#KiniNews: Federal Court rules part of PAA unconstitutional; IP on Pahang royal case sent to AGC

KiniTV www.youtube.com

Brief Summary

This video covers several key Malaysian news stories. It includes a federal court ruling against a provision in the Peaceful Assembly Act, concerns raised by former Prime Minister Dr. Mahathir Mohamad regarding potential political interference in the appointment of a new Chief Justice, and the postponement of a debate due to a family emergency. Additionally, the video reports on a police investigation into an alleged assault by a royal figure, an MCMC investigation into a racist social media post, and Elon Musk's criticism of a US tax and spending bill. Finally, it presents viewer opinions on whether the government is protecting judicial independence.

  • Federal Court strikes down part of Peaceful Assembly Act.
  • Concerns about political interference in Chief Justice appointment.
  • Debate postponed due to family emergency.

Federal Court Ruling on Peaceful Assembly Act

The Federal Court has declared Section 9(5) of the Peaceful Assembly Act (PAA) unconstitutional. This section previously allowed for a fine of up to 10,000 ringgit for organizers who failed to notify the police five days before a planned gathering. The ruling, led by Chief Justice Tank Mun on her last day before retirement, was unanimous. The challenge was brought by former Muda Secretary General Amir Hari Abdul Hadi, who was charged in 2022 for failing to notify police before a protest about the LCS scandal. The court found that the section imposed punishment beyond what is allowed under Article 10(1)(B) of the Constitution, which guarantees freedom of speech, assembly, and association, deeming it a disproportionate intervention. Amir's criminal case has been sent back to the High Court to be resolved in line with the Federal Court's decision.

Concerns Over Appointment of New Chief Justice

Former Prime Minister Dr. Mahathir Mohamad has commented on the delayed appointment of a new Chief Justice, following the retirement of Chief Justice Tumai Munan Mut. Mahathir stated that he was informed of differing views within the Judicial Appointments Commission regarding the selection and stressed that there should be no external interference in the process. He warned that outside involvement could undermine the judiciary's integrity, emphasizing the importance of appointing someone with extensive judicial experience, similar to Tenkum's qualifications, to ensure decisions are widely accepted.

Postponement of Debate

A debate between UMNO Youth Chief Dr. Akma Salai and student activist Fakru Razi Kai Rial has been postponed because Akmal's father has fallen critically ill. The postponement was made in solidarity with Akmal, allowing him to be with his family during this difficult time. A new date for the debate, which was to focus on demonstrators, will be announced after further discussions with Akmal. Previously, Akmal had challenged the students to a debate following a protest in Sabah on June 22nd that culminated in the burning of a poster of Anoir.

Police Investigation into Alleged Assault by Royal Figure

The police have completed their investigation into a case where a man claimed he was assaulted and stabbed by a royal figure and have submitted the investigation papers to the Attorney General's Chambers (AGC). The incident allegedly occurred at a Guantan nightclub. Police opened an investigation under Section 324 of the Penal Code. The police chief stated that 13 individuals had their statements recorded, including the victim for identification purposes. The complainant alleged he was attacked by a group, including a member of the Pahang royal family, after bumping into the royal family member twice at different entertainment venues.

MCMC Investigates Racist Social Media Post

The Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission (MCMC) has recorded a statement from an individual regarding a social media post containing elements of racism. The post concerned the appointment of a new armed forces lieutenant general and used a racial narrative that could potentially disrupt the country's harmony and unity. The MCMC seized a handphone and SIM card to aid the investigation, which is being conducted under Section 233 of the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998, carrying a penalty of a maximum 500,000 ringgit fine or two years jail, or both. The individual is believed to be Sunai Bulo past division chief Zaharudi Muhammad, who had posted a hypothetical news report about a Chinese person becoming the 50th prime minister.

Elon Musk Criticizes US Tax and Spending Bill

Elon Musk has criticized US lawmakers and President Donald Trump over a massive tax and spending bill, calling it the biggest debt hike in history. He threatened political payback for anyone who votes in favor of the bill. Musk slammed politicians who campaigned on spending cuts but now support the bill, warning they will face primary challenges. He also attacked what he termed the "Democrat Republican uni party" and suggested that if the bill passes, a new "America party" will be formed.

Public Opinion on Judicial Independence

Following concerns raised by Rafuzi Ramly regarding the judiciary, viewers were asked whether the government is handling matters in a way that protects judicial independence. 68% of voters expressed legitimate concerns, while 24% believed the government is prioritizing judicial independence. 6% felt it is a complex issue requiring a balanced and transparent approach. Some voters emphasized the need for separation of powers and prioritizing seniority in the elevation of judges.

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the Apple Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

Full transcript of “#KiniNews: Federal Court rules part of PAA unconstitutional; IP on Pahang royal case sent to AGC”. Click a timestamp to open the video at that moment. Need another video? Use the YouTube transcript generator.

0:00 [Music] [Applause] [Music] The federal court has struck down a key provision in the peaceful assembly act. This was in response to Amir Hariri Abdul Hadi's challenge against the provision. However, Amir said the ruling shouldn't distract from the government's failure to act on the LCS scandal, which was what he had protested against. Dr. Matthew Muhammad has responded to concerns about political interference in the appointment of a new chief justice. Stay tuned for all the details. The federal court has ruled that a part of the peaceful assembly act is unconstitutional. Specifically, the ruling struck out clause 9 bracket 5 of the PAA. Section 9 bracket 5 stipulates that an organizer can be slapped with a

0:45 fine of not more than 10,000 ringgit for failure to provide a notice to the police 5 days before a planned gathering. Chief Justice Tank Mun on her last day before retirement led a five member bench today in the unanimous ruling over a challenge brought by former Muda Secretary General Amir Hari Abdul Hadi. He was charged back in 2022 for allegedly failing to notify police before a protest over the LCS scandal. His legal team challenged the charge and on August 8th last year, the high court granted him leave to bring the case to the federal court. According to FMT, Tenkum said section 9 bracket 5 impose punishment beyond what's allowed under article 10 bracket 1 bracket B of the constitution which guarantees the freedom of speech, assembly, and

1:31 association. She called the section a disproportionate intervention that amounted to a prohibition rather than a restriction on the guaranteed rights. Tokoimun also ordered that Amir's criminal case be sent back to the high court and resolved in line with today's decision. Prior to today's judgment, the government reduced an initial 10-day notice requirement under the section to five days. Amir later said that the decision should not distract the public from the literal combat ship controversy. Let's take a look at what he said. scandal.

2:41 The only personal Scandal.

3:37 Former Prime Minister Dr. Matthew Muhammad has weighed in on the topic of the appointment of a new Chief Justice. This comes amid the delay in announcing a replacement for Chief Justice Tumai Munan Mut who is set to retire upon reaching the mandatory retirement age of 66 this Wednesday. Mater said he was informed there are differing views among the judicial appointments commission members selecting the judge and hopes the commission settles it. He stressed that there should be no external interference. Speaking to reporters yesterday, Mahhater warned that outside involvement could undermine the judiciary's integrity. He said if outsiders decide who becomes a judge, we will not get the best judges. He added that this was why they entrusted the responsibility to the commission. He said the commission has enough members to evaluate the candidates's

4:23 performance. Mad also stressed on the importance of appointing someone with extensive judicial experience to match Tenkum's qualifications. He said a chief justice leummoon has a long track record which is why her decisions are easily accepted by all parties. Amno youth chief Dr. Akma Salai was set to debate a student activist tonight. However, the debate is now on hold. This is as Akbal's father has fallen critically ill. In a statement, Secretary Rakia Abanji said the postponement is made in solidarity with Akmal and to give space for Akmal to be with his family during this challenging time. It also expressed sympathy for Akmal and his family and urged members of the public to pray for them. The secretary added that a new date for the

5:09 debate will be announced once the situation allows and after further discussions with Akmal. The debate was originally slated to be held at 9:00 p.m. at Ruma Manger in Pataling Jaya where Akmar was to face off against student Fakru Razi Kai Rial. The topic of the debate is demonstr. Previously, Akmal had challenged the students to a debate following a protest in Sabah on June 22nd that culminated in the burning of a poster of Anoir and Fakur Razi had accepted the challenge. Last night, however, Akma posted on his social media accounts that his father is on his deathbed. He asked friends who know his father to pray and apologized on his father's behalf if he had hurt anyone's feelings when he was well. A man had claimed he was assaulted and

5:55 stabbed by a royal figure. Now, the case is with the attorney general's chambers. Pang police said they have wrapped up the investigation in the case and have sent the investigation papers to the AGC. In a press conference today, Bahung police chief Yahaya Otman reportedly said that his team is awaiting instructions from the AGC regarding the alleged incident at a Guantan nightclub. He said police opened an investigation into the case under section 324 of the penal code and sent the investigation papers to the AG. According to him, the AG had returned it to them to complete the investigation and they had completed it and submitted it back to the AG. Yahayas said 13 individuals had their statements recorded to complete the

6:40 investigation, including the victim who was called in for identification purposes. On May 8th, a traitor claimed to have been assaulted and stabbed by a group of men, including one believed to be a member of the Pahang royal family while at a nightclub. According to a police report that went viral on social media dated June 5th, the 30-year-old complainant alleged he was attacked by the group after he bumped into the royal family member twice at different entertainment venues. The MCMC recorded a statement from an individual over a social media post that contained elements of racism. In a statement today, the MCMC said the post touched on the appointment of a new armed forces lieutenant general with a racial narrative that could potentially

7:26 disrupt the country's harmony and unity. Following this, it said the individual was summoned to give his statement and facilitate the investigation. The MCMC added that it had also seized a handphone and SIM card to facilitate the probe. The probe is being conducted under section 233 of the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998 which carries a penalty of a maximum 500,000 ringit fine or two years jail or both. While MCMC did not name the individual, Malaysia Kiny understands the person was Sunai Bulo past division chief Zaharudi Muhammad and has contacted him for comment. Previously, Zaharuin, who is also past president Abdul Hadi Awangs son-in-law, had made a post on Facebook where he had also attached a screenshot

8:11 of a news article regarding the promotion of Johnny Limang from Major General to Lieutenant General. He had penned a news report from the future about a hypothetical scenario in 2015 when a Chinese person has become the 50th prime minister with his parents having secured citizenship through the Malaysia My Second Home Scheme. However, Zaharudin insisted that the appointment is not linked with the post, saying that it is merely decorative and had no connection with the news above. If you like the stories we produce, consider supporting us by subscribing to Militia Kiny. Click the link in the description below or scan the QR code on your screen to subscribe. Elon Musk has hit out at US lawmakers

8:56 and US President Donald Trump over a massive tax and spending bill. He's calling it the biggest debt hike in history and threatened political payback for anyone who votes yes for it. In a series of posts on X, Musk slammed US politicians who campaign on spending cuts but now back Trump's bill. In a post on X, he said every member of Congress who campaigned on reducing government spending and then immediately voted for the biggest debt increase in history should hang their head in shame. Mus said they will lose their primary next year if it is the last thing he does on this earth. He didn't just go after Republicans. He also attacked what he called the Democrat Republican uni party. He warned that if the bill, which

9:42 has been dubbed the big beautiful bill passes, the America party will be formed so that the people actually have a voice. Musk added that anyone who campaigned on the promise of reducing spending but continues to vote on the biggest debt ceiling increase in history will see their face on a poster in the primary next year. He attached an image of the poster in his post. According to Bernama, Trump has been advocating for the bill's passage for weeks and had applied pressure on critics within the Republican party. Critics such as Musk have criticized the bill for not going far enough in cutting government spending and for increasing the debt ceiling. Rafuzi Ramly had previously warned of deepening concerns over the judiciary, particularly in response to the upcoming replacement of the chief justice and the

10:29 appointment of new judges. With several senior judges approaching retirement, he said questions have arisen about the future direction of the country's judicial system. In light of these developments, we asked our viewers whether they thought the government is handling these matters in a way that protects judicial independence or is there reason to be concerned about political influence. Let's take a look at the responses. A majority with 68% of voters said that there is legitimate cause for concerns. Meanwhile, 24% believe that the government is prioritizing judicial independence and appropriate appointments are being made. 6% said it is a complex issue and a balance transparent approach is needed. Several voters brought up the issue of

11:15 separation of powers and said that the judiciary needs to be separated from the other branches of the government. A user also said to prioritize seniority in the elevation of judges. What are your thoughts on the matter? Share them in the comment section below. That is all for me today. For more stories, you can go to kinyv.com. You can also follow us on Instagram, X, YouTube, and Facebook for the latest news updates. I'm Chameleia. Thanks for watching.

Share

More video summaries