0:00 Manchester United squad is not good enough. At least John, that's what most of the fans are saying. But is that actually fair? >> Well, we've got the squad in front of us and if we look at it, there are some areas that do look a little bit ropey. You've got Luke Shaw pretty much on his own out here. He's getting towards the end of his career with Benjamin's ongoing injury issues. Man United having to rely a little bit more on Xerxy than they might like. So, there's plenty of areas in this squad, I think, that can use some work. But there's this curious phenomenon, I think, when we're trying to judge how good a squad is, which is that the players themselves are judged on the performances of the team. So, if a team has a bad run of form, then we look at the individual players and say, "These players are bad. They're not good enough." When actually, I think the reality is is that squad building is much more complicated than that, right? It's about not necessarily the players in themselves intrinsically. It's about the dynamics between different parts of the squad and the way that the coach can
0:47 get more or less out of them, right? So, I think what we're going to try and do today is dig into some of these more dynamic issues and think about how the squad is working as a whole rather than just going through the individual players and saying that player isn't good enough, that player is good enough. >> Okay. So, then rather than breaking it down through players, let's look through areas of the pitch. Why don't we start with the attacking end? >> Yeah, because if we start there, we can see that Manchester United are actually producing really good numbers. So, if we take non-penalty expected goals, for example, Manchester United are fourth in that list. So, we're talking about an attack here that is getting them a level of chance quality which is good enough to compete with the Champions League clubs. Now, at the same time, there are some other numbers that suggest that everything isn't perfect. We look at xG per shot. We can see that that's a little bit lower than the other teams around them at the top of the table, and that does suggest that there are some questions about shot selection. Um, but
1:34 for the most part, this forward area is producing the kind of chances that you would want a team challenging for the Champions League spots to be producing. So clearly not the case that the whole squad is bad across the pitch. >> Yeah, I guess that's not surprising, right? Given Inos have invested a lot in the attacking end of the pitch, bringing in Mumumer, bringing in Kuna as well. But I'm guessing not everything about this is perfect. >> Yeah, I think they've obviously raised the ability levels in that area of the pitch. But what they haven't done is fixed balance issues in particular. So you've mentioned already Kuna and and Burmo. Both of these guys can be played in the wider areas, but they're more insider for guys, And then if we start looking into the the width options that are available, you've got Patrick Dorgu who is sort of brought in to be a kind of wing back um under under Amarim. You've got Rashford who has come back from loan at Barca and United were trying to move him on in the summer and
2:19 they haven't managed to do that. Uh you've got a mad on the other side who I think is a genuine like league level player in that wide area. But I think it's very clear that the best players that Man United have sort of forced them into playing a more narrow approach to the game. Right. So if they were to bring in a coach who wanted to use width in any games, they probably don't have quite as much upside there. >> And I guess the person to blame for that is Ruben Amarim. >> Yeah. And and you and I have sat in this very room and talked about this that the idea that if you bring in a coach like Amarim who has a different approach to squad building, then you're going to end up with a scenario where most of your best wide players have moved on to to facilitate, for example, as we've said, someone like Patrick Dorgi who probably feels a little bit more like a wing back option here. So if we're taking lessons from this, the first lesson of squad building then is don't bring in consecutive managers with completely different styles of play.
3:05 >> Yeah, absolutely. If we're looking back over the history here, I think the reason why there's a lack of really good wide options in this Manchester United squad is because Man United hired Amarim and so this is part of his legacy in the squad. But there is another issue here and that is the issue of contracts. Because as we saw before, one of the reasons why Man United haven't been able to recruit in that wide area is because Marcus Rashford is still on their books. Actually, if we look at the screen here, we can see they've got Rashford until 2028. They probably would have wanted to move him on and they could have brought someone else in. That hasn't happened for whatever reason. And this is something that is really important to consider. I think the the length of contracts whenever you're considering how good a squad is because the contracts do stop you from being able to make the improvements that you might want to make. It's very easy as fans to look at a squad and say, "Well, there's weaknesses here, so all we need to do is bring in these kind of players and then everything will be fixed." The reality
3:51 is that you've often got players that you have to continue paying. you have to continue paying a wage and you can't just simply stop playing them and think that that's going to be okay. And I think there's a few examples of of players in in similar situations that we've got here, right? And so, for example, we've got someone like Joshua Xerxy who Manchester United have to pay his wages until 2029. We've already talked about how Shesho is injured. Man United might want to bring someone in in January, but the fact that they're going to have to pay Xerxes until 2029 means that it's going to impact their ability to squad build in that area. >> Yeah. Potential issues with Briano Metanus Cano as well. Obviously, they're playing well right now, but they'll be in their 30s at the end of their contract. So, you you better hope they keep playing well, otherwise you probably have the same problem with them. >> And then the other interesting one here is Manuel Agati, who is also being paid up until 2029. Now, this is slightly complexified by the fact that Ugate got injured in the summer. He may well have
4:36 been moved on by Manchester United if they could and that would have actually solved a couple of problems in their midfield recruitment in the summer as well, which we should go on to talk about. >> Okay, let's go through the midfielder, the area where they've obviously most recently invested heavily in. Yeah. So they brought in Andre Santos in the summer. They brought in Yuri Tielemans in the summer and they also brought in Carlos Bleber in the summer. Now Andre Santos and Tielemans were brought in first and they were relatively cut price options. Santos was around 50 million. Tieleman's a bit a bit cheaper and then they obviously at the end of the window decided that someone like Ble should be brought in because I think if we look at the profile of these players in the midfield area we can see that um Andre Santos Mayu and Tielemans none of them are really large space defenders. they're not going to cover huge amounts of space particularly well and so it was thought that bringing in Balaba should help sort out that problem but this has
5:22 led to probably the biggest discourse about Manchester United's squad. So we've got Gary Neville on Sky Sports Comm saying you buy cheap, you buy twice. A load of these players aren't good enough. Now this is 25th of October. So, you know, it's very much laced with hindsight bias, I would say. And so the reality is that we've got a lot of people saying that rather than spending big money on a few players in the midfield, maybe Man United should have spent big money on one player in the midfield to solve some of the problems that we're seeing now. But I would question that because I think if you go for a really expensive option like your Declan Rice's, your Elliot Anderson's, what you're getting is players who are great. they're really well-rounded on both sides of the ball. Whereas, if you get a cheaper option, what you're getting is a less well-rounded player, right? Who's going to have strengths but also weaknesses. And I think if you're going to take this kind of approach where you are going to think about maybe spending your money a little bit more wisely, you're going to have to be aware of what those
6:07 weaknesses are and find ways of bringing those players into your team where you overcome some of those weaknesses and mitigate them. And I would argue that Michael Carrick probably hasn't done that very well. So, I've got a couple of sequences from Man United's recent game against Aston Villa, the 4-4 thriller, however you want to look at it. Um, and I just wanted to show a few things. So, we start off with Man United in a defensive situation. Villa have settled possession on the ball and Man United are in this sort of 424 shape that we've seen them use for the most part under Michael Carrick. Obviously, that changes depending on what the opponent are doing. So, we've got Mazawi tracking Manzambi inside because he wants to drift into the middle and try and form this overload and he's going to move in to make sure that doesn't happen. But for the most part, we can see we've got the two midfielders here, Yuri Tielemans and Kobe Manu. Now, neither of these two are big space defenders, right? That's what we're talking about when we're talking about not getting the elite elite central midfielders. These players
6:54 probably aren't going to be able to cover a ton of space. And so we can see Man United doing certain things to try and help them out. So actually, if we look at the the two forwards in the in the in the front four, Burma and Fernandez, you can see they're starting off a little bit deeper to make sure there's a bit of an overload in the middle. And as we said before, Mazra is coming inside to make sure that Manzambi isn't free. But the problem is is that this is the starting position, right, for your press and opponents are finding ways of just being able to pull this structure around, open out the space in the middle and access it. So, let's just see how that plays out because the ball is played back to Zion Suzuki and immediately Fernandez is jumping onto him, right? Man United want to be aggressive in the press. You can see that they're trying to get man-to-man around the ball. Immediately that is removing one of your central options from the picture. Villa obviously going to try and do things to try and make it easier for them to possess the ball and create space around certain players. So
7:40 we can see that happening on their left hand side. Ian Matson pushing higher up the pitch to drag Ahmad who's on the outside of that front four away. And you can see because Burmo is wanting to try and protect this central overload. You can see Po Torres is in a lot of space. So Zan Suzuki is going to play the ball to him and that means that Embermo is going to have to jump out right. So we end up with this scenario now where immediately that central protection that was there has gone. Um you've got the front four pressing up high while a man dropping in a little bit deeper. And so we now have the two villa pivots in quite a lot of space here. Now in theory what's supposed to happen when the forward players jump up is that the midfielders can jump up particularly on the ball side. Right? So you can see in this instance Tielemans has made an effort to get a little bit further forward. And that's setting off a chain reaction where you can see Lenny Yuro stepping up onto Manzambi to make sure
8:26 there's no space here. And this is the way that many teams do it in the modern game, right? They use their backline to step into these spaces that open out to make sure that they aren't problematic. And we'll talk a little bit later about man how Man United aren't doing that. And so in this instance, it seems as though everything is fine. Okay, Tielemans is probably a little bit too far away from Geretska here. The problem is is that as soon as Pores gets into a situation where he can play the channel ball, that's going to trigger Man United dropping back. The back line is going to drop back and that means that Yuro is going to leave Manzambi. That means that Tielemans has to drop back onto Manzambi to make sure he's not free on that side. So essentially what you've got is Tieleman's not really covering Geretska very well and then certainly not covering Manzambi particularly well in the turnover. This is from a few seconds later and we can see it's very much Villa in a deep buildup situation. Now in this scenario you can see Tielemans has stepped right up onto Gretka to make
9:13 sure there's no out balls on this side of the pitch and Manzambi's come inside and Mazawi has followed him. And so on paper we can see here this is okay from a Man United perspective. You got coverage man-to-man in the midfield. Tieleman stepping up to be more aggressive. But there are a few problems. One of these problems is that Bruno Fernandez is blocking the passing lane into Geretska who's also being tracked by Tielemans and that means that Pow Torres once again is in a space. And so what we can see here is the out ball is pretty simple for Villa to just play the ball into Pow Torres's feet and this causes a few chain reaction effects, right? You've got Tieleman's already very high up the pitch. Mazawi now, okay, he's covering Manzambi, but he's a fullback and he knows that that channel is his responsibility, right? So we've already seen a few minutes ago Ptorius take the ball forward play into that channel. So Masarawi has to be aware
9:58 that he has to cover that channel in some way. Um so he's his temptation is to move back into that back line. Whereas Manzami can obviously drop in in this into this space that has opened out. So the space that wasn't problematic before immediately becomes problematic as soon as that press is broken and Torres carries the ball forward. Actually in this instance he's got a really easy pass into the feet of Manzambi. You can see the separation between Manzambi and Mazawi, which means that if Manzambi receives the ball, all he has to do is play a bounce pass into the feet of Kamar and then suddenly you've got a scenario where Villa very much overloading this midfield area. Right, you can build out in the wide area and probably attack through Allison in this wing. In the event, Torres plays the ball to Matson on the touch line here and then continues his run in behind the defender on this side. Um, and Matson plays the ball back to him. So, they've broken the press very easily with just a one two and we now have a
10:45 lot of trouble, right? because you can see Mazawi has come across to make sure that the uh channel is covered. Manzambi is free, um McIn is free and the two pivots are free as well. And actually what ends up happening here is that Pores plays the ball to Geretska and if Gretka takes a more positive touch then I think he has access to any of these three players and suddenly you've only got one player Kobe having to cover the whole of this midfield area. In the end, Gretzka takes quite a negative touch. He lets the ball roll across him and that slows things down enough for Man United to get back in. But I think against teams making better decisions in possession, these sorts of weaknesses are going to be exposed on a number of occasions. >> So going back to score building lessons, this one probably falls on Michael Carrick. If Carrick took a better approach without the ball, then these midfielders would not be put under so much pressure. >> Yeah, exactly. I think that the tactics
11:31 that you play can make the players look better. We talked about it right at the beginning, right? We we have a very individualist account of player quality, right, which is this player isn't playing very well when actually in this instance, is it the case that Kobenu isn't playing very well in defensive phases or is it just that he's not being protected? Are there ways that we can actually find better structures to protect these kind of players? So, as we said before, we're mitigating the downsides and allowing their upsides to shine. If that is the case, we probably come out with a much more positive view of Kobe Mayu's ability um than we have in maybe the last few games that Manchester United have played. >> So, is that the case? What else could they have done? >> Well, we've already talked about how Manchester United's 424 shape here is actually quite manipulable by opponents, you can start off with all of the coverage in the middle that you want, but if essentially what you're doing is being aggressive and pressing out onto the opposition back forward, then you're
12:17 going to open out this space and teams are obviously good enough to work their way through this press into that underloaded area. Now, the irony here is that most Premier League teams, I think, are aware of the fact that the central areas are the most important to protect out of possession. And so, what we're seeing is a lot of structures that are designed to protect the middle. Man United who we've already said don't have big space defenders in the central midfield areas are using a system where they actually open out the space in the midfield. That becomes a huge problem. So most of the teams that we see defending now to protect the middle use a bit more of a 442 diamond. So you've got a diamond in the midfield here with sort of a pivot player in the middle. Uh and then your your usually your wingers kind of coming inside. You can do different things, right? You could have Fernandez jumping out here if you wanted or you could have Fernandez here and Amad coming inside or and Burmo coming inside, whoever. There's different ways
13:02 that you can structure this, but you have these two players on the outside of the diamond and their job is to to make sure that they can get across to the fullback when when the um when the opponent plays out on one side. Now, obviously, this is leaving a a half space escape here, but as we've said, we've got this floating pivot player who can come across one side to the other depending on which side the ball is on to lock on, right? So actually with a couple of passes you should easily end up with something like this where you're forcing the opponents into the wide areas of the pitch and then you're locking on and squeezing them making it hard for them to rotate the ball back around. Now if they do manage to rotate the ball back around then it's simple right because bang bang bang across here and then everyone shifts across the other way. Pivot player can just switch across onto the other half space and the wide player on the far side should just come inside and help retain that overload in the middle. This is the way that many teams in the Premier League
13:48 are defending now. And I think if Manchester United defended in this way, it would give much more protection to those players who we've said aren't really big space coverers. One other area we should talk about is the back line, right? Because uh modern presses want to jump up aggressively. Often you're opening these spaces out. And if you have a plus one at the back, that means you actually have an extra player who can jump out to help out in these areas if the opponent drift into it. Right. Uh, and this is an area that we should talk about with Manchester United because we're not seeing them utilize their back line in quite the same way. >> All right, let's talk about the actual defense then. >> So, we've just talked about how in the modern game you can use your center backs to help out in these pressing moments to make sure that you're not opening out those central spaces. And I think Man United have a bit of an issue here, right? Because the starting center backs that they tended to use this season, Harry Magguire and Martinez, are good, but in opposite directions, right?
14:34 So, with Magguire, you don't really want to have him stepping up into midfield and then having to track back to cover. uh because he's he's not that quick. But then when you get him into the box, he's a fantastic box defender. He's decent at carrying the ball out and building out. Martinez, I think, is the opposite thing, right? You do want him stepping out. He is a great at covering these spaces here. But then when you have him in the box, he is a short defender for a center back and as we've seen, he's given away a few goals in that regard as well. So of course there's also Dict, but he's been perennially injured at Manchester United. And this shouldn't really be surprising because as we've said, Inos have taken quite a sequential approach to recruitment, right? They started out making sure the front line was bolstered. They then built the midfield this window. You would expect that their next summer window will be focused around improving the back line and there's plenty of areas that you can do that. And I think there's the possibility for them to make massive
15:20 improvements here because if they do bring in starting level center backs who are more modern, who are able to step up and help out covering that midfield area, but also drop in and be really good box defenders, then not only are they going to be improving the quality of the backline intrinsically, they're also going to be improving the quality of the midfield. Right? That's the dynamic that we're talking about. Most modern center back partnerships in the Premier League now are based around that, the ability to to cover higher up, but also to box defend really well. So, I think what you get if you do bring in those center back profiles, you improve the quality of the midfield as well as the back line. Now, on top of this, we've also got Lenny Euro and Aiden Heaven, and I think those players have been maybe a little bit unfairly maligned because often they're being thrown under the bus of the chaos at the back. Um, and people are thinking, well, then maybe they're not as good as we originally thought when they were signed. But I think what will happen is
16:05 if you bring in those starting level center backs, you're then protecting them a little bit more. You're giving them space and chance to develop. Uh and so you then have succession planning further down the line. So I think the the reason why there should be positivity about this is that if you bring in a couple of center backs, suddenly you're improving the midfield, you're improving the back line and and and then all you're really left with is the issue of the fullbacks. >> Yeah, I'm guessing if you improve the fullbacks, you're also helping to improve the attack as well. >> Yeah, of course. because as we've already seen Shaw coming to the end of his career. There's no real backup here I guess apart from Dorgu if you want to play him deeper. Masarawi also getting on a little bit and and Dallow a good backup option I would say on both sides but you probably want to have a starting level player ahead of him. So again, plenty of scope for improvement here, but I think there should be positivity because I think not only are you improving the bat line, you're improving
16:51 the rest of the team. And I think if we then look in a couple of seasons time, if they do make these changes, we'll probably feel a lot more positive about the general squad on the basis of these defensive improvements. >> So the final squad building lesson here then is that everything is interlin. And this is the problem with Inos's sequential approach, right? Just because you sign attacking and midfield players, it doesn't mean those areas are solved. because if the back line isn't fixed, then that's going to present issues for these players. But I guess then if they do sign defenders next summer, top level defenders, then everything will be solved. >> Well, I don't know if I would go so far as to say that everything has been solved, but I certainly think that the squad will look a little bit more coherent than it maybe does right now. But there is a downside to this as well. I think if you take this sequential approach, then the problems of age and time become a factor, right? Because if we look at this viz of Manchester
17:36 United's age profile right now, we can see that the players that they've bought in the forward areas. So we've got Burma, we've got Kuna, we've got Bruno Fernandez, they're all coming out of the peak age block that we have on the viz here. And that means that, you know, yeah, okay, maybe they'll solve the defense next summer. These players are going to be getting older, right? Which means you then have to return back to the front line again to fix it, right? So there's a potential that if you take that sequential approach, it sort of becomes a bit of a never-ending problem. like the painting of the fourth road bridge. By the time you get to the end, you have to go back to the the beginning and start again. But I actually think they might be better served by taking a more holistic approach to this by looking at the squad as a whole and thinking about the dynamics there. And so rather than having to fix whole parts of the pitch, you actually say, well, if we bring in a center back here, that might raise the profile of the the whole defensive area. If we bring in a forward
18:21 on the right hand side, that might fix some of our attacking dynamic problems. And so rather than having to buy a lot of players to fix problems, you're suddenly raising the profile of the squad by making smart individual signings. But I don't think that's going to be possible until they reach this base level where all of the areas of the pitch are at a level where you can start making those individual changes. So maybe after this next cycle, we'll see Man United shifting to that more holistic approach. If you like this video, please consider subscribing to the channel. The Athletic is home to some of the world's best sports journalists, including David Ornstein, Amy Lawrence, and James Horncastle. With the latest transfer news and insights on every Premier League story that matters, theathletic.com puts you inside football.