Might Want to Think Twice Before Eating Oatmeal

簡要總結

本影片主要探討了燕麥片對健康的影響,並提出了三個可能被忽略的觀點:

  • 燕麥片對血糖和膽固醇的影響可能不如宣稱的顯著,研究結果是與白麵包相比得出的。
  • 燕麥片含有一種麩質(avenin),可能對某些人造成發炎反應。
  • 燕麥片的生產過程中可能使用草甘膦(glyphosate)作為乾燥劑,這是一種有爭議的除草劑。

影片建議,在食用燕麥片時應選擇有機產品,並考慮是否真的需要每天吃早餐,或者可以嘗試間歇性斷食。

Introduction: Is oatmeal healthy?

影片介紹了燕麥片,作者提到自己過去每天都吃燕麥片當早餐,並認為它很健康。然而,作者將分享三個關於燕麥片的新資訊,這些資訊可能不廣為人知。作者並非建議完全停止食用燕麥片,而是希望提供更多資訊,以便做出更明智的選擇。影片將著重於未加糖的燕麥片,並避開那些含大量糖分的即食燕麥片。儘管許多文章宣稱燕麥片是超級食物,有助於降低膽固醇、控制血糖和維護心臟健康,但影片將深入探討這些說法的真實性。

New information on oatmeal

影片深入探討了燕麥片與血糖、胰島素和膽固醇之間的關係。研究顯示,燕麥片確實能顯著改善膽固醇和血糖水平,但這些改善是與白麵包相比的。例如,食用燕麥片後血糖上升幅度可能比白麵包少50%,但這並不代表燕麥片本身就能顯著降低血糖。此外,研究還指出,血糖的改善僅在餐後立即出現,之後並無持續效果。部分研究僅針對β-葡聚醣(燕麥中的一種化合物)進行,而非直接研究燕麥片的效果,因此將β-葡聚醣的效果推論到燕麥片可能存在偏差。另有研究顯示,糖尿病患者食用燕麥片後,血糖水平並未出現明顯變化。因此,燕麥片「有益心臟健康」的說法可能過於簡化,並未提供完整的資訊。作者建議自行檢測食用燕麥片前後的血糖變化,以了解其對個人身體的實際影響。此外,作者也提到很難找到關於添加大量糖的即食燕麥片對血糖、胰島素或膽固醇影響的研究。

Is eating breakfast healthy?

影片提到了燕麥片可能含有麩質。雖然一般認為燕麥不含麩質,但實際上它含有一種名為avenin的蛋白質,這種蛋白質可能會引發體內的發炎反應,增加細胞激素。這種反應可能延遲發生,導致難以將症狀與燕麥片的攝取聯繫起來。對於患有腸躁症、發炎或乳糜瀉的人來說,食用燕麥片可能會使情況惡化。麩質是引發自體免疫疾病(尤其是橋本氏甲狀腺炎)的主要因素之一。此外,燕麥片的生產過程中可能使用草甘膦(glyphosate)這種除草劑。雖然美國食品藥品監督管理局(FDA)的報告中並未提及燕麥,但孟山都(草甘膦的生產商)聲稱其產品是安全的。然而,世界衛生組織(WHO)已將草甘膦列為致癌物質,且有訴訟案例顯示,接觸草甘膦可能導致癌症(如非霍奇金淋巴瘤)。環境工作組織(EWG)的研究發現,超過95%的燕麥產品樣本中含有草甘膦。這是因為燕麥在收穫前會使用草甘膦作為乾燥劑。因此,在選擇燕麥片時,鋼切燕麥優於即食燕麥,且應選擇有機產品,以避免攝入草甘膦。

Learn more about the benefits of skipping breakfast!

影片建議,除了食用燕麥片,也可以考慮完全不吃早餐,嘗試間歇性斷食,可能會發現身體感覺更好。如果一定要吃早餐,雞蛋會是更好的選擇。作者推薦觀看另一部關於不吃早餐的好處的影片。

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the Apple Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

YouTube Transcript Generator

0:00 so the topic of today is oatmeal and I used to love oatmeal I used to have it every single day as a breakfast and I was told that it was healthy and so today I want to share uh three things that you probably have never heard before relating to oatmeal and the reason I'm bringing this up is because if you're consuming oatmeal for health reasons you may change your mind after watching this video now of course I'm not telling you not to consume oatmeal I just want to give you some additional information to think with that is not necessarily easy to find when you type oatmeal on the internet and I'm not going to even cover what you probably already know the sugary type of oatmeal in these little packets this instant

0:45 oatmeal tons of sugar you know you already know that's really bad I want to talk about the oatmeal that's actually not sweetened but it's interesting even in the packets of instant oatmeal that has tons of sugar apparently you could still have a little claim there that says that it's heart healthy I mean you'll see articles out there that'll say that oatmeal is one of the healthiest foods that you can possibly eat it's considered a superfood it will lower your cholesterol it will help your diabetes and blood sugars it will make your heart healthy so the first thing I'm going to dive into I'm going to put a bunch of studies down below so you can verify what I'm saying is true is some studies done on oatmeal in relationship to blood sugars and Insulin

1:30 as well as cholesterol now when you read these studies it does definitely say that there is a significant Improvement in cholesterol as well as blood sugars okay both and that's pretty exciting I mean like wow because if something is cholesterol friendly or it's blood sugar friendly then you know sign me up but if you actually read the studies it will say there's a significant decrease in cholesterol and blood glucose compared to the control now what is this mean compared to a control what is that all about well you're comparing it to something else right and that comparison is white bread that's right white bread so if you compare anything to white bread it's going to be better in a significant way

2:19 so let's say for example you eat some white bread okay and let's say it spikes your blood sugars by 10 points and then when you eat uh the oats it only spikes your blood sugars by five points and then we can say in the study there's a significant difference there's a a much less like 50 percent less spike in blood sugars than the controls but that 50 Improvement is not just you know adding this to your diet and seeing an improvement in blood sugars it's compared to something else and then when you read on in the study it says the Improvement in blood sugars only occurred right after the meal okay it didn't occur later on probably because there's a a nice Spike of blood glucose when you eat white bread so that was one

3:05 point the other thing that they mentioned the studies is that part of the study was just consuming three grams of beta glucan not consuming oatmeal but just that compound and that created a lowering of cholesterol and so then by inference and we can just say well there's beta-glucan in oats and just by deductive reasoning it then must create the same effect act but that's a little confusing because that's an isolated compound versus eating it as a whole grain and then there's other studies that 29 participants enrolled in the study they all had diabetes and they did not see any change with blood glucose levels between the two so when we talk about the benefit there's only certain studies they're talking about and so when they quote it's heart healthy

3:50 they're kind of cherry picking certain parts of studies and not giving you the full understanding of what it really is going to do to your cholesterol levels or blood sugars in fact the best thing I think you should do is just start testing your blood sugars when you consume it and then not consume it and then you'll know for yourself but also I could not find any of these studies involving the instant oatmeal with all the added sugar okay somehow those studies are really hard to find in relationship to them improving your blood glucose levels or insulin levels or cholesterol levels the next topic is gluten free right because we all know that oats are gluten free well apparently they do have a a type of gluten it's called avanin okay and this

4:38 protein has been known to increase cytokines which are in like an inflammatory response in your body but here's the Catch-22 it's delayed you may not feel any symptoms for days later so it's going to be very hard to make the connection between the two but if you have irritable bowel syndrome or inflammation or celiac you may find that eating oats can worsen the situation and you have to realize that these glutens which is just a category of a lot of different types of proteins it's like one of the primary uh triggers for autoimmune diseases especially Hashimoto's which is a thyroid problem

5:25 number three weed killer called glyphosate it's interesting that the FDA when they did the reports or studies on different foods they kind of omitted oats for some reason but we don't have to worry about that because Monsanto did their own studies and that was the creator of glyphosate and they said that it's completely safe so we don't really have to worry about that but of course the World Health Organization did say that glyphosate is a carcinogen and there was a lawsuit that was one in court by someone being exposed to glyphosate and winning millions of dollars because they developed cancer and the type of cancer apparently increases the risk for is called Non-Hodgkin's lymphoma but another

6:10 organization called ewg which I'll put a link down below when they found traces of glyphosate weed killer and over 95 percent of samples of oat products and it's not that this oat is genetically modified they use glyphosate as a pre-harvest drying agent because it can kill the plant really quick and dry it up and that's what they use not only in oats but in wheat I mean this kind of goes beyond the genetically modified foods like in the corn the soy canola that type of thing so anyway if you do have oats of course you know steel cut would be much better than the the process

6:55 instant oats and if you're going to eat it make sure it's organic okay unless you want some weed killer in there but you may also want to try something you might want to just skip your breakfast all together and do intermittent fasting you'll probably be shocked to find out how good you actually feel by not doing a breakfast in general but that being said if you want to do a breakfast I think eggs would be a much better choice now since we're on the topic of breakfast if you have not seen my video on how to transition out of doing a breakfast in the benefits I put that video up right here check it out

Share

YouTube Video Summaries