GitHub Copilot Just Died

簡要總結

本影片主要討論了 GitHub Copilot 最近的重大變更,這些變更實際上消除了該服務的許多優勢,使其與直接使用 AI 服務(如 Claude)相比,幾乎沒有任何優勢。影片中提到,GitHub Copilot 正在迅速走向「惡化」的道路,主要體現在以下幾個方面:

  • 取消了高級請求單元,轉而採用基於 token 的計費方式。
  • 移除了所有免費模型。
  • 對於年度計劃用戶,取消了年度計劃選項,並大幅提高了模型乘數。
  • 定價與直接使用 Claude 幾乎相同,沒有任何折扣或優惠。

引言

影片介紹了 GitHub Copilot 的重大變更,這些變更比預期的更快發生,並將其與「惡化」的概念聯繫起來。作者提到,他之前發布了一個關於 AI 如何走向「惡化」的影片,並認為這個過程會比較緩慢,但 GitHub Copilot 的變更速度超出了他的預期。

GitHub Copilot 的變更

從 6 月 1 日開始,GitHub Copilot 取消了高級請求單元,這意味著使用者不再有固定數量的請求可以使用 AI。以前,每月 10 美元的計劃提供 300 個請求,無論 token 數量多少。現在,取而代之的是基於 token 的計費方式,使用者需要根據使用的 token 數量付費。此外,所有免費模型都被移除,使用程式碼審查等功能也需要付費。

年度計劃和模型乘數

GitHub Copilot 完全取消了年度計劃,並大幅提高了模型乘數。例如,Claude Opus 的乘數從 3 增加到 15 或 27,Sonnet 從 1 增加到 9。這意味著使用者每月可以發送的請求數量大幅減少,例如,每月只能發送 10 個 Opus 請求或 30 個 Sonnet 請求。

定價變更

GitHub Copilot 的定價現在與 Claude 的定價模型完全相同,使用者需要按照 token 數量付費,沒有任何折扣或優惠。這使得 GitHub Copilot 除了程式碼自動完成功能外,幾乎沒有任何優勢。此外,只有更昂貴的每月 39 美元計劃才能使用 Opus 模型。

結論

作者認為,GitHub Copilot 的這些變更使其不再具有吸引力,因為使用者可以直接使用 Claude 等 AI 服務,而無需支付額外的費用。他預計,未來所有 AI 服務的定價都將趨於一致,與 API 定價相同,可能只有模型的所有者才能提供小幅折扣。作者建議觀看他之前發布的關於「惡化」的影片,以了解這些變更對使用者的影響。

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the Apple Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

YouTube Transcript Generator

0:00 I just released a video on how AI is going down the path of inshittification. It'll be linked right up here and in the description if you want to check it out. But I thought this was going to be a rather slow process that would take months or even a year or two to fully go down the path of raising the prices and reducing the quantity of what we get. But it is actually accelerating much quicker than I thought. GitHub with Copilot just sent me an email today essentially saying they're entirely removing all of the good things related to their Copilot plan and making it essentially on par with just paying for AI directly. It's honestly embarrassing seeing the changes that they've made. So let's take a look at what these changes entail. Starting on June 1st they're essentially removing the entire idea of premium request units. Essentially what that meant is that you had a set number of requests you could make to an AI. It was 300 with the $10 a month plan which is what I was on. And essentially you could send 300 requests to the AI

0:48 and then it would respond to you and it wouldn't matter how many tokens were taken. It would just be based on the request. And certain models such as like Opus would consume more than one request while cheaper models may consume less actual requests. But in general you got a certain number of requests you could make and it didn't matter how many tokens there were. Obviously this was consuming tons of money for GitHub and Copilot so they decided to completely scratch that entire idea. They removed this entirely and instead now you still have your $10 and your $39 a month plan but instead of getting these requests all you do is just get credits that go towards actually paying for the AI based on a token -based number. And if we look here they've also changed it so that you no longer can use any free models. There used to be free models included in the monthly plan that didn't count against you. Those have all been removed and if you're using things like code review with Copilot that uses GitHub Actions behind the scenes they're now going to be charging

1:36 you for that as well. So essentially they're just charging you for absolutely everything that you used to be getting for free which because they don't have enough money to do this is why they're doing that but it essentially removes all the value you're getting for paying for this particular service. The only thing that you're still getting that's free is the in -editor code complete and edit suggestions. Otherwise everything else is being changed completely. And the biggest thing that's changing for someone that's on the yearly plan which is actually what I was on which we scroll to that section you can see anyone that's on the annual plan they're not even offering that anymore so they're actually completely removing the annual plan and they're going to be changing how the model multipliers work for your premium request because they want to honor that same premium request situation and I figured they would increase it slightly maybe twice as much three times as much but it's honestly embarrassing looking at what they've done. If we scroll down to the brand new chart for these multipliers you can see the old multipliers on

2:22 the left for example you can see here Claude Opus was at three while now it's going to be 15 credits or if we look at the newer models of Opus you can see originally it was three premium requests now it's 27 that's a nine times increase and this is very consistent you can see Sonic went from one to nine you can see down here we're going from one to six one to three there's essentially a three to nine times increase on almost every single model that you're being charged for and if you're only getting 300 requests per month that means that you can essentially make 10 Opus requests per month on this plan or you can make 30 different requests on the sonnet so that's 30 ai requests per month that's essentially one per day obviously that's not going to be enough for doing any type of real world actual work and if we look at the actual pricing that they've changed it to essentially you're just paying a per unit price for the tokens you're using and they're just using the exact pricing model of Claude so you can

3:09 see here for haiku it's one dollar input five dollars for output and if we look here one dollar input five dollar output so you're getting no discount no benefit you're just pre -paying for these credits ahead of time and if you exceed your prepaid limit you just pay at the exact same rate you would pay if you used Claude directly so i don't see absolutely any benefit in using something like github copilot anymore other than that you get the in editor code completion that's the only thing you're getting by paying this additional money and if you're not on their 39 a month plan you don't even get access to these opus models they're only available on the more expensive plan so if you want to use these better models you have to just pay more up front and hope you use that usage limit now most likely you are going to use that usage limit because 10 a month or 39 a month is not a lot when your output tokens are costing you know 15 per million and so on but still it's you're paying pre -paying essentially for

3:57 something that you're getting at the exact same rate it doesn't really make any sense to me and i don't really see the benefit of using something like github copilot anymore when you could just pay directly with claude for example or use one of claude's plans that still technically exist at that time where you can pay essentially a monthly rate to get a certain amount of usage out of it eventually i am guaranteeing you that this will go away as well the same way that copilot has removed the ability to do just a one flat fee monthly thing i think every single one of these plans is essentially going to go to the point where they price you exactly the same as what the api pricing is and maybe people like claude or open ai that have their own models are going to be able to off you a slight discount if you're using like claude code or something it'll be a small discount but realistically this is the rate that we're going to be paying going forward and it's changing much quicker than i actually thought it would and if you want to learn more about what this actually means and how this instantification is

4:45 going to actually affect all of us i highly recommend checking out that video that i released just a few days ago i will link that video right over here on your screen

Share

YouTube Video Summaries