We just rebuilt the ancient Indus Valley Civilization in glorious 3D.

Brief Summary

Alright, so this video is all about the Indus Valley Civilization (IVC), a super advanced ancient Indian culture that mysteriously disappeared. We're talking planned cities, flush toilets, and major international trade, but their language is still a mystery. The video explores their origins, what made their civilization special, and tries to debunk some common misconceptions about them, like whether they were peaceful or egalitarian. Finally, it dives into why they vanished and whether they were really forgotten.

  • The Indus Valley Civilization (IVC) was a highly advanced ancient civilization in northwest India, dating back 5,000 years.
  • The IVC had planned cities, advanced sanitation systems (including flush toilets), and a thriving trade network.
  • The script of the IVC remains undeciphered, making it difficult to understand their culture and history fully.
  • Common misconceptions about the IVC, such as it being an egalitarian and peaceful society, are challenged.
  • The decline of the IVC was likely due to environmental changes and the collapse of trade networks, rather than an Aryan invasion.

Introduction: The Lost Civilization

The video starts with a dramatic intro about a civilization lost to time, setting the stage for exploring the mysteries of the Indus Valley Civilization (IVC). It poses questions about what it means for a civilization to be forgotten and the limits of human knowledge when trying to understand the past. The video promises to take us on a journey to uncover the secrets of this ancient culture.

Discovery of the Indus Valley Civilization

In 1924, Indian and British archaeologists made a groundbreaking discovery: the Indus Valley Civilization. But the story actually starts earlier, with James Lewis (aka Charles Mason) who, while on the run from the British East India Company, stumbled upon the ruins in the 1820s. He didn't realize the significance of his find, and for a long time, people underestimated the age of the bricks. It wasn't until the 1920s that full-scale excavations confirmed the existence of this ancient civilization.

Origins: From Mehrgarh to the Indus Valley

The IVC didn't just appear out of nowhere. Its roots can be traced back to the Mehrgarh culture around 7,000 BCE. These early settlers were farmers and herders, and they even had dental surgery! They traded with Central Asia and the southern coast. Over time, climate change pushed them to move from the dry uplands of Balochistan to the fertile Indus River Valley. This move to the floodplains was key to the rise of the IVC, as it allowed for abundant food production and population growth.

The Golden Age: Urban Planning and Daily Life

The IVC was special because of its focus on city planning, sanitation, and trade. Their cities had a modern grid-like design with wide streets and standardized bricks. Every house was connected to a drainage system, and they even invented the flush toilet! They also had advanced water management systems, like the dockyard at Lothal. Life wasn't all work, though. They enjoyed food, drinks (including refined alcohol), and games like dice and early versions of chess.

Fashion, Trade, and International Connections

The IVC was known for its luxury fashion and crafts. They were the first to weave cotton, making fine textiles that they exported. Jewelry was also popular, with tons of bangles being found. They were also big on international trade, with routes extending to Central and West Asia. They used seals as commercial signatures and had a standardized weight system. They traded with the Arabians and Mesopotamians, with Indus people even living in those regions and vice versa.

Unsolved Mysteries and Rethinking Assumptions

Because their script hasn't been deciphered, many mysteries remain. The video challenges some common assumptions about the IVC. Were they really an egalitarian society? Maybe not, considering the luxury houses that have been found. Were they peaceful? Probably not, as weapons have been discovered, and there's evidence of warfare. Who did they worship? We don't know for sure, but the Pashupati seal offers some clues.

The Disappearance: Debunking the Aryan Invasion Theory

Why did the IVC disappear? The old theory of an Aryan invasion is likely wrong. Instead, it seems that environmental changes, like shifts in the monsoon and rivers drying up, led to food shortages and chaos. Trade networks collapsed, and cities declined. People migrated, and the IVC culture was transformed over time. It wasn't a sudden end, but a slow process of change.

Legacy and Rediscovery

The IVC was eventually forgotten, but its legacy lived on in transformed ways. The video points out that historical amnesia is common in the Indian subcontinent. New discoveries are constantly changing our understanding of the IVC, showing that elements of its culture still remain, even if they're not always obvious.

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the Apple Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

Full transcript of “We just rebuilt the ancient Indus Valley Civilization in glorious 3D.”. Click a timestamp to open the video at that moment. Need another video? Use the YouTube transcript generator.

0:01 We built a civilization meant to stand the test of time. Now we're nothing more than dust. Remember us. Rebuild us. [Music] What does it mean for a civilization to be lost to time? What are the limits of human knowledge? [Music] Welcome to the timehub adventure. Today we'll be traveling deep into the past. 5,000 years ago, the Indis Valley civilization thrived in northwest India. An ancient precursor to the great

0:49 peoples and empires of the subcontinent. [Music] This was a truly advanced civilization with planned cities, flushed toilets, merchant guilds, and international trade. And yet, so much of their world remains shrouded in mystery. Here's the problem. We still haven't decoded their language. These symbols mean nothing to us. Right now, it's all guesswork. Even more strangely, there's no mention of the Indis civilization in later records, no acknowledgement of their existence. It's like they all just suddenly disappeared. So, who really were the people of the Indis? What did they invent? What did they believe? And dang it, what happened to them?

1:35 [Music] Strap in, adventurer. It's about time we get some answers. Please fasten your seat belts. [Music] In 1924, a team of Indian and British archaeologists shocked the world when they unearthed the greatest find of the 20th century. Two ancient cities buried beneath Punjab and Sin, the remnants of a lost 5,000-year-old civilization. the Indis Valley civilization or IVC for

2:21 short. The discovery sparked a wave of global interest and scholarship. People desperately wanted to know more about this Indian contemporary of ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia. But the story of its discovery actually began a century earlier. Meet James Lewis. In 1826, he deserted the British East India Company and was on the run from colonial authorities. To evade capture, he created a fake name and identity as American Charles Mason and journeyed through northwest India. Eventually, Lewis made a deal with the British East India Company for clemency. As part of the clemency deal, he would excavate local sites and hand over any historical artifacts he could find to the company. And so, rather unsurprisingly, when he passed through the town of Hara and came across earthn mounds and brick ruins, he conducted an

3:07 immediate investigation. The locals already had their own folklore about the site. They believed that it was the ruined city of a cursed medieval king Raja Hararpa. Lewis on the other hand believed that he discovered the remains of an ancient but the city dating back to the 4th century B.C.E. both were wrong. In truth, he'd wandered through the ruins of a lost civilization thousands of years older than anyone could have imagined. For nearly a century, visitors, including trained archaeologists, could never quite solve the historical puzzle. According to the esteemed Dr. Bandark, for example, the Indis bricks were too sophisticated to be more than 250 years old. In fact, the bricks were of such high quality that they were being

3:53 repurposed by British railway contractors. That being said, a few archaeologists such as RD Energy did speculate about the remote antiquity of the site. But it wasn't until 1921 that the archaeological survey of India under John Marshall finally committed to a full-scale excavation of the Hara and Mahendraodaro sites. In just 3 years, these excavations revealed the existence of the long-forgotten Industy civilization in all its ancient and mysterious glory. To better understand the IVC, we have to understand its origins. After all, it didn't just suddenly pop into existence. So, where did the people of the Indis

4:39 come from? The answer lies in the predecessor Maherar culture. Around 7,000 B.CE. A group of semi-nomadic hunter gatherers settled a site, Maherar, in the mountains of present-day Baloasan. By 6,500 B.C.E., These settlers had developed farming and had domesticated herd animals. The earliest evidence of its kind in South Asia. Mheragar may have been small, but it wasn't some isolated backwater. For example, archaeologists have found the world's earliest evidence of dental surgery using copper drills similar to those used in bead making. And the discovery of turquoise beads, lapis lazuli, and carved seaells suggests long-distance trade with central Asia and the southern coast. As the centuries passed, Mheragar

5:27 technology developed further. We find glazed beads, ceramics, terracotta figurines, seals, pit kils, and copper smelting crucibles. Curiously, these artifacts resemble those of distant Mesopotamia. That being said, technology wasn't the only thing flooding in from West Asia. People did, too. By 45,00 B.C.E., waves of Zagrosian hunter gatherers began migrating into the Mahagar region. In time, these migrants would mix with the locals and assimilate. So, while there is a significant genetic shift in this period, there's a remarkable cultural continuity. But history teaches us that change is inevitable. For the people of Mheragar, climate pressure made their land increasingly inhospitable. As the

6:12 monsoon shifted south and Blothan dried up, they began to search for better land to settle. And oh me, oh my, they found it. Starting in 3,300 B.C.E., Settlers from the Heraggar migrated from the dry uplands of Bloasthan into the fertile lowlands of the Indis River. What this upstart group of settlers couldn't have foreseen is that the Indis River Valley would change their fortunes forever. Because like other first civilizations, Egypt, Mesopotamia, and China, they'd settled on a flood plane. And flood planes create the conditions necessary for great civilizations to emerge. Here's how it works. Flood planes involve the seasonal flooding of a river like the Indis. These floods replenish nutrients in the soil making for highly fertile naturally irrigated land.

6:57 Productivity skyrockets. Food becomes more abundant. These food surpluses lead to population growth which leads to specialization and large-scale trade which leads to centralized authority in urbanization and thus a civilization is born. In this case, the Indis Valley civilization. As expected, the early period of the IBC saw the rise of small proto cities such as Harappa, Nosharo, Kotiji, and Dolivera, which would eventually become major urban centers. And at Doliva, archaeologists have discovered early water management systems, reservoirs, and distribution channels, and motif carved seals pointing to the emergence of an advanced administration. Finally, by the mature period, the contours of the IVC had fully taken

7:42 shape, marked by increasingly complex urban planning, architecture, social organization, and long-distance trade. It is this mature period, the flourishing golden age of the Indis Valley civilization that we'll be focusing on next. While the Egyptians were constructing pyramids for their godkings, the Chinese were weaving silk, and the Mesopotamians were writing contracts on uniform tablets. The people of the Indis were focused on an entirely different set of priorities. City planning, sanitation, smart governance, and maritime trade. In many ways, the IBC was ahead of its time. Let's break down what makes it so special. Urban design and planning.

8:28 While other ancient civilizations did have grand cityscapes, the IVC is striking in that its cities implemented a modern grid-like design. These were planned cities with wide streets crisscrossing each other at right angles. Detailed city and town planning was the norm. In the IBC, all settlements, great or small, were given a surprising amount of attention. The largest cities used a layout with two distinct zones, a raised citadel complex and a lower city. Dolivera is a notable exception with three distinct zones, a citadel complex, middle city, and lower city. Meanwhile, smaller cities like Lothal had just one distinct zone which contained both the citadel complex and the main city. Buildings were constructed with sundried kilfired

9:15 bricks and stone was used for the foundations. These bricks followed a consistent sizing ratio of 4:21. Let me say that again. Every single brick used in construction throughout the entire Indis Valley region adhered to this 4:21 ratio. This consistency was maintained across thousands of square miles and over 5 million people. Standardized measurements were clearly important to the people of the Indis, but practical design and aesthetics were not mutually exclusive. Houses in the IVC were built around airy light soaked courtyards which served as gathering spaces and offered ventilation necessary for dealing with the heat. Doors and windows were made of wood, often painted or carved for decorative purposes and outfitted with grills so that light

10:02 could still enter when shut. Carved alabaster and marble lattice work was not uncommon either. And archaeologists believe that these materials would have been set into the walls for show. But what truly set the IVC apart from their contemporaries are their advanced sanitation and water management systems. Sanitation was regularized. Every house, no matter its size, was connected to a network of covered sewers and drainage systems. And private bathtubs and toilets were linked to these systems. Fun fact, the IBC invented the world's first flush toilet. A clay toilet pot with a hole at the bottom where waste was cleared out into the city drainage system with flowing water. This means even the average Indis household, not just elites, enjoyed a level of hygiene that would not be common in Europe for

10:47 thousands of years. and public sanitation facilities existed, too. Consider Mojendro Daro's Great Bath, which is among the first large-scale waterproof structures in world history. The tank was lined with bitamin coated bricks and had stairs leading down to the pool. It was likely used for communal bathing and rituals. Besides sanitation, water management was also incredibly important to the people of the Indis. While Mahendara was dotted with over 700 wells, Harappa utilized a combination of wells and a massive central tank. Meanwhile, Doe Vera had few wells but utilized river dams and stonelined reservoirs instead. Speaking of water management, the IVC port of Lothal is home to the world's oldest dockyard. The dockyard had a lockgate system to manage the flow of tidal water, prevent silting, and ensure

11:34 smooth cargo operations. And if that wasn't impressive enough, the dockyard was seamlessly integrated with the city's drainage system, which protected the port from monsoon floods. Simply put, over 4,000 years ago, the people of the Indis engineered systems that modern cities still struggle to replicate. Daily life and leisure. Life in the Indis Valley civilization wasn't just a daily grind. Based on the archaeological record, we know that the people of the Indis like to unwind with food, drink, and games. Let's start with something delicious. Some of the ingredients cultivated by the IVC like sesame and barley are still staples in South Asian kitchens today. Ever had thul or chicky snacks found in corner shops across modern-day India? These foods trace

12:20 their roots back thousands of years to the Indis Valley. But Indis people liked a bit of indulgence when it came to alcohol too. Perforated filter pots from IVC sites show traces of fermentation which suggests that there was a local brewing tradition. And other pots resemble distillation devices, which implies that Indis people were refining alcohol hundreds of years before other civilizations. But what's a good brew without some entertainment to go along with it? Well, it turns out that the people of the Indis were surprisingly playful. Games of strategy and chance were popular among adults. For example, archaeologists have unearthed cubicle dice with detailed markings similar to those described in the Mahabharata, suggesting a deep and ancient continuity in South Asia's gaming traditions. Archaeologists have also discovered game

13:05 boards and carved game pieces, evidence of structured strategy games with rules and highlevel tactics. Interestingly, scholars believe that this game board found at Lal may be an early version of the strategy game Chataranga, an ancestor of modern chess. Besides these more complicated adult games, however, children's toys have also been found at multiple IBC sites. So, yes, the people of the Indis may have been productive farmers, engineers, and traders, but they also knew how to enjoy life, fashion, and aesthetics, a thriving industry. In the ancient world, the Indis Valley civilization was also known for its luxury fashion, crafts, and aesthetic culture. Terracotta pottery and sculpture were significant, of course, but let's consider textiles. Looking closely at terra cotta figurines and sculptures gives us a sense of what

13:52 the people of the indis used to wear. Rather curiously, IVC clothing closely resembles saris and doies in modern day India. But what's most remarkable is the quality of the fabric itself. See, the people of the Indis were the first in the world to weave cotton, hence spinning the fibers into fine, breathable textiles, perfect for a hot climate. These cotton textiles were of such high quality that the IBC exported them in bulk to foreign buyers. Jewelry was also a major part of the aesthetic culture. Archaeologists have uncovered hordes of bangles, pendants, rings, and earrings worn by both men and women. These items were not particularly rare. In fact, archaeologists have excavated hundreds of thousands of bangles at various IVC sites. Let that

14:39 sink in. Hundreds of thousands. Yes, the scale of the craft industry is hard to fathom. Beadmaking workshops were common in many cities and advanced techniques were used like earnestite drilling and heat glazing. Metalwork too reached a high level. But metal scarcity had significant impacts on the industry. See, bronze is an alloy of copper and tin. But while copper was mined locally, tin was scarce and had to be imported from Central Asia. Thus, bronze items were rarer and more expensive. But let's take a step back. None of this would have been possible without one crucial innovation in agriculture, double cropping. The IVC was the first known culture in the world to double crop. Doublecropping created large food surpluses, which in turn supported specialized labor, full-time

15:24 artisans, and a thriving class of merchants. Oh, did I say merchants? Let's segue into international trade. If there had been an ease of doing business ranking in the 3rd millennium B.CE, it's fair to say that the Indis Valley civilization would have been at the top. Trade in the IBC wasn't just active. It was organized, efficient, and expansive. Indis trade routes extended across both Central Asia and West Asia, forming a vast interconnected network. To manage this trade, the IVC developed tools of identification and control. Their carved seals, often depicting bulls, elephants, or unicorn-like animals, likely acted as commercial signatures. Pressed into clay

16:11 or wax, they could mark ownership, identify traders, or even represent merchant guild affiliations. Many scholars believe they worked like early logos or stamps, helping track goods, and verify senders. Some seals were used to fasten cords or sacks. If they were intact on arrival, that would have served as proof that the package had not been tampered with. The people of the Indis followed a binary weight system based on doubling and having units, a method that allowed for remarkable precision and standardization. These weights closely correspond to those found in Mesopotamia and Arabia, which facilitated trade across great distances. But the people of the Indis were not just traders, they were seafarers, too. Clay tablets and stone seals from Mahenjodaro show flatbottomed riverboats with covered deck cabins. Meanwhile, at Lothal, archaeologists discovered a

16:58 model of a more advanced oceangoing vessel with a mast, sail, and steering ore. Ocean oceangoing vessels were necessary, of course, to conduct high volume trade with foreigners like the Mesopotamians and the Arabians. The historical record provides some fascinating insights in this regard. First, let's consider the Indis Arabian connection. The IVC extended their Gulf trade networks deep into Southeast Arabia, forging particularly strong connections with the Amnar culture. In fact, Indis artifacts have not only been found at coastal sites, but also at inland sites like Salot and Bissa. We know that Indis merchants and craftsmen live for extended periods of time in Arabia and not just seasonally due to the presence of industy cookware and children's toys which suggest the relocation of entire families. Further, Indis seals and beads found in these

17:44 areas were made using local materials, which implies that they were actually crafted by these IVC expats. Curiously, the homes of Indis people in Arabia are found near the homes of local elites, indicating that they wielded significant influence. Now, let's consider the Indis Mesopotamia connection. In Mesopotamian writings, the people of the Indis are referred to by a particular name, the Maluins. The trade appears to have been so extensive that Malu Hans lived and worked in Mesopotamian lands in various capacities. Uniform tablets describe a Maluan settlement called Guaba located near the city of Ur. This village was known for its Maluhan style graineries, gardens, and temples. Perhaps even more mind-blowing is the existence of a seal from around 2000 B.CE. that refers to a Mesopotamian judge named Shu Alishu, who

18:30 also worked as a translator of the Maluhan language. In essence, there were enough Maluins in the region that one could get work as a translator. These dynamics were not one way. We know that foreign traders, Mesopotamians, Arabs, Egyptians, and Central Asians lived in IVC cities like Lothal with siding in special quarters. Trade brought outside cultural influence to the IVC too. For example, several Indis seals appear to depict a scene from the Epic of Gilgamesh, a sign that Mesopotamian stories had traveled across the sea and into the IVC heartland. [Music] Though we have learned a considerable amount about the IVC, there is still

19:17 much that remains shrouded in mystery. In truth, it's because the indescript found on seals like this has yet to be deciphered. Otherwise, we could shed light on these mysteries. For now, we can only speculate. But there is reasonable speculation and unreasonable speculation. Unreasonable speculation is couched in presumptive bias. This has been the hallmark of a lot of early Indolarship, fueling popular narratives that influence how we see the IVC even today. When archaeologists unearthed the red Jasper sculpture at Harpa, it left John Marshall stunned. To him, the piece was far too refined, smooth, lifelike, and rich with detail to have originated in the Indis Valley civilization. He apped that the statue must have been Greek. Not exactly scientific, wouldn't you say? But wait, there's more. Does

20:04 this bronze figure really look like she's dancing to you? If not, that's okay because you might be surprised to learn that it was given the dancing girl moniker on a whim. Nothing scholarly about it. John Marshall named this figure the dancing girl because he felt that she looked cheeky and exuded a natural confidence. His opinion, his feelings, nothing more. The priest king figure was named on a whim, too. Marshall and Wheeler felt that the statue depicted a respectable leader like a priest or a king. And just like that, it was designated as the priest king. So what if the familiar narratives that we've come to accept don't actually hold up when examined through a different lens? Did they really collapse due to a war with invading Arians? Who did they worship? Did they have kings or

20:51 were they granola eating hippies? Let's take a look at how our assumptions about the IVC might need rethinking. Mystery number one, was the IVC an egalitarian society? The IVC is unique in that unlike its contemporaries, it did not spend its resources on grand palaces, royal tombs, and other monumental structures. Early excavations revealed no obvious signs of a ruling class. The absence of overt displays of power once led scholars to believe that the IVC was an unusually egalitarian society, with several claiming that it was something of a communist utopia. This bland image of the IVC embedded itself into the mainstream narrative, but it's plainly wrong. Later excavations revealed the existence of multi-story luxury houses, which indicates some level of social stratification, and most scholars now

21:37 accept that uniform urban planning, standardized measurement, and large-scale food distribution could not have been achieved without a centralized authority of some kind. These realities, combined with the fact that commerce was tightly organized and regulated across great distances, has led to speculation that the IVC may have been governed by a collective of merchant lords. But the presence of influential merchant lords does not necessarily exclude the possibility of an indis king or kings. Consider this inscription describing the great revolt against Mesopotamian conqueror Naramsen. The inscription mentions a long list of rebel kings including Ibra, man of Malua. Now this is fascinating because it not only implies the existence of an indis king but it also further implies that the king whose title is man of malua was not an autocrat in the same way that a god

22:23 king of Egypt would have been. One could plausibly conceive of Indis kingship as more akin to a first citizen executive answerable to powerful clans and merchant associations. In the absence of palaces, well, according to a Pinder Singh, Indis citadel buildings could have functioned as palaces even if they don't quite look like it to modern day viewers. H mystery number two. Was the IVC a peaceful society? If we were to accept the dominant narrative about the IVC today, we would have to believe that the Indis people did not pick a single fight in 1600 years. No conquests, no rebellions, not even a defensive war. Sounds too good to be true, right? Historian Jonathan Canoyer is the main proponent of the

23:11 peaceful Indis theory. He says that no weapons of war have been found at IVC sites. They had no reason to fight because they had an excess of resources. When there was any conflict, it was resolved through trade and diplomacy. City walls were built to protect against floods and wild animals, not for defense. Even still, the IVC was too isolated to be invaded. Anyways, Kenoyer is wrong both logically and in light of the available evidence. Let's break it down. Weapons of war. Kenoyer claims that no weapons of war have been found. But the earliest excavations of Harappa and Mahendraodaro revealed hordes of weapons. Mes, daggers, bows, arrows, axes, spears, which John Marshall himself referred to as weapons of offense. Weapons even find their way

23:57 into Indis art. At Kalibangan, a cylinder seal depicts Indis warriors spearing each other to death. No reason to fight. Kinoyer and his ilk believed that the Indis was so resourcerich that there was no motivation to fight. But even if we were to accept this at face value, any wealthy region, especially a peaceful one, will attract invaders. Canoyer's counter is that the Indis was too isolated to be invaded. Wrong. Long-distance warfare was not uncommon. One inscription even describes the Mesopotamians conquering an Indis city and they invaded distant Magan and Parisum too. In fact, at Parisum, Indis warriors once fought in a battle against the Mesopotamians. Notice how there's a direct invasion line running all the way

24:43 through Elilum and Parisum into IVC territory. The westernmost ports of the IVC would have been valuable and accessible prey for Mesopotamian conquerors. Besides, studies of IVC skeletons show that they suffered cranial injuries at significantly higher rates than later periods. This data points to regular large-scale violence. Defensive walls. Large scale violence should lead to the construction of defensive structures like city walls. Surprise, surprise. Indis cities did have extensive multi-layered fortifications. In fact, some of these citadels were so heavily fortified that their walls measure 18 m in thickness. Kenoyer and other scholars argue that these walls were only meant to ward off wild animals and to protect against floods. But anti- flooding structures

25:29 are engineered differently and 18 m thick walls are not necessary to protect against wild animals. Plus, it would be foolish for us to discount the defensive watchtowers recently discovered at Mahendaro, wouldn't you say? Look, in Elim and Parasum, walls were used for defense. So why would city walls suddenly not have a defensive purpose in the IVC? Consider Surotara, where citadel defenses were upgraded after a disastrous fire. This suggests that the fire was caused by an organized attack and that walls were meant for defense. Mystery number three, who did they worship? Of all the mysteries left behind by the Indis Valley civilization, their religious life remains one of the most elusive. Without any deciphered

26:14 texts, we can only rely on clues hidden in seals, figurines, and structures. So, what have archaeologists found? Well, they've unearthed a number of interesting clues. Ritual fire altars, swastikas, fertility goddesses, carved seals etched with symbols of nature, and public baths used for religious purification. Interestingly, the lack of grand temples and the lack of an obvious priestly class has been interpreted by some scholars as evidence of animism. But one artifact stands out in particular, the Pashupati seal. The Pashupati seal shows a multi-headed horned figure seated in a yogic cross-legged pose and surrounded by animals. Some scholars like Asco Parola have suggested that it is a form of Shiva. Others have urged caution as

27:00 it's not clear that the figure is meant to be divine. Interestingly, this isn't the only Pashupati seal. Many such seals exist, pointing to the importance of this multi-headed horned figure, whether divine or not. Caution is worthwhile. After all, projecting later traditions onto ancient cultures can be misleading and ahistorical. That being said, shared religious elements are undeniably interesting and difficult to ignore. Purification by water, the ritual use of fire, the sacred swastika symbol and a deep reverence for nature all would feature prominently in later Vic Hindu traditions. Whether these elements were transformed and later integrated into Vadic tradition remains an open

27:46 question. So what do you think? Mystery number four. Why did the IVC suddenly disappear from history? After the initial discovery of Harappa and Mahendraaro, historians struggle to understand how the IVC collapsed and why it was forgotten by those who followed. How could such an advanced culture simply disappear from collective memory. They believe that the civilization must have been completely destroyed. It was the only explanation for this historical erasure. Meet the Arian invasion theory brought to you by Max Mueller and Mortimer Wheeler. The Arian invasion theory posits that a race of Indo-Uropean warriors, the Arians, swept into the subcontinent, brutally conquered the native peoples, and built a new society on the ruins of the old. It was a theory that fit suspiciously

28:33 well into colonial fantasies of racial superiority. The British, after all, were desperate to paint themselves as new Arians, continuing an ancient tradition of foreign civilizing conquerors. For decades, this Arian invasion theory dominated both textbooks and popular histories. There's just one problem. It's wrong. Consider this. There are no indications of a catastrophic war. There's no evidence of a genetic shift. In fact, there's no evidence of an Aryan race at all, let alone any significant step migration into India during this era. Even the Rigveda, the oldest Sanskrit text, refers to Arya as learned nobles, not as a particular race of people. And on top of it all, there's no sharp break in the material culture. So, if it wasn't an

29:19 Arian invasion or even a peaceful migration that destroyed the Indis Valley civilization, what did? Ironically, just as the abundance of the flood plains gave rise to the Indis Valley civilization, it was also responsible for its downfall. Starting in 3,300 B.CE, the Indis and Sorosi rivers powered the IBC. Its agriculture, its cities, its trade. But around 1900 B.CE. everything changed. The monsoon shifted. Rivers changed course and dried up. Crop yields fell. Food shortages hit. And the cities of the IVC were thrown into chaos. But environmental stress alone does not explain everything. As major trade partners like Mesopotamia went through internal turmoil too, economic networks

30:06 that once connected the Indis to the world began to crumble, the disruption of trade had a severe impact on the Indis cities. Street grids became irregular. Buildings shrank in size and quality. Streets flooded with sewage and piled up with garbage, not unlike modern Bangalore. Public administration broke down. Racked by food shortages and a collapsing economy, the remaining urban residents were forced into dire circumstances. Archaeologists have discovered skeletons littering the cities of the late IVC with signs of violent trauma. But these were not the result of some foreign invasion. These remains hint at local conflicts and internal strife, fights between starving citizens, raids from neighboring hill tribes, and more. Urban Indis society fractured under the pressure. As cities

30:52 became uninhabitable, the people of the Indis ruralized and dispersed. Some migrated east into the Gangetic plane. Others migrated south into the Dean Plateau. Fun fact, modern-day Dani clans like the Reddis still have significant amounts of IVC blood. New regional cultures emerged. These regional cultures inherited fragments of older Indis traditions, agricultural practices, urban designs, and craft techniques. But over time, even these elements were transformed and adapted to new circumstances. For example, the post IVC successor cultures would not have had the wealth or population density to justify the implementation of sophisticated sewer systems. It's not surprising that there would be discontinuity in sanitation management. Circumstances demanded it. So it was for

31:40 many other aspects of IVC culture. And that is the blueprint for how the IVC sort of disappeared. Not with a sudden snap of the fingers, but with a slow erasure and transformation over centuries. By 1500 B.CE, it's fair to say that the Indis Valley civilization had well and truly collapsed. Its legacy long forgotten, even by its descendants. Okay, team huddle. Is it really so surprising that the IVC just vanished from collective memory? Perhaps not. There were no glorious last battles to remember, no catastrophes to immortalize. This is particularly relevant to the Indian context because Indian empires rarely mention their

32:25 predecessors or even their contemporaries except in the context of a war or rivalry. Historical amnesia is the default in the subcontinent. So why would it be any different for the IVC? Even the Morian emperor Ashoka, one of India's most beloved rulers, lay forgotten for over 2,000 years. His story was only rediscovered in the 19th century thanks to scattered inscriptions. [Music] As time goes on, new discoveries are collapsing our tired old narratives about the Indis Valley civilization. The long-standing belief that the IVC simply disappeared from history is increasingly questionable. The IVC may have been forgotten, sure, and its script may have

33:12 become undecipherable. But if we look closely, we can see that elements of its culture remain, albeit transformed. And now you know. [Music]

Share

More video summaries