, "They're buying it. They're buying it." But it was very authentic. It was very much in our analytics. You could see it. It was very like we do everything by the book when it comes to this because this is the best job uh I'll ever have pay-wise. I would never want to screw that up. And uh it was always a big fear that you hear people starting to do that and they get their channels taken down. And I don't want that. This has been something that I've been doing for years and years and years and I've never had a problem up until the last 3 months. And so unfortunately I went back and forth with YouTube a couple of emails which I think it's AI on their end just like making these responses because it doesn't sound

7:46 like someone's actually um responding and they respond fairly quick and I and there's just millions of people on YouTube uh millions of channels out there that could be potentially reaching out. I think it's AI. I think it's just like a generic AI response and unfortunately I don't think I'm going to get another response from them that tells me what's actually happened. And so basically what they're saying is they think there is fraudulent uh viewership and that um they can't prove it and they can't tell me a real time frame. They just think that it's fraudulent. So, they are cutting our pay on any view that they think might be

8:32 fraudulent, which basically again, they're cutting our views in half. You may see our video is getting, say, 60,000 views. They're only going to pay us for 20,000 or whatever they see fit, and they don't have to prove to us any different. Um, so the only thing after reading the emails and from what Chat GBD is saying is potentially the only thing that they have is that we're getting 30 to 50 to 60,000 views a video on our normal daily vlogs. Of course, our other videos are bigger. And I think that's kind of the problem is we have some videos in the background that are doing great and getting just hundreds and thousands of comments while our normal videos are getting 50 60,000 views and we're getting 100 comments.

9:19 Um, I think the problem is, and we've noticed this for a while, which is is on us. It's not anything to do. We're not being shadowbanned. We're not being anything like that. This is our content is not as good as it used to be. and our content we're very much aware is maybe not as entertaining or what people wanted. Um, so our views have dropped, but our comment section is drastically lower than it used to be. So we'll get 60,000 comments and we'll get a I mean 60,000 views, we'll get 100 comments. So YouTube's like, "This looks like it's fake. Why are they getting all these views and low comments? It doesn't add up." So we don't ask for anything. We literally never ask you guys for anything. We don't promote really these products we

10:06 don't believe in. We're not doing these things for money. Uh the only thing that we have promoted and we I think we only did it one time on the Crockers was Pain County. Uh we love their uh products. We don't get paid for it. He just sends us products and he has for the last many years and then we'll show them in our video and talk about it. But go check them out if you want. Other than that, we don't promote anything. We don't do anything. We don't ask you guys for favors. We're just very um genuinely uh blown away every day that anyone even wants to watch us and our family. And we're very grateful for the opportunity of being on YouTube. We're very grateful that I personally don't even have to go look for the ads. Uh Google does it for us. They take um right off the top, whatever the ads are paying, they're pay they're taking at least half of that.

10:52 We'll get paid the other half. Now they're taking half of the half. So technically right now Google and YouTube is keeping 75% of ad revenue and giving us 25 which is pretty crazy um because it hasn't been like that for years and just over the last couple of months. So, the only thing I'm asking is if you guys watch and you even consider commenting but don't comment. Um, the fact that our comment section is a lot lower, smaller is the only thing that I can think of and chatbt can think of of why they think our stuff is fraudulent. Um, I'm not asking you guys to get on there and comment like a b cde e f, you know, just like whatever because then that looks sketchy. Uh, all we're asking is, hey, if you watch our

11:38 videos, um, if you want to comment down below and it'll help us drastically, hopefully get out of this hole and start making money. We still are very comfortable with money. We still make enough to survive. We're not like going to freak out and not be able to post, have to go get a job and stuff like that. No. Uh, but I'm also doing this video to maybe hopefully if other channels are going through it, you go to your analytics, look at your view count, and look what you're getting paid for. Um, go check it out. Hopefully no one else is dealing with this, but if they are, um, report it to YouTube, and maybe if enough channels report it, it'll get taken care of. But if you're just a viewer, uh if you don't mind and you support us enough, um please feel free to throw comments in the videos,

12:25 including this one. And um let's hopefully over the next couple of videos, maybe the next week, it'll make a difference enough that YouTube will be like, "Okay, this isn't fraudulent. We can give them hopefully the back pay. We're losing a lot of money. Um drastically a lot of money. a third of our paycheck for no reason, no real expla e uh explanation. And um hopefully the comments will kind of help. If not, we're still going to post videos. We're still going to we're going to do. It's just not giving us as much money to pump into our channel as we normally would or put into savings for our kid or do whatever. Um we're not going to go bankrupt. We're not going to do anything like that. I don't have to

13:10 like go get another job or anything. Um it's just we're losing unfortunately a third of our paycheck and um it's due to we don't know. Um they literally have just told us they don't know if it's actually fraudulent or not, but until something changes, they're just going to not pay us for half our views, which is pretty crazy. Um, so we don't ask for much, but if you feel the need or the want, I guess, not the need, the want to support us, um, we would be very much grateful if you guys would comment on a more regular basis. Let's just say for like the next week and, um, maybe get the, uh, comment section up. Uh, and

13:57 we'll see if it makes a difference. It may not, we may, this may be the new norm for our channel. If it is, it's just what it is. We'll deal with it. But um as of right now, I'm truly very much uh not sure what to do to make it any better because YouTube pretty much said it is what it is and uh they don't have to give us a full expla explanation or data behind it to prove that we're doing fraudulent things, which is kind of weird. So, I don't know. It's the world we live in with this job and uh AI and everything happening and and people scamming out there. So hopefully this is just a phase and we'll get through it. But I do want to say thank you to everyone that supports us. Thank you to everyone that uh has been commenting and keeping us

14:43 alive um you know to the extent that we're at. So, all of you that have been commenting faithfully on our videos and supporting us from the bottom of hearts, thank you. Cuz they could be taking all our uh money or just cancelling our channel, I guess, thinking it's fraud. I don't know. Um, and anyone who decides to comment that hasn't been commenting, thank you from the bottom of my heart. And hopefully, again, a big reason why I'm posting this is hopefully to help other channels that may be going through this. Uh, I'm not saying if your views are low, it's probably you don't have great content or you're out of the algorithm. Uh, I don't think we're shadowbanned. I know we're not putting out as much good content as we used to, and I'm very much aware that we're not

15:28 as entertaining as we used to be. And I'm very much aware that our channel has changed over the years. I'm not worried about any of that. That's all on us. It's just the uh comment section that is weird. than the only thing that anybody can think of right now of why they think our channel is fraudulent. So, pretty weird, pretty ironic that haters used to say that we were um doing this and now YouTube because our comment section is low thinks we're doing it. It's a it's a weird world we live in and uh we tried to do everything as honest as we could and be as faithful to you guys and not pump out videos um promoting products just to get paid. we pretty much would pride oursel on that and uh I'm going to continue that. I'm not going to try to

16:14 make more money uh to make up for it by promoting products that I just don't care about. If something comes along and and I see fit to do it, I will. But it's few and far between when we do that on the channel. I very much pride oursel in just trying to give you content and not sell you products so we make money. I don't want to do that. Uh haven't really done that. And um uh in exchange for y'all support, I want to keep the channel the same and uh yeah, we'll kind of see what happens. I just wanted to fill you guys in and uh kind of just ask for a little uh a little um throw us a bone, I guess. Um and let's see if we can get this to change. But until then, it just is what it is. We're we're in YouTube's uh game and we just got to

17:01 play it. And uh yeah, what a weird thing that I never expected that our channel would get popped for fraudulent activity and they would take half our paycheck, a third of our paycheck, and um only pay us for half the views when we've tried to pride oursel in doing it the right way. So, I don't know. It's where we're at. We'll see what happens. There will be a video tomorrow of our normal stuff. I just wanted to do this because I just started finding all this out. So hopefully you guys have a great day and uh please help channels out, not just ours. Uh comment, comment, comment on everyone's channels that you support. It makes a way bigger difference than you guys would ever know. All right, guys. Peace.

Share

YouTube Video Summaries