The LGBTQ+ Experience

Brief Summary

The LGBTQ rights movement challenged the gap between American ideals of freedom and the restrictions imposed on LGBTQ people’s lives. From policing, employment discrimination, and medical stigma to Stonewall, AIDS activism, legal change, literature, and public art, the history shows both the power of collective action and the inequalities within the movement.

  • LGBTQ people built communities and resisted discrimination even when visibility could lead to arrest, job loss, or family rejection.
  • Stonewall helped turn longstanding resistance into more visible, confrontational organizing, while later debates exposed differences of race, class, gender, and political strategy.
  • Baldwin, Butler, and Feinberg examine how gender and identity are shaped by social expectations and enforced through everyday interactions.
  • AIDS activism and memorial art challenged neglect, stigma, and the denial of public mourning.
  • Legal equality brought important protections, but the lecture asks whether liberation also requires changing the institutions and categories that produce inequality.

Postwar Family Ideals, Policing, and Early Organizing

The postwar ideal of the nuclear family treated marriage, conventional gender roles, and child-rearing as signs of maturity, morality, and good citizenship. Although real families were more diverse, schools, churches, medicine, advertising, and employers reinforced this ideal and treated alternatives as failures. LGBTQ people faced both punishment for same-sex relationships and policing of gender expression. Sodomy laws criminalized sexual acts, while police used disorderly-conduct and liquor laws to raid bars, entrap people, and expose them publicly; arrests could lead to prison, job loss, and family rejection.

During the Cold War, the Lavender Scare portrayed gay and lesbian federal employees as security risks, on the theory that concealed relationships made them vulnerable to blackmail. Executive Order 10450, issued in 1953, expanded security screening and helped exclude people accused of “sexual misconduct,” often without evidence of disloyalty. Alfred Kinsey’s 1948 and 1953 reports documented a wider range of sexual behavior than conventional morality acknowledged. His Kinsey scale placed sexuality along a continuum rather than in two fixed categories, challenging stigma, though the scale itself remains limited.

Early organizations offered routes to community and political action. The Mattachine Society, founded in Los Angeles in 1950, encouraged gay men to recognize shared political interests; the Daughters of Bilitis, founded in San Francisco in 1955, provided lesbians with social connections and circulated information through its magazine, The Ladder. Both groups had to weigh organizing against the risk of exposing members to arrest, firing, or rejection. Compton’s Cafeteria in San Francisco’s Tenderloin served transgender women, drag queens, and sex workers who were excluded from more “respectable” spaces. In 1966, patrons resisted a police roundup there, years before Stonewall, demonstrating that transgender and gender-nonconforming people were already resisting police control of public space.

Respectability, Sexual Liberation, and Stonewall

Some activists used the term “homophile” to emphasize affection rather than sexual behavior and to challenge the idea that gay identity was only about sex. Carefully managed demonstrations often used formal dress codes to present participants as respectable, conventional Americans. This strategy could help build public support, but it also risked implying that people had to conform in appearance or behavior to deserve rights. In some 1950s lesbian bars, butch and femme roles mirrored conventional masculine and feminine pairings.

The sexual revolution, the counterculture, and women’s liberation challenged expectations about marriage, reproduction, and sexual morality. The birth-control pill helped separate sex from reproduction, while feminists opposed sexual double standards. Yet much of the new freedom remained focused on heterosexual relationships. Gay liberation activists argued that sexual freedom should include same-sex relationships and increasingly emphasized visibility and pride rather than respectability. In 1973, following activist pressure and changes in psychiatric perspectives, the American Psychiatric Association removed homosexuality from its diagnostic manual as a mental disorder.

Stonewall took place in the early hours of June 28, 1969, after police raided the Stonewall Inn in Greenwich Village. The Mafia-operated bar served a diverse clientele, including gay men, drag queens, gender-nonconforming people, and homeless LGBTQ youth. Police raids were routine, but this time patrons and people outside resisted, throwing objects as the crowd grew; officers barricaded themselves inside, and the conflict spilled into the streets. Stonewall was not the beginning of LGBTQ activism, but the sustained organizing that followed made it a turning point. The Gay Liberation Front connected LGBTQ demands to the era’s broader liberation movements and questioned institutions that treated heterosexuality and gender conformity as normal. In 1970, Christopher Street Liberation Day marches made public visibility itself a political act and challenged the shame imposed on LGBTQ people.

Backlash, Political Representation, and Intersectionality

The gains of gay liberation met organized opposition. In 1971, singer and activist Anita Bryant led a campaign to repeal a Miami-Dade County ordinance prohibiting discrimination based on sexual orientation. Its “Save Our Children” slogan framed equal treatment as a threat to children and promoted unsupported claims that gay people were dangerous. Voters repealed the ordinance, but the defeat helped mobilize LGBTQ activists nationally and foreshadowed later disputes over schools, families, and public visibility.

In 1977, Harvey Milk became one of the first openly gay elected officials in the United States when he won a seat on San Francisco’s Board of Supervisors. Milk argued that coming out could counter stereotypes by making gay people visible as neighbors, relatives, and co-workers. He opposed California’s Proposition 6, the Briggs Initiative, which would have allowed gay and lesbian public-school employees to be dismissed; voters rejected it in 1978. That November, former supervisor Dan White assassinated Milk and Mayor George Moscone. White’s conviction for voluntary manslaughter rather than murder provoked the White Night riots in 1979 and deepened mistrust of the legal system.

The movement’s risks and priorities were not the same for everyone. Race, class, gender, and access to family support could shape a person’s exposure to discrimination and ability to participate. Black feminist lesbians, including the Combahee River Collective, argued that racism, sexism, class oppression, and homophobia could not be treated as separate problems. This framework, called intersectionality, helps illuminate whose concerns received funding and visibility and whether campaigns prioritized employment, housing, health care, or marriage. It also informs readings by James Baldwin, whose experience in gay social spaces was shaped by race, and Leslie Feinberg, whose narrative connects gender policing to working-class life and labor conflict.

The AIDS Crisis and Community Care

In 1981, the CDC reported unusual cases of pneumonia among previously healthy gay men in Los Angeles, while physicians also observed Kaposi sarcoma, a rare cancer. Early labels such as GRID (“gay-related immune deficiency”) falsely suggested that AIDS affected only gay men. HIV can infect anyone through blood exposure; people with hemophilia were also affected after receiving contaminated transfusions. The term AIDS was adopted in 1982, but effective combination antiretroviral treatment did not become widely available until the mid-1990s. AIDS attacks the immune system, leaving people vulnerable to infections and cancers, and many patients in the 1980s became gravely ill without effective treatment.

The epidemic affected gay and bisexual men, people who injected drugs, people with hemophilia, heterosexual partners, women, and infants. Race and poverty shaped access to medical care, while fear far exceeded the evidence: HIV is not spread through casual contact, yet people with HIV faced denied services, job loss, and school exclusion. In 1987, Princess Diana shook hands with an AIDS patient without wearing gloves, helping communicate that touch did not transmit the disease. LGBTQ communities organized practical care, including meals, medical appointments, fundraising, safer-sex education, and support for people abandoned by family.

The crisis was worsened by stigma and inadequate public response. President Reagan did not deliver a major address devoted to AIDS until 1987, six years after the first CDC reports. Ryan White, a teenager with hemophilia who acquired HIV through treatment, was barred from public school in 1985; his case challenged the idea that AIDS affected only one stigmatized group. Activists argued that shame surrounding sexual health obstructed accurate information about transmission, condoms, prevention, and testing. They also distinguished slow government action from the efforts of doctors, researchers, nurses, and public health workers, while asking why patients’ needs did not receive a response proportionate to the emergency. Stigma could discourage disclosure and testing, and partners were sometimes excluded from hospital rooms or funerals.

ACT UP and the AIDS Memorial Quilt

ACT UP—the AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power—was founded in New York in 1987. Convinced that conventional appeals had failed while people were dying, its members used disruptive protests at government agencies, Wall Street, and religious institutions to force powerful organizations to address the epidemic. At a 1988 protest at the Food and Drug Administration, demonstrators demanded faster access to experimental drugs and changes to clinical trials. Activists studied immunology, drug development, and trial design, becoming informed critics of the medical system and helping patients gain a greater role in research and treatment policy. They also challenged high drug costs and unequal access to care. Their slogan, “Silence = Death,” linked government neglect, public shame, and pressure to hide LGBTQ lives to real consequences.

The AIDS Memorial Quilt began in 1987 through the Names Project, founded by activist Cleve Jones. Each panel commemorates someone who died of AIDS and may include a name, photograph, clothing, or personal objects. Panels measure roughly three by six feet—about the size of a grave—giving individual form to deaths that statistics can obscure. First displayed on the National Mall in Washington, D.C., in 1987, the quilt turned private mourning into a public monument at a time when families often could not or would not acknowledge how loved ones had died. Its panels, whether elaborately embroidered or made from simple materials, invited ordinary people to create a shared record. Unlike traditional war memorials, the quilt honored people whose deaths were often met with silence, shame, or blame, and it made the scale of the national crisis visible.

Legal Victories and Questions About Identity

Over time, major LGBTQ organizations increasingly pursued legal reforms concerning employment discrimination, relationships, military service, and laws criminalizing same-sex intimacy. In Lawrence v. Texas (2003), the Supreme Court invalidated remaining laws criminalizing consensual same-sex activity. In Obergefell v. Hodges (2015), it recognized a constitutional right to same-sex marriage. These decisions had practical consequences for inheritance, medical decision-making, benefits, family recognition, and custody arrangements.

At the same time, queer theory questioned whether categories such as gay, straight, man, and woman were as stable as society assumed. It asks not only why particular identities are stigmatized, but also how social rules define and police those categories. Judith Butler argues that repeated enforcement of gender roles helps make them appear natural; this does not mean that people can simply choose any identity at will, since social expectations can be enforced through punishment. Marriage equality can protect couples while preserving the idea that marriage is the most legitimate form of relationship, and public visibility can reduce stigma while exposing some people to new risks. The lecture frames this as a tension between gaining equality within existing rules and seeking freedom from restrictive rules themselves.

James Baldwin on Race, Sexuality, and Masculinity

In “Here Be Dragons,” James Baldwin defines androgyny not as a particular anatomy or appearance, but as possessing qualities that culture assigns to both sexes. Love, he argues, requires emotional resources that society divides into masculine and feminine categories. He suggests that people fear those who reveal qualities they refuse to recognize in themselves; a person labeled a “freak” can expose the instability of supposedly secure identities.

Baldwin connects sexuality to an American ideal of masculinity built on toughness, dominance, independence, and rejection of femininity. Culture organizes experience into oppositions—such as cowboys and Indians, good and bad, tough and soft—and pressures people to fit them. He also links gender stereotypes to a society shaped by slavery and racial domination, where ideas about gender helped establish who held power and who was expected to submit. Insults about being feminine or gay function as tools to discipline people who do not perform approved manhood.

Baldwin’s account of Greenwich Village complicates the assumption that bohemian spaces automatically offer freedom. There, he encounters racial objectification shaped by white fantasies about Black masculinity and sexuality. His experience shows that discrimination cannot be reduced to sexuality alone: race shapes the desire, suspicion, and humiliation a person may encounter even among other marginalized people. Baldwin’s argument asks whether the solution is simply to include more men in a narrow ideal of manhood or to question the ideal itself.

Judith Butler on Imitation and Gender

In “Imitation and Gender Insubordination,” Judith Butler questions what it means to identify publicly as a lesbian. A label can help people organize, find one another, and claim rights, but it cannot fully describe a person and can impose expectations about who counts as an authentic group member. Coming out is not necessarily a single disclosure that makes identity transparent: someone may be out in one setting and not another, and identity can mean different things depending on who is listening. Butler therefore considers how identity can be used politically without treating it as a permanent, universal definition.

Butler also challenges the idea that heterosexuality is the original and homosexuality merely a copy. Heterosexual gender roles must repeatedly reproduce recognizable gestures of masculinity and femininity to appear natural. People are taught how to sit, dress, speak, flirt, and move through space, and those who do not comply may be corrected or punished. Repeated acts create the appearance of a stable masculine or feminine essence. Butler asks why heterosexual roles should be treated as originals when they also depend on imitation.

Butch and femme identities can reveal how constructed gender roles are, but Butler does not claim that all gender nonconformity is automatically liberating. Performances can reproduce familiar hierarchies as well as disturb them. Her argument goes beyond asking society to accept more identities: it examines how the boundary between normal and abnormal came to seem obvious and what becomes possible when that boundary is recognized as unstable.

Leslie Feinberg’s Stone Butch Blues: Childhood and Gender Policing

Leslie Feinberg’s Stone Butch Blues follows Jess Goldberg’s experience of gender policing from childhood. Rather than begin with definitions, the novel shows people reacting to Jess’s body, name, clothing, and behavior. Jess remembers the warmth of a Diné household that helped raise them, contrasted with the emotional coldness of their birth family. This contrast shows that care and belonging do not always come from the people society says should provide them. When one of the Diné women predicts that Jess will have a difficult life, Jess’s parents respond with fear and withdraw from those who had shown Jess affection.

At school, a teacher questions Jess’s name and publicly singles them out as Jewish, showing how classrooms teach which identities are treated as normal. Adults repeatedly ask whether Jess is a boy or a girl, demanding an explanation of Jess’s gender and expression. Jess initially accepts that demand and feels shame, revealing how such questions can exercise power rather than express innocent curiosity. Near a pond, Jess asks a crow the same question people ask; the bird simply caws, offering no judgment and exposing the human-made nature of rigid classification.

That brief freedom ends when neighborhood boys attack Jess, pull at their clothes, inspect their body, and lock them in a coal bin. They believe anatomy should settle identity and feel entitled to enforce that belief through violence. Jess’s father then punishes them instead of focusing on the harm they suffered, showing how family rules can reproduce broader gender expectations. The novel also places this violence in a working-class neighborhood divided by a labor strike, where children inherit conflicts over strikebreaking. Jess’s mother tells them it can be better to let boys think they are stronger, capturing a hierarchy that expects girls to confirm boys’ superiority. At synagogue, Jess is pressured to wear a dress to participate, making belonging conditional on performing an approved gender role.

Leslie Feinberg’s Stone Butch Blues: Community and Its Limits

As Jess grows older, they find a lesbian bar and meet butches and femmes for the first time. After being treated throughout childhood as fundamentally wrong, Jess encounters people who look and behave like them and realizes they are not alone. They also learn that this community has its own social codes: butches often adopt masculine clothing and behavior, while femmes embrace conventional femininity. Jess is initially frightened by Butch Al but is drawn to Al’s confidence and strength. Al’s clothing and presentation—including binding her breasts—show Jess a form of masculinity that does not depend on being male.

Al becomes Jess’s mentor, offering affection and guidance in a masculine style. Her tenderness challenges the assumption that masculinity means emotional distance. Still, the bar is not a perfect alternative to heterosexual society. Conflicts between butches escalate, and Al expects Jess to defend themself despite Jess’s fear. Jacqueline and Mona offer protection, showing that solidarity exists alongside expectations of toughness. Jess has escaped punishment for failing to conform to traditional femininity, but now encounters a different set of expectations about assertiveness and fighting. Feinberg shows that marginalized communities can develop their own rules about gender and acceptable behavior.

The later fates of people in the community complicate Jess’s memories of the bar: Yvette is murdered, Mona dies of an overdose, and Jacqueline struggles with heroin addiction. The community provides belonging, but it cannot remove the dangers imposed by a society that marginalizes its members. The novel connects these pressures to the everyday enforcement of gender described by Butler and to Baldwin’s account of how masculinity is maintained through ridicule and threat.

Robert Mapplethorpe and the Politics of Representation

Robert Mapplethorpe’s 1989 exhibition The Perfect Moment became a major dispute over censorship and public arts funding. His photographs use controlled lighting, symmetrical compositions, and references to classical sculpture, challenging the assumption that erotic subjects cannot also be formally beautiful. The controversy showed that museums are not neutral: decisions about what can be displayed reflect judgments about bodies, desire, and respectability.

In a 1980 self-portrait, Mapplethorpe presents himself with makeup and softened features, using a more conventionally feminine appearance. In Agitow, a nude figure curls inward, becoming almost sculptural; the pose withholds an easy narrative and invites comparison with the Western tradition of idealized bodies. In Ken Moody and Robert Sherman (1984), two men appear in a carefully balanced composition that contrasts their bodies. The image raises questions about who controls the representation of racialized bodies and whether aesthetic abstraction can hide unequal power. Together, the photographs make viewers consider how bodies become ideals, objects of desire, and classical visual forms, providing a counterpoint to Baldwin’s critique of racialized masculinity.

Keith Haring and Gran Fury: Images Against Silence

Keith Haring’s 1989 poster Ignorance = Fear, Silence = Death uses his familiar bold figures and direct graphic style for an urgent message about AIDS. Three figures cover their eyes, ears, and mouths, invoking refusal to see, hear, or speak. The title presents ignorance and silence as sources of danger: refusing to discuss sex or acknowledge the epidemic made education and prevention harder. The poster’s simple, widely recognizable visual language works on streets, flyers, and museum walls, making accessibility part of its politics. It also shows that institutional silence is not neutral because its consequences fall on people already facing stigma.

Gran Fury, an activist collective associated with ACT UP, created the 1989 campaign Kissing Doesn’t Kill: Greed and Indifference Do. The campaign borrowed the polished look of commercial advertising but placed same-sex and interracial couples kissing at its center. By using a familiar format for images of intimacy, it challenged viewers to question which kinds of affection they had been taught to accept. Its slogan redirected attention from kissing to greed and indifference, distinguishing the actual mechanisms of the epidemic from prejudice against those affected. Designed for public spaces such as streets, buses, and advertising surfaces, the campaign made everyday surroundings a site of political argument.

Felix Gonzalez-Torres and Public Mourning

Felix Gonzalez-Torres’s Untitled (Portrait of Ross in L.A.) (1991) consists of wrapped candies weighing a total of 175 pounds, the healthy weight of his partner Ross Lacock, who died of AIDS. Unlike a conventional portrait, the work does not preserve a recognizable likeness. Viewers are invited to take candy, so the pile physically diminishes and loss takes place in front of them through their participation. The pile can be replenished, complicating the metaphor: Ross’s death cannot be reversed, but care, memory, and renewal continue.

The work connects strangers to a private love that might otherwise remain invisible in public culture. Like the AIDS Memorial Quilt, it turns personal mourning into a public encounter, but it does so through absence, repetition, and audience participation rather than through names and individual panels. Both works insist that people lost to AIDS deserve to be remembered.

Conclusion: Equality, Liberation, and Public Memory

The LGBTQ rights movement was not only a campaign to change laws; it also challenged everyday assumptions about who can appear in public, who can be loved, and whose life deserves protection and remembrance. Baldwin questions the rigid ideal of American manhood, Butler examines why gender identities are treated as unquestionable originals, and Feinberg shows how those expectations are enforced through ordinary interactions and violence. Mapplethorpe makes bodies and desire visible, Haring and Gran Fury demand a response to public indifference, and Gonzalez-Torres asks viewers to participate in remembering someone lost.

The lecture closes with a central question: does equality mean being admitted into existing institutions, or can genuine liberation require changing the institutions and categories themselves?

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

Full transcript of “The LGBTQ+ Experience”. Click a timestamp to open the video at that moment. Need another video? Use the YouTube transcript generator.

0:02 Hello everyone. So this week we're going to be looking at the LGBTQ rights movement. And as with our previous units, I really want you to pay attention to the gap between what Americans claimed to believe about freedom and the lives that people were actually permitted to live. Uh we're going to begin with the historical movement and then we will turn to um our three readings that disagree in pretty productive ways about gender and identity. And then finally we are going to turn to some art that brought these arguments into um more direct public view. Okay, so before we get into organized activism, um I want you to remember our discussion of the postwar ideal of the

0:47 suburban nuclear family. So marriage was presented not merely as one possible way of life, but as evidence of maturity, morality, and overall good citizenship. Um a husband was expected to earn wages and then the wife was expected to maintain the home and raise children. This ideal was never really a true description of every American family. Um we know that women worked and unmarried people would form households together. Uh queer communities existed during this time. Um what matters that is schools, churches medicine advertising employers all reinforced that one arrangement was normal and they treated

1:32 deviations of that arrangement as personal failures. And before we move on, we really should distinguish sexuality from gender expression. So someone might be targeted during this time for loving a person of the same sex, but someone else might be targeted simply for dressing or behaving in ways that others considered inappropriate for their sex. So for example, until the 1970s, uh most public schools and of employment required that girls or women wear skirts or dresses. State sodomy laws criminalized particular sex acts and that occurred regardless of whether these were private acts or not.

2:19 Police could use disorderly conduct laws entrapment and liquor regulations to harass people at bars and other gathering places. [snorts] Police officers would pose as gay men and then they would proposition suspects only to arrest them if they then agreed to engage in sexual activity. And arrests had consequences that went far beyond just a prison sentence. Newspapers would print people's names, you could get fired by your employer, families could discover relationships that people had concealed for their own safety. So the law effectively made visibility extremely dangerous. Bars were crucial because people needed

3:05 somewhere where they could meet one another, but these were also very vulnerable spaces. Some owners of bars would pay off police or organized crime figures to try to protect their bar. [snorts] When we get to the Stonewall riots later in the lecture, I want you to remember that the question was not simply whether patrons wanted a night out to have fun and meet people. It was really about whether they could occupy a public space being themselves without fear of intimidation. So we've already discussed the Red Scare and McCarthyism. We briefly touched on the Lavender Scare, but the Lavender Scare developed alongside the Red Scare and McCarthyism

3:51 where federal officials portrayed gays and lesbians as security risks. So the supposed logic was that a person hiding a relationship could then be blackmailed by a foreign communist government. Um, I want you to notice the circular reasoning here. So the government is treating homosexuality as shameful. It's then making people conceal it, [snorts] and then they're citing that concealment as evidence that they're untrustworthy. So Eisenhower's Executive Order 10450 in 1953 expanded federal security screening and was used to exclude people that were accused of quote unquote sexual misconduct.

4:36 Um, essentially careers were destroyed without any evidence that these workers had ever betrayed any government secrets. Um, the larger historical point is that uh Cold War conformity was enforced not only through pop culture, but through the actual machinery of the state. Now Al Alfred Kinsey was a biologist at the Indiana State University who been researching human sexuality during the 1940s. Um, this was that time when homosexuality was widely condemned as immoral and it was classified in the DSM as a mental illness. Now Kinsey conducted thousands of interviews um about American sexual

5:23 experiences including things like premarital sex, adultery, masturbation, and homosexuality. And his findings revealed that Americans' actual sexual behavior frequently contradicted those traditional expectations. Um, in 1948 he published Sexual Behavior in the Human Male and then he followed that up with Sexual Behavior in the Human Female in 1953. Both of these reports generated enormous controversy um because they very frankly and openly discussed sexuality and they revealed that far more Americans than it was assumed had same sex encounters or same sex fantasies. He also developed the Kinsey scale, which placed sexuality along this

6:10 continuum shown on the slide from exclusively heterosexual to exclusively homosexual. Uh this challenged the assumption that everybody belonged to one of two distinct categories. It was truly groundbreaking at the time, but uh I think now it really feels limited as it's placing sexuality on a clear binary scale when sexuality can really be far more complicated than that. So although his research had some limitations, it really helped challenge the medical and moral stigmatization of homosexuality and it influenced changing attitudes towards sexuality in the decades to come.

6:56 I want us to understand too that even during this time of intense persecution and suspicion, LGBTQ people formed societies that were aimed toward liberation. So we have the Mattachine Society, which began in Los Angeles in 1950 and it initially encouraged gay men to understand themselves as minorities with shared political interests rather than just isolated individuals that had some kind of private problem. We also have the Daughters of Bilitis, which began in San Francisco in 1955. It was a social alternative for lesbians who really had few to no safe public gathering spaces. Um its magazine The Ladder became a very

7:42 important way to circulate ideas and advice um and news about the LGBT Q community all across the United States. But both of these groups really had to confront a very difficult strategic question. How could um they openly organize without then exposing members to uh things like arrest, firing, or rejection by their family? So their caution was not just uh timidity. It reflected the actual dangers of being identified publicly. At the same time, a politics centered on proving that gay and lesbian people were respectable could marginalize those who didn't fit um middle class standards of appearance or gender or behavior.

8:32 LGBTQ people also attempted to create safe spaces where they could express themselves at least somewhat openly. Um Compton's cafeteria was a late night cafeteria in San Francisco's Tenderloin uh where transgender women, drag queens, sex workers um all could gather together. Many of these people had been pushed out of the more respectable public spaces. So, a place to just sit and talk and hang out with like-minded people really carried enormous importance at this time. In 1966 after um Compton's had dealt with repeated police harassment, patrons decided to resist officers during an attempted roundup. [snorts] Um accounts describe uh thrown coffee and dishes,

9:18 damaged windows. There was fighting in the streets. Um the precise sequence of the events are really difficult for historians to reconstruct because um this confrontation really pre- predates any direct um any any direct historical analysis of these kinds of movements. But the important thing to understand is that um the confrontation predates Stonewall by several years and it reminds us that transgender and gender non-conforming people were really not late additions to LGBTQ activism. They were already resisting the policing of public space, of their appearance, and of their basic means of survival.

10:03 This era also included attempts to sort of rebrand homosexuality to emphasize respectability. Though the term homophile emphasized affection rather than sexual behavior. Um, activists use it because they wanted to shift public discussion away from the assumption that gay identity was only about sex. Uh, some organizations um held very carefully managed demonstrations with formal dress codes where men wore suits and ties and women wore dresses. They really wanted the public to see um that they could look like conventional respectable Americans. Um, I think that we can understand this strategy without assuming that it's sufficient. Uh, the approach is trying

10:49 to win acceptance by showing similarity to heterosexual society. But the problem with that is that it also implicitly accepts that unconventional appearance undermines a claim to rights. Um, this is mirrored pretty well in early lesbian culture. So 1950s lesbian bars uh strictly separated individuals into butch or femme personas. And this imitated the traditional pairing of a woman with a man where the butch would act as the man and the femme would act as the woman. Um, we're going to see this uh more clearly when we read Feinberg's uh Stone Butch Blues. The sexual revolution uh which we

11:36 discussed in earlier lectures emerged on alongside the counterculture and women's liberation movement and it challenged traditional expectations surrounding marriage, reproduction, and sexual morality. Um, the introduction of the birth control pill really helped separate sexual activity from reproduction um while feminists uh continue to challenge those sexual double standards that granted men greater sexual freedom than women. However, um much of this new found sexual freedom really remains centered on heterosexual relationships. Uh, gay and lesbian Americans continued to face criminal prosecution, employment discrimination, and widespread social stigma. So, gay liberation activists challenged

12:22 the contradiction. They argued that sexual freedom could extend to same-sex relationships. And unlike the earlier homophile organizations, they increasingly embraced public visibility and pride rather than emphasizing conformity and respectability. In 1973, um, after some extreme pressure from gay activists and, um, changing psychiatric perspectives of the decade, uh, the American Psychiatric Association finally removed homosexuality as a mental disorder from its diagnostic manual. Um, so the sexual revolution raised disagreements about things like gender roles monogamy um pornography and sexual autonomy. And these debates

13:07 influenced feminist and queer theory, and, uh, that would include Judith Judith Butler's, uh, later arguments about the social construction of gender and sexuality that we're going to get into later. Now, a moment that really crystallized calls for gay liberation was the Stonewall uprising in 1969. To understand Stonewall, we need to understand why a gay bar is so important. Um, so in 1969, openly gay social life was severely restricted. Um, as we already discussed, people risked losing their jobs, their families, um, their housing if they were identified publicly as homosexual. So, bars were,

13:54 um, among the few places where gay people could meet, they could dance together, and they could develop a sense of community. So, the Stonewall Inn in Greenwich Village was operated by the Mafia, and it catered to a relatively diverse clientele, and that included gay men, drag queens, um, um non-conforming people. Uh, there were some homeless LGBTQ youth um who went to Stonewall. And so it wasn't a glamorous or particularly safe establishment to begin with. Um for example, there was no running water behind the bar um and police raids occurred at at least on a weekly basis. So New York police enforced laws against disorderly conduct and they used liquor regulations and gender-related policing

14:40 to harass patrons. Um they would come in and demand identification, arrest people, and then they would publicly expose their sexuality. Um so raids were very frightening, but they were a familiar occurrence. The lights would come on, people would line up, and then officers would check your identification. But in the early hours of June 28th, 1969, police came in for a typical raid of Stonewall. But this time uh the patrons and the people gathering outside decided to resist. So as the officers tried to make arrests, the crowd grew bigger and bigger, people started throwing objects, um the police eventually had to barricade themselves inside the bar. Um and then the confrontation spilled out and continued on the streets.

15:27 I would say that it's kind of tempting to describe Stonewall as one spontaneous riot that created the LGBTQ movement overnight, but that's not truly accurate. Um there had already been years of activism and earlier confrontations like the one at Compton's Cafeteria. Um so what made Stonewall especially consequential was the sustained organizing that immediately followed it. So protests and confrontations over Stonewall continued for several nights. And participants didn't really share all the same goals or experiences. Some wanted an end to police harassment, others wanted the freedom to express their gender openly, and still others were demanding more

16:13 fundamental transformation of society. Um Stonewall's lasting importance is that anger over everyday policing was transformed into this more public and confrontational movement. Instead of treating homosexuality as something to conceal or apologize for, activists insisted that society itself needed to change. So Stonewall was a turning point that helped initiate broader movements for acceptance, safety, and toleration. The Gay Liberation Front emerged shortly after Stonewall. Um, even its name matters. So liberation connected this organization to the language of anti-war activism, to black liberation, and to

17:00 the other um radical movements for social change that we saw in the 1960s. So rather than asking for only tolerance, activists are questioning the social institutions that made heterosexuality compulsory and treated gender conformity as normal. This did produce some disagreements, so some activists wanted specific reforms, um others wanted a broader transformation of society. And so when we read Judith Butler's essay, you can see an intellectual version of this question. Uh, is the goal to secure recognition for a stable identity or is the goal to challenge the rules by which identities become recognizable at all?

17:46 In 1970, activists marked the anniversary of Stonewall with marches, including the Christopher Street Liberation Day in New York. These weren't initially commercialized festivals that we often associate with Pride today. Um, marching at this time meant risking identification in a society where being known as gay or lesbian would cost you your job, your housing, your family support. So public visibility itself was a political act. Um, Pride really reverses the logic of shame. So instead of treating sexuality as something to hide or apologize for, participants could assert that there was really nothing disgraceful about their lives to begin with.

18:33 But there were movements that countered this growth um for the LGBTQ community. So in 1971 um singer and activist Anita Bryant led a campaign to repeal the Miami-Dade County ordinance that prohibited discrimination based on sexual orientation. Um her slogan was Save Our Children, and it framed gay rights as a threat to children rather than as a question of equal treatment. Um this kind of rhetoric is powerful because it converted discrimination uh into a supposed act of protection. It implied without any evidence that gay people um are inherently dangerous to children, particularly since they couldn't have children of their own. So the idea was that they have to convert

19:18 children to homosexuality to further their quote-unquote gay agenda. Um voters did repeal the ordinance, and this defeat um then helped mobilize LGBTQ activists nationally. Um while the campaign uh anticipated arguments that would recur in later disputes over things like schools, families, and public public visibility for uh members of the LGBTQ community. Now in 1977 Harvey Milk became one of the first openly gay elected officials in the United States when he won a seat on San Francisco's Board of Supervisors. Um his victory challenged the idea that gay people could participate in politics

20:04 only by concealing their sexual orientation. Milk argued that coming out could change politics by making gay people visible as regular people, as neighbors, relatives, or co-workers rather than just as abstract stereotypes. Um but this strategy required personal risk, which really wasn't evenly distributed. He opposed California's Proposition 6, which was the Briggs initiative, which would have permitted dismissal of gay and lesbian public school employees. Um, voters rejected it in 1978. But in November of 1978, former supervisor Dan White assassinated Milk and Mayor Joe George Moscone. Um, White was convicted of voluntary manslaughter

20:51 rather than murder. And this provoked the White Night riots in 1979. Um, the case really exposed deep mistrust between LGBTQ communities and the legal system. So we also need to remember that not everyone experienced the movement in the same way. Um, a white gay man could afford to live independently. Um, he might face very different risks from a black lesbian or a transgender sex worker or a working-class person who's dependent on family financial support. So black feminist lesbians, including the Combahee River Collective, which we've already discussed, um, argued that

21:38 racism, sexism, class oppression, and homophobia can't be understood only as isolated problems. Their experiences did not fit neatly into movements that only addressed one form of inequality at a time. Um, these tensions are not just theoretical. They influenced whose concerns received funding, um, whose leaders were visible, uh, which neighborhoods were policed, and whether political campaigns prioritized employment or housing or healthcare or even the right to marry. Lesbians also criticized male dominance within gay organizations while LGBTQ people of color challenged racism within predominantly white movements. Um, class and access to healthcare really shaped whose needs were heard.

22:25 And the word that describes the interconnecting elements of identity is intersectionality, which we've discussed in previous lectures. Um, intersectionality is a very useful framework for James Baldwin's essay where he describes how um being black changes his experience of gay social spaces. Um, it's also helpful for Leslie Feinberg um whose narrative ties gender policing to working class life and labor conflict. All right. So now we're moving into a period when LGBTQ communities faced a different kind of emergency, one that would be completely devastating and reverberate in memory for decades to

23:10 come. Uh, in 1981 the CDC reported some unusual cases of pneumonia among previously healthy gay men in Los Angeles. Um, physicians also started noticing Kaposi sarcoma, which is a rare cancer in otherwise healthy young men. So at first researchers did not understand what connected these illnesses. Um, some early labels like grid or gay-related immune deficiency helped create this false assumption that um AIDS was an exclusively gay men's disease. Uh, we should understand that HIV can infect anyone through blood-based exposure. So another group that was widely affected was hemophiliacs who need regular blood transfusions and were unknowingly uh receiving tainted

23:56 transfusions. Um, the association with homosexuality nevertheless shaped how the public interpreted the epidemic and how urgently institutions responded. So by 1982 the term AIDS was adopted. Um, HIV, the virus that causes AIDS was identified in the early 1980s, but effective combination antiretroviral treatment would not become widely available until Um, so for many patients that were diagnosed in the 1980s, this disease was absolutely terrifying because there was so little that medicine could do to stop its progression. The illness attacks the immune system and so it leaves people vulnerable to infections and cancers that their body

24:42 would ordinarily be able to fight. Um, friends and families would have to watch um their loved one become gravely ill often over a very short period of time. Um, we need to remember that this is not an abstract debate about sexuality. It was the experience of enormous repeated loss of life. Um, this epidemic also exposed inequalities within the LGBTQ community and the country more broadly. Um, gay and bisexual men were heavily affected, but also people who injected drugs or hemophiliacs, um heterosexual partners, um women and infants were all also affected. Um, things like race and poverty affected access to medical care.

25:28 Uh, so public health resources really shaped people's experiences. [gasps] Fear of transmission of AIDS often also exceeded the scientific evidence. So HIV is not spread through casual contact. Yet um patients were sometimes refused services, workers lost their jobs, um children with with HIV faced exclusion from schools. So the public fear of illness became intertwined with existing prejudice. Um, in 1987 Princess Diana shook hands with an AIDS patient without a glove on and this raised international visibility for how the disease was transmitted and it helped spread awareness that touching an AIDS patient is not going to put a

26:13 healthy person at risk. Um, communities did develop their own responses and their own networks of care. Um, volunteers delivered food, um they accompanied patients to their appointments, they helped raise money for treatment, um they organized safer sex education and they cared for people that had been abandoned by their families. This is really important because it shows that activism is not only protest. It's also about the practical work of keeping people alive or helping people have dignity in death. And so by the time effective combination treatments uh transformed HIV care in the mid 1990s, this epidemic had already killed hundreds of thousands of Americans. Treatment was a major

27:00 scientific breakthrough, but it did not erase the losses or guarantee equal access to medication. So my uncle was a gay man who died from AIDS in 1991 and my mother has truly never healed from the tragic loss of her brother. Uh she was working as a teacher's aide at the time and she had to face backlash from parents who were concerned that she could somehow pass it to their children if she visited and cared for her brother. She was very lucky at the time to have a principal that supported her through this. I also had a theater professor who lost almost his entire community of friends to AIDS in the '80s and '90s. Um he managed to escape the disease because he had been in a committed relationship with another man that was exclusive, but

27:45 when they broke up, his ex-boyfriend contracted the disease and also died. Um ultimately the AIDS epidemic created a massive cultural crisis and it asked the question, who would record the lives of the dead and who um or how could people make a wider public acknowledgment of these losses when we were often treating them as unworthy of mourning? It's also important that we discuss the language used to describe AIDS. So when newspapers and politicians um treated the epidemic as punishment for supposedly immoral behavior, um they encouraged the public to see sick people

28:31 as responsible for their own suffering rather than as people who deserved care. Um, President Reagan did not deliver any major public address devoted to AIDS until 1987. This is six years after the first CDC reports. Um, federal research and public health efforts didn't develop and uh did not develop during the 1980s very effectively. Um, activists criticized the pace, the scale, and the public messaging of the response while the death toll continued to rise. We could consider, for example, the case of Ryan White. Um, so Ryan was a teenager from Indiana who acquired HIV through treatment for his hemophilia. Um, but in 1985 he was barred from attending public school because parents

29:17 and officials feared that he could infect his classmates. So his case made it harder for the public to pretend that AIDS affected only one stigmatized group. The crisis also exposed the consequences of treating sexual health as something shameful to discuss. Um, accurate information about things like condoms or safer sex or um accurate information regarding how the disease is transmitted um could prevent infections. But we had these moral objections to frank public uh discussion, and that created massive obstacles. We should also take a moment to distinguish the government's uneven response from the work of individual doctors and researchers, nurses, public

30:02 health officials. Many of these people were trying desperately to understand the virus and to treat patients. The central political question is why their work and the needs of patients did not receive a response proportionate with the scale of the emergency. Um, activists would argue that silence itself is dangerous. So when people are afraid to disclose their diagnosis, um seek testing or discuss prevention, then stigma could contribute directly to the further spread of the virus. Um, the epidemic also exposed the consequences of treating some lives as less valuable than others. Um, patients sometimes faced rejection by medical providers and families could exclude surviving

30:48 partners from hospital rooms or from the funeral of their loved one. Now ACT UP stands for the AIDS Coalition to Unleash Power. It was founded in New York in 1987 and it emerged from the conviction that conventional appeals had failed and people were dying while officials and pharmaceutical companies were moving at a glacial pace. ACT UP used direct action and deliberately disruptive protest. So members staged demonstrations at government agencies, on Wall Street, and at religious institutions. And their aim was to make the epidemic impossible for power powerful institutions to continue

31:33 to ignore. Um, one famous action took place at the Food and Drug Administration in 1988. Um, protesters demanded faster access to experimental drugs um and changes to clinical trial procedures. They argued that people facing a life-threatening disease should have a meaningful voice in decisions about which risks they could accept. Um, members educated themselves in immunology, drug development, and clinical trial design. Um, they became unusually sophisticated critics of the medical system and they helped change how patients could participate in research and treatment policy. ACT UP also confronted the cost of medication and inequalities in access to care. Um, a drug is not much of a

32:19 victory if the people who need it can't afford it or can't enter the health system that distributes it. Um, their their main slogan was silence equals death and this connected the political with the personal. Silence could mean government neglect, public shame, and refusal to discuss safer sex um or the pressure on LGBTQ people to hide their lives. Each kind of silence has real consequences. Now let's take a look at the AIDS Memorial Quilt. So the AIDS Memorial Quilt, um, began in 1987 through the Names Project. It was founded by activist Cleve Jones. Each of its panels commemorate people who died of AIDS, and it incorporates

33:05 their names, sometimes photographs, um, pieces of their clothing or objects that were associated with their lives. Um, each panel in this quilt is roughly 3 x 6 ft, which is about the size of a human grave. And that physical scale really matters. Um, when we look at death statistics, those can be difficult for us to really wrap our brains around. But when we see a 3 x 6 ft panel, it imagine it it really asks us to imagine one particular person who is now dead because of AIDS. So this quilt was first displayed on the National Mall in Washington D.C. in 1987, and thousands of individual acts of mourning then became, um, a public

33:52 monument demanding national attention at a time when many families were unable or unwilling to acknowledge how their loved ones had died. Some of these panels are very beautifully embroidered, but others are handmade with very simple materials. Um, their value doesn't depend on artistic training. And so this quilt deliberately makes space for ordinary people to create, um, an artistic and historical record. Think about the contrast between this and, say, traditional war memorials. So the quilt commemorates people whose deaths were frequently not met with public honor, but with silence and shame and blame. And so it insists that these lives also deserve to be remembered.

34:37 Um, the quilt also turns private grief into collective action. So families, partners, and friends who might otherwise mourn alone can now see their losses alongside thousands of others. And this really reveals the huge scale of this national crisis. Now over time, major organizations increasingly emphasized legal reforms. So that included protection from employment discrimination, the recognition of gay relationships, um issues involving military service, and the repeal of laws criminalizing

35:23 same-sex intimacy. So in Lawrence v. Texas in 2003, the Supreme Court invalidated those remaining laws that criminalized consensual same-sex activity. Um and then Obergefell v. Hodges in 2015 uh recognized a constitutional right to same-sex marriage. Um these victories matter materially. So legal recognition, especially of a marriage, can infect things like um like inheritance, um medical decision making, benefits, um and the ability to build a family without the state refusing to acknowledge it. So take for example um a situation where um a person in a homosexual relationship um has a partner who is in the hospital, they can't make

36:09 medical decisions for them if they are not legally married. Um or a situation where they have children together, either adopted or um via um surrogacy or via um uh in vitro fertilization for lesbian couples. Um if they were to break up, how do we um deal with custody of the children? If their marriage is not declared valid, we can't answer these questions. So by the late and early 1990s, some activists and scholars were questioning whether the categories of gay, straight, man, woman are really as stable as society assumes.

36:57 So, queer theory asks not only why certain identities are stigmatized, but how the categories themselves are produced and policed. The question shifts from who belongs to this group or that group to who establishes the rules for belonging in the first place. So, Judith Butler's argument, which we'll look at a little closer later about imitation, is especially interesting. So, if heterosexual gender roles have to be constantly repeated and enforced, then maybe they're not as natural as we claim them to be. This isn't the claim that individuals can just choose any identity at any time at will. Social expectations are powerful because

37:44 people encounter them repeatedly and they can be punished for failing to comply with them. Now, I want to finish the history section by distinguishing equality under existing rules from liberation from rules that are themselves restrictive. So, marriage equality, for example, can protect couples while also leaving intact assumptions that marriage is the most legitimate legal form of a relationship. Public visibility can reduce stigma while also exposing some people to new risks. The movement has never had one answer to these tensions, and that's why our readings really matter. So, Baldwin is going to question the American ideal of manhood, while Butler is going to examine the

38:30 instability of identity, and then Feinberg will show what those social expectations feel like when they're enforced against a child. As we move to literature, pay attention to where the authors agree and where their perspectives create complications for one another. All right, let's turn to literature. So we have discussed um James Baldwin before in our civil rights unit. But in Here Be Dragons, Baldwin begins by talking about androgyne which he defines not as having a particular anatomy or a particular appearance, but really as possessing internal qualities

39:17 that are culturally assigned to both sexes. Um he insists that love itself requires access to emotional resources that society tries to divide into the binary of masculine versus feminine. Baldwin then moves on to make a pretty unsettling observation. So people fear figures who reveal qualities that they don't want to recognize in themselves. So his discussion of the hermaphrodite isn't really about medical classification. It's more about how a person labeled a quote unquote freak um can expose the instability in everyone else's supposedly secure identity. Now he connects American sexuality to the national myth of masculinity.

40:03 Um the ideal American man must be tough, dominant, uh independent, and above all um in no way feminine. So notice how Baldwin lists oppositions. So cowboys and Indians, good guys versus bad guys, tough guys and softies. Um he's arguing that culture organizes human experience into these crude binaries and then expects real people to fit into them. Um he also has a racial argument. American masculinity developed in a society organized by slavery and racial domination. So Baldwin doesn't treat gender stereotypes as separate from the historical need to establish who has power and who must submit. Um Um, his account then of up in Harlem

40:50 makes clear that insults about gender and sexuality are tools of cultural discipline. Um, being called feminine or gay isn't simply a description of a person. It's a way of threatening someone who has failed to perform the approved version of manhood. One of the most important turns in the essay is his description of Greenwich Village. Um, we might expect a bohemian neighborhood to offer freedom from conventional morality, but instead Baldwin encounters racial objectification within spaces that are supposed to reject sexual conformity. Um, he describes being viewed through white fantasies about black masculinity and sexuality. Um, and this is why we can't flatten his argument into just gay

41:36 people experience discrimination. His position as a black man shapes what kind of desire, suspicion, and humiliation he encounters, even among other marginalized people. So the essay ultimately suggests that liberation requires more than allowing different sexual identities to exist. It requires questioning the ideal of masculinity that makes vulnerability shameful or difference threatening and then domination appear natural. So as you read Baldwin, I want you to ask yourselves whether the problem is that some men are excluded from the category of real man or whether the category itself has really become so narrow that it damages everyone who

42:22 tries to inhabit it. All right, let's look at Judith Butler's Imitation and Gender Insubordination. So this essay is a little more theoretically difficult, so I want to walk through the argument rather than just reduce it to the phrase gender is a performance. So Butler begins by questioning what it means to speak publicly as a lesbian because the label seems to promise a stable identity even though no label can ever completely describe a person. So the politics of coming out initially appears straightforward. So someone moves from concealment into truth. But

43:07 Butler is questioning that picture. So a person may be out in one setting and not out in another and the meaning of an identity changes depending on um who is listening. So coming out is not necessarily one final disclosure after which identity becomes transparent. Um what this does is create a political uh a political dilemma really. So identity categories can help people organize. They can help people find one another and demand rights. But then they can also impose expectations about who counts as an authentic member of a group. So Butler wants to use identity politically without pretending that it has a permanent universal definition. So now let's consider the title word

43:55 imitation. So conventional thinking treats heterosexuality as an original and then homosexuality as a copy or a deviation. What Butler does is reverse that logic. So heterosexuality itself has to reproduce recognizable gestures of masculinity and femininity in order to appear natural. So think about for example the amount of instruction that is involved in things that are supposedly normal gender behavior. So things like how people are told to sit or dress um how they're told to speak um how they're taught to flirt with members of the opposite gender um or how they're supposed to move through space. So if these behaviors were simply

44:42 automatic expressions of biological sex, then why would society need to teach them and then correct them so often? So Butler's point is that repetition produces the appearance of an underlying identity. We learn to interpret repeated acts as evidence that a stable masculine or feminine essence was really there all along. And this helps explain why butch and fem identities matter to her argument. Um they're sometimes dismissed as copies of heterosexual male and female roles, but Butler asks why heterosexual roles should be granted the status of originals in the first place. Imitation can expose the constructed character of what it imitates.

45:28 Yet Butler doesn't claim that every instance of gender nonconformity is automatically liberating. So a performance can reproduce familiar hierarchies as easily as it can disturb them. So notice the difference between Butler and simple argument for tolerance. Butler is not merely saying that society should accept more identities. She is asking how the distinction between normal and abnormal came to seem so obvious to us in the first place. And then what happens when that distinction is revealed to be unstable? Finally, let's take a look at our excerpt from uh Leslie Feinberg's novel

46:15 Stone Butch Blues. So the novel asks us to experience gender policing through Jess Goldberg's experiences beginning in her childhood. So that difference in form matters. So instead of starting with some kind of definition, the novel makes us watch adults and children react to Jess's body, their name, their clothing, and their behavior. So early in the excerpt, Jess recalls being cared for by a Diné woman um in the Southwest. And the narrator contrasts two very distinct worlds. Um Jess's birth family's emotional coldness and then the warmth of the household that helps raise Jess. Um so this is not simply a sentimental

47:02 childhood memory. It's establishing that care and belonging don't always come from the family society when society says that the family should provide those things. So Jess's parents then react really fearfully when one of the DNA women predicts a difficult life for Jess. Um their response is pretty revealing. So rather than trying to understand or protect Jess, they then withdraw from the people who have shown Jess affection. Um this episode introduces a recurring pattern in which adults recognize difference and then respond with fear. So at school, the teacher questions the name Jess um and she insisted it's not a girl's name and then publicly singles Jess out

47:48 as Jewish. Um notice here how gender and religion become occasions for a teacher to mark a child as different in front of classmates. So a classroom is not a neutral space. It actively teaches which identities are supposed to be normal. Adults also repeatedly ask Jess whether they are a boy or a girl. And this makes uh it what makes this really so painful is that there's an assumption that strangers are entitled to demand an explanation for your gender and your expression. Um Jess initially accepts their right to ask and then responds with shame. Uh so the question is therefore an exercise of power, not just innocent curiosity.

48:39 Feinberg also gives us a striking contrast in the scene um that's set near the pond. So Jess asks a crow the same question that people keep asking them and the bird just caws. So nature offers no judgment. This moment really exposes how arbitrary and human-made demand for rigid classification is. But then that brief moment of feeling freedom is shattered when the boys from the neighborhood then come and attack Jess. They pull at their clothes, they try to inspect their body, and then they lock Jess in a coal bin. And the violence isn't just random bullying. They believe that Jess's anatomy has to settle the question of identity, and

49:25 then they feel entitled to enforce that knowledge in the open. What happens afterward is almost as disturbing. So Jess goes home and their father punishes them rather than responding primarily to that violence that Jess has just suffered through. So the family's concern with gender conformity then overrides the child's need for love and protection. So the novel is showing how institutional rules can be reproduced within these intimate familial relationships. Feinberg also locates Jess in a working-class community that is marked by a labor strike. So children have inherited their parents' divisions over strike breaking,

50:10 and the scab gang becomes this source of danger. So the novel places gender violence within a world that's already structured by economic conflict. So Jess's mother also tells Jess that sometimes it's better to let boys think that they're stronger. And that advice captures an entire gender hierarchy in one seemingly ordinary sentence. So girl is expected not only to be weaker, but to protect boys' belief in their superiority. Now the conflict over clothing at synagogue then adds another layer. So Jess is pressured into wearing a dress in order to participate in their religious community. So belonging is being offered on the condition of performing an approved gender role.

50:58 If Butler explains why gender categories require repeated enforcement, then Feinberg is showing what that enforcement looks like in everyday life. It looks like a teacher's remark or a stranger's question, maybe a parent's punishment or bullying of a child. So the theoretical argument then becomes a matter of safety, shame, and survival. And there's a connection to this in this reading to Baldwin as well. So both authors are showing how masculinity and femininity are maintained through ridicule and threat. Feinberg is emphasizing how those demands are experienced by a gender nonconforming child who really has little power to refuse them.

51:46 Now as Jess gets older, they discover a lesbian bar where they encounter butches and fems for the first time. This is a major turning point because throughout their childhood, Jess has been treated as if there's something fundamentally wrong with her. So she suddenly finds herself surrounded by people who look and behave like her and starts to understand that she isn't alone. One of the most interesting things about Jess's introduction to this community is that she has to learn its social rules. So the butches generally adopt masculine styles of dress and behavior, while the fems embrace conventional femininity. Another thing that's particularly interesting is Jess's reaction to Butch Al. So initially Al really terrifies her, but Jess is also fascinated by Al's

52:34 confidence and strength and masculine appearance. Feinberg takes a lot of time carefully describing Al's clothing, her body, her the way that she binds her breasts flat or the way that her jacket both reveals and conceals her body. And so Jess is encountering a version of masculinity that doesn't depend on being male. And then she's able to recognize something of herself in Al. Al eventually takes Jess under her wing and begins teaching her how to survive as a young butch in this uh community. And this relationship is very important because Jess has never really had an adult who could help her understand her gender identity. So Al becomes a kind of mentor, offering affection and guidance

53:22 in a distinctly masculine style. And the tenderness underneath Al's intimidating exterior really complicates the assumption that masculinity means um lack of emotion or emotional distance. But as we read, we see that the bar is not presented as some kind of perfect alternative to heterosexual society. Jess encounters conflict with Monique and then the situation escalates into a confrontation between different groups of butches. Um Al expects Jess to defend herself and to respond to the challenge um even though Jess is frightened and really just wants the confrontation to end. Um Jacqueline and Mona then help protect Jess and they show that care and solidarity exist alongside expectations

54:09 of toughness. Um this is something that I think is also particularly interesting about Feinberg's depiction. Jess has spent her childhood being punished for failing to conform to traditional femininity. But now within a community that accepts her masculine identity, she's encountering a different set of expectations about how she should behave. She's expected to be tough and assertive and willing to fight. So Feinberg's showing us that even marginalized communities can develop their own rules about gender and acceptable behavior. So finally the the later references to members of this community who have died or disappeared complicate Jess's memories of the bar. [snorts] Yvette's been murdered, Mona died from an

54:55 overdose, um Jacqueline is struggling with heroin addiction. And so the community that once offered Jess this extraordinary sense of belonging has also experienced tremendous suffering. So ultimately find Feinberg is reminding us that finding a community doesn't eliminate the dangers of living in a society that marginalizes its members. All right, let's move on to some examples of art from the height of the LGBTQ movement. Our first artist is Robert Mapplethorpe. Um his exhibition the Perfect Moment became a major flashpoint in debates over censorship and public arts funding

55:42 in 1989. So Mapplethorpe uses carefully controlled lighting, symmetrical compositions, and references to classical sculpture. The deliberate elegance of these photographs complicates the idea that erotic subject matter and formal artistic beauty are mutually exclusive. The controversy surrounding this exhibition raised questions about whose sexuality could be represented publicly. Um it also revealed that museums are not neutral spaces. So decisions about what deserves to be displayed reflect social judgments about bodies, desire, and respectability. So in the 1980 self-portrait on the left of

56:29 the slide, Mapplethorpe presents himself in more stereotypically feminine ways. He's wearing makeup. His features look soft. In Agitow in the middle, the nude figure is curling inward so that the body becomes almost sculptural. And the photograph really withholds an easy narrative or direct confrontation with the viewer. Its emphasis on shape and surface invites us to compare the male nude with the long tradition of idealized bodies in Western art. But in this case, it is not a white heterosexual male. It is a black homosexual male. And then finally Ken Moody and Robert Sherman from 1984 um on the right uh places two men in this carefully staged composition that

57:15 emphasizes contrast between their two bodies and balance. So we shouldn't stop at that visual contrast just between black and white skin because the work raises questions about who controls the representation of racialized bodies and whether aesthetic abstraction can obscure unequal power. So when we look at all of these images together they demonstrate how Mapplethorpe repeatedly asks viewers to examine how bodies are turned into ideals, objects of desire um and classic uh classic visual forms. Um this also makes Baldwin's critique of racialized masculinity a very useful counterpoint to Mapplethorpe's imagery.

58:03 Let's move on to Keith Haring. So Keith Haring was a gay man and you might have seen Haring's art prints on t-shirts or stickers. Um they're really very popular. So Haring's 1989 poster Ignorance Equals Fear, Silence Equals Death um uses those familiar bold figures and direct graphic language um but its message is urgent rather than his usual playful. So the three figures are covering their eyes, ears, and mouth and that evokes that familiar image of um refusing to see, hear, or speak. Um the equation in the title turns ignorance and silence into real causes of danger. So in the context of the AIDS epidemic refusing to

58:48 discuss sex or acknowledge the epidemic didn't protect public morality. It just made education and prevention more difficult. Um also notice how little specialized art knowledge is required to understand this poster. Um Haring's visual language works in the street, on a flyer, or in a museum. So accessibility is part of the politics of art. Um, the poster also asks viewers to recognize that silence is not neutral. So, when public institutions refuse to speak, the consequences fall on people who are already being stigmatized.

59:34 Now let's look at Gran Fury's Kissing Doesn't Kill, Greed and Indifference Do. So Gran Fury was an activist collective associated with ACT UP. Um, and it's 1989 campaign borrowed the polished visual language of commercial advertising, but instead used couples kissing as the central image. Um, I think this strategy is really clever because advertising usually uses romance and desire to sell products. Um, so the collective then inserts same sex and interracial intimacy into that familiar format, and it forces viewers to confront which kinds of affection they've been trained to consider as acceptable. Um, the slogan then redirects attention away from kissing and toward greed and

1:00:21 indifference. So, in other words, the image challenges the public to distinguish between the actual mechanism of an epidemic and the prejudices projected onto the people that are affected by it. So unlike an artwork that asks for quiet contemplation, this one is truly designed to interrupt ordinary public life. Um, it treats the street or the bus or the advertising surface that it's placed upon as a place where political arguments are being made. Finally, Felix Gonzalez-Torres, um, Untitled Portrait of Ross in L.A. from 1991,

1:01:06 um, is a very unconventional portrait, um, which consists of wrapped candies with a total weight of 175 lbs. This was the healthy weight of his partner Ross Lacock who died of AIDS. And a traditional portrait tries to preserve a recognizable likeness of the individual. This work gives us something that can physically diminish as viewers are encouraged to directly interact with the artwork by taking a piece of candy from the pile. Um loss isn't simply represented. It's actually happening in front of us and through our participation um as the pile diminishes. Um the possibility of replenishing the pile then complicates the metaphor. We

1:01:53 really cannot reverse Ross's death um but acts of care and memory and renewal prevent this work from becoming only a depiction of disappearance. Um it's very significant that viewers can take something away. Um the artwork then creates a relationship between strangers and the private love that might have otherwise remained invisible in public culture. Um compare this work to the AIDS Memorial quilt. Both of these transform personal mourning into a public encounter. Um but one of them is working through accumulated names in individual panels while the other is using absence, repetition, and participation.

1:02:40 Now as we conclude um I want you to notice that this movement was never only about changing laws. It was also about challenging the everyday assumptions that determine who can appear in public, who can be loved, and whose life is considered worthy of protection and remembrance. Um our reading from Baldwin questions the rigid ideal of American manhood. Um Butler asks why uh any gender identity should be treated as an unquestionable original. And Feinberg shows how those expectations are enforced through ordinary encounters and sometimes horrific violence. The artists that we looked at also approach similar questions through images. Mapplethorpe makes bodies and desire visible. Herring and Gran Fury um

1:03:28 demand a response to public indifference. And then Gonzalez-Torres asks asks viewers to participate in remembering someone who's been lost. The question I want to leave you with is whether equality means being allowed in into institutions as they already exist or whether genuine liberation sometimes requires changing the institutions and categories themselves. That's all for this week. Um you do have your usual quiz due on Sunday. Um this week you also have a compare contrast essay due Sunday at 11:59 p.m. Um for these I'll just remind you guys again I think you're doing a lot better on the discussion posts but please please please practice academic honesty and do

1:04:14 your own work. Um if your essay has vague or inaccurate references to the assigned material I'm going to have to give you a zero. Um for those of you who have been doing your own work consistently thank you so much. I really appreciate you. All right. I'll see you next week everyone.

Share

More video summaries