Ahl-e-Bait me Kon Shamil hain???? || Debate Mufti Atiq Ur Rahman Alvi Vs Shahbaz Asfahani

0:00 They are saying that I am doing brokerage As if you think yourself to be Rasulullah yes this day of yours The question we have is, Rasulullah sallalla wasallam said to Ahl al-Bait Those whom you believe have spoken of Hasar What happened today Asaf Hani sahab is in deep trouble and think of yourself inside They ask you to save half your life yes son then don't talk to elders Don't mess with elders Sur, these are strange If the verse is translated then Allah Taala addressing B saying that you are what to do do this don't do this Do not give up your life and this is the essence of the whole The conclusion is that if you do all these things If you do, Allah will keep the evil away from you. will give but I actually don't understand it I gave him advice and at the end he came He said that Allah Taala to you

0:47 It will remove the evil but not all these things Don't do this, write to them and send it to them, Bama Ahlo Ayal ji will say that Begum Sahiba to you I was not called nor were the children called Went Sir will not be able to come today Billa Min Satan Ram Bismillah Rahman Rahim Viewers Gahe Sometimes you watch many of our debates and we are very happy to talk There are many more topics mentioned above Ahle Bait Aahar keep debating from time to time Or who is the Ahl-e-Bait of you Prophet Muhammad in this Different schools of thought have different backgrounds Some say that those people of yours The scope of the Bait is quite vast in which you Prophet Muhammad's father-in-law, his wives and even his relatives Mohammed is also there because he is a follower

1:33 And if you look at the Durood Sharif, that too is Aal and join a school of thought It is said that Hazrat Bibi Fatima and her family Bait Hazrat Ali this is the Ahl-e-Bait of you Prophet Muhammad What does the Quran say in this context? It has been mentioned in Surah Nisa that this The Prophet used to make his wives and daughters wear veils. the bottom line means it is within the range daughters and wives then Sur's punishment came In which verse number 33 is mentioned with reference to the wives From verse number 35 to complete detail by Allah Tala ordered the wives, then one There is a hadith in Bukhari Sharif which says that Zaid bin Akmar is the Vayat and that Ghadar is of us The one quoted is a hadith in which Zaid bin

2:30 The scope of Ahl-e-Bait is something else Some schools of thought are close to Ahl-e-Bait The scope is something else and this is our today The topic of the debate is that our panel today He is an amazing person Shivaj Ifni You all must be aware of saheb because He often talks to us about such topics. remain part of the debate and today we have a A new guest has joined us This is Mufti Ateeq Rehman Alvi Sahib Naib Sadar Jamiat Hadith Sir, for the first time you are our Alam says too much flattery in the debate Walekum Shahbaz brother how are you hey wala salaam rahmatullah ji from allah Vesper is absolutely fine good shahbaz bhai case

3:16 So I kept it, I even gave the hawala It is an obvious thing because Ahl-e-Bait Regarding Ahar and Ahlul Bayt, which is a Strong is that opinion from the side of sh maktab fikr that whatever is there regarding Ahl-e-Bait We overrate some things, others maktab fikar so i want that cases You start it yourself and then we will debate will carry forward the Bamala Ala Rameen Sala Salam Muhammad Assalam walek in the service of taree na Rahmatullah as per today's topic, our There is a debate about which verse is Al-Bait in Tahir Who are the people meant in the verse Tatir who are Ahl-e-Bait

4:01 'Kaal' has been used, this is its meaning Which personalities have been involved in this and On which people does the status of Ahl-e-Bait depend? In this we, Insha Allah, also point towards the narration we will go and ourselves this word which is Alal Bayt We will also go towards its mafa, its meaning is will also go to the other side so that it is known that this verse which We recite Innama Yuri Dulla In whose grace is this By this I mean who are the people who are responsible for our today's Insha Allah in conversation under debate at Aga Maktab The first Aruj of that is the Vaj and the cough and On top of this, there are a lot of brokers near Ahl-e-Tshu. is present and this is also from Qutub Ahle Sunnat The meaning of the thing is similar to what is meant by Ahl-e-Bait

4:49 The one who is holy is the Prophet Sallallahu alaihi wa wasallam ameer momineen Imam Hasan Hussain and Janab Zehra Salamula Aha In this verse, these people are meant by Alal Bayt As I have said that the Kalma Ahl ul The Bait has different masadis, one at a time It's a word, okay, like I said, human The mistake of man is ours too sir Maulana sahab is also there, you will tell him that you If we are humans then how will others be humans? They will say shame on these Ahl-e-Bait, this Murk (demon) Its sources are different from those of Ahl and Bayt if If a misda is mentioned at some place then We will not munsar there that Wherever the words Alal Bayt are mentioned in the Holy Quran The meaning that has come from this is only that which is

5:36 There is no commodity in Masadi but it is mentioned in it do you laugh at this or not because We have seen in the Qur'an for Falah If it is used then this is what it means it can and cannot happen this is against that of the thing which is in the narration because In the narration we see a cat in Asnar It is stated in Al-Bayt that there also the kalma al bayt has come and similarly others also on maqama and now what we need here what we want to talk about is from this j you have to do that if you turn towards the holy Quran Look at what is said there Rasulallah sallallahu al wasallam his what did you say regarding No, this is what we mentioned to you I have revealed it to you, I have sent this mention to you

6:24 What should he do, he should do it with the people Who took the Prophet for us, this is the work of the Prophet Let us sit down and say, brother, this verse is about this In that verse it is about when we It is ordered that Juice And when we were given the command that the Rasool should take take it take it now if regarding this verse Rasulallah sallallahu wasallam specifically If you make the person angry then we will have to go to Chapora There is no need for us to go left or right We wandered here and there and told our jokes According to his style, he accepted the wish But that is ok because Quran Majeed has given it to whom? We declared Rasulallah to be the first Will you go to the doorstep of Rasulallah or Rasul Allah in this verse who is Ahl Bayt

7:11 What do they mean by that then we turn to the tradition Insha Allah those who go ahead discuss the details There must be a tradition also that this is the glory of the revelation What the verse means is this: the people from Ahl-e-Bait This is the Jawad Mukasa that I mentioned The rest of the conversation went as planned, Insha Allah It will move forward and we, Insha Allah brokers, will also move ahead in this Majeed will request you to serve him well Shahbaz Bhai with Ateeq Rehman Alvi Sahib Before I go, I just have a small question I would like to answer that what is this about Ahle Bayt The classification is close to Ahle Tashu What is that verse which you have described in detail I told you which class is this? There will be classification, not these four things If this is the truth then this is the Ahle Bayt and The one who is out of this should be in Lagvi Maini

7:57 can but ahle bayt is not Classification What specifically did I get? I have requested, I have requested very strongly Our intention in this verse is in this verse My mind is in the assembly, we are discussing about the people of the Ahl-e-Bait not doing as i requested In the tradition, the cat is called a Bait i.e. one who has four Ahle Bait Nabu Murad is here in the wall that who is Ahl al-Bayt Nabu besides you All those people are sitting at home they will be counted as A bait because they Four live in Diwali so one is here which in him makki hami himself has also said on this It was said in Mark 1.25 that here Al Bat B is the intention of the mind, B means that everyone comes in the mango All those who will be present within the four walls They come to the Bayt but this verse is special It is believed that this is the intention of Hazrat Makki Hami

8:43 According to you it is also good Raman sahab whatever you have He heard the case and recited a verse Quoted that according to him who is Ahle Bayt He told that he is Panchatan Pak and The reference was also to Panjatan Pak, we talked about it this is how we start it, whether the people Only the Panchan Pak is Bait and the rest are Ahle Bait or what they are saying in luvi myni what is his status is he ahle bayt he is not there what status is he in and what does it mean Can they be classified sir You have a case against yourself and kindly you chat about it please do Bismillah Rahman Rahim, the first thing is that what the sir said

9:30 that cat is also called ahle bayt It is in the tradition, I have no right to it If you will give me the reference of the authentic narration then this I have a question for them, please give me authentic reference It is better to call the cat Ahle Bait The second thing is that there is a Hasar And there is another thing, this thing is in the mind and in this thing the difference is that this thing means that It is Ahl-e-Bait that the denial of the other has been proven It is not said at any other place Ahle Bayt are two and the third stage has been proved But it was said that these are Ahl-e-Bait and it should be proved that three If it goes then it will prove to be one place I do not deny the other person, yes if it is said

10:16 Let's go, this is the only Ahle Bayt, this means the rest that it has been denied, now this is what we demand from them will make any one verse read like this He said that the meaning of Rasulallah Salam It happens We have sent down the knowledge to you people Please explain it, any one verse should explain it This is the only Ahl-e-Bait in which there is desire If five people are being called Ahl-e-Bait then We believe in five, but our This is the case of the real Misk Rasool of Ahle Bayt The voice of Pak Sala Salam is heard and its Along with this Syedna Ali RAZ is also Ale Bait of yours Syedna Hasan has included them by praying Sadna Husain Razala is also a person of the family

11:02 The prophecy is of Syedna Syeda Fatima Zehra Raz also The family of Ali, the family of Aqeel, the family of Ja'far, Raz Allah and he are the entire Ahlul Bayt if this When they say Hasar of Ahle Bayt then they mean this It so happened that I wanted to deny this to everyone else So do we need any argument for Hasar that There should be hasar and there should be denunciation of the rest, present this to us First of all, let us present this argument first Take this argument and then discuss further The argument is that of a hussar and a cat In the authentic narration it is said that Ahle Bayt That's absolutely correct Shibas bhai give this first Let's answer the questions and then move on to the debate Let's go, he is talking about big Jamia that any Quran that you have taken any one word from Quran Such a verse has to be told that this is the Ahl-e-Bait and The other one is denied, in this there is one more

11:50 The second cat who is from the Ahle Bayt Can you tell me by some tradition that this is authentic or Whatever advice you have, please do it kindly please tell me Thank you very much ji ji very nice The conversation is going on and Insha Allah these people who I will resign from this, I was a handsome man Otherwise I am stating the narration and the source I would have done it, said Mufti Sahab Alvi The one who is the Sahib is the one who belongs to Maktab al Hadith They keep a close eye on the tradition But still I am in their service, And I do whatever is required to be complete If you have a mobile then you will search for it first Fawad Hafiz Nooruddin in Masdar Majma Jawad Sir, please investigate this matter Abdullah Mohammed darwish ishak al jajal awwal al iman al ilm

12:37 ahara is the statement in this Juz Awal i.e. what is now This is the arch of Darul Fikr that has been established If the elderly are attacked in this then it is here Kinnar is a big cat which is one of the many After that Al-Mussan Imam Ahmad in-Hamza Its comparison with Ahmad Jain's Shari and Tahqiq I am doing this says Nad Hasan and here also called anar Don't This hadith in this also is of Ar Hamza Ahmad Jain With investigation Manat and Sinner say what they are Its name is Sana, this cat is called ok and along with this there is another reference to this I render my A to the service which I have started I spoke about the Masaad of Ahl Bayt

13:24 It is different, okay, what do we mean by that Who is your story? We have seen it in the tradition. Got used to the [ __ ] as I Even at that time I was requesting that the hadith If you look at Bukhari, then it is A Bat Ahal Bait I am lost now In that, Mr. Kastala Sahib Irshad Sari After that Ibn Hajar Saklani sahab Fatal Bari He himself came and their Ulama Ahle Sunnat He explained what is meant by these Ahl Bayt In which the separation has happened, I am explaining it very clearly in this I would like their attention and this too we can consider in al-Bait The hadith says that this people have become separated By Ul Bait we mean the Sahaba and not Ahle Bait Rasool, see the difference, people of this Ahl-e-Bait If you mean companion then you will say brother

14:10 How did the companions become Ahle Bayt, I asked He is present within these four walls I told them Ahl-e-Bait, the cat is also Ahl-e-Bait Now they asked the Quran from the Bayt I requested that brother, in the beginning I What did Rasool Taban say from now on? You are telling me that you showed me from the Quran If you give it to me then I will ask them that if you agree to this You should have read Ibn Taymiyyah who is your Yes, he is extremely holy and counted among the Imams Imam Ibn Taymiyyah sahab says Listen to that Miya when the Rasul says any Hadith that if you explain something then that Time, we will neither go towards Lughat nor towards anyone else in mamul fata they will go towards this I can consider it if you tell me I will also recite its Arabic vote in his service

14:56 So that it is easy to search, now What is Tamiya sahab saying sir that To find the misk of Ahl Bayt you must consult Rasul Why should we go to the bargah of Quran To understand the Quran, go to Rasul's court At that time you say that I will go from Lughat to I will come, I will bring it from such and such place, they say This point has no status for him now That is why I said in the beginning that Ahl-e-Bait What we have in mind in this verse is Min Hail In totality, Ummu accepts our wish Now you are telling me that I don't need the Quran Show me the verse, I am just saying that brother You are our debate in this verse, So you are al hadith correct muslim same chapter What has been established, Baba Ahl Bayt Fazal Al Hazrat Ayesha herself narrates in Bait Fazal Ahl Bayt is saying that when this verse was revealed and

15:43 Asif sahab I would like your attention and Mufti Sahab please note this and I will tell him I will also demand from me a correct Hadith Explain the verse Tathheer 33 and the verse which is This is him or Nisa Anbi from Shaan till the end Hazrat Ayesha says that when this verse is revealed Completing which part of the revealed verse No, this is not the only reward I got when When the verse was revealed, it was to these people Rasulallah collected the Jawa Muqaddas in this You are describing the verse as Nazul Rasool Mufti sahab is saying a very strange thing and without any proof they say yes Whose love is my wife, brother, who's love is my lust You can also go and see where the Majaz wives are

16:30 The reality of Ahl is gone, there are no Misda wives If you tell me, I will refer to this as well So that people can also become familiar with the word 'Lugat' that Majaz is used for wives The truth is not used for wives So according to Ahl Hadith now in the end I I am leaving the question for them that since you have Ibn Taymiyyah is one of your followers They said we are on the side of Rasulullah If you go then there is a correct narration from Rasulullah Ateeq Rehman Alvi sahab presenting the correct narration So and so wife of the Prophet said that I am I am one of those Ahl-e-Bait in the verse Tathheer I am a part of Misda, this has come to my glory There is a correct narration, Bismillah, this is presented you will know that Rasool has taken nas in his nose did you make a statement to the people or not Well Alvi sahab you have heard our conversation

17:17 The question was not answered nor did we say Hasar Give your argument, take the answer, you are good After our talk, now they have theirs I have given a speech, tell me my point in the middle Listen to me, this is what he has said I did not want to speak in the day but the issue This is when it deviates from its title and I will keep on speaking for 10 minutes and my question remains the same If it remains then will you allow me to speak? Because if I start talking about my I'll do it and keep talking for 15 minutes And I talk off topic and the listener You will understand that I am talking a lot in the meantime I am not talking, I had two brief questions The first question was that who narrates this hadith He narrated a very good hadith about I will give you the answer later because that The narration is just that, second thing is mine The question was that a Hasar should be born, the meaning of Hasar

18:03 This was the only question, there was no answer to it Diya, answer this first, then we will talk You have also heard Swanni from Hasar Answer to the hussar Answer to the hussar that the surf this is this is what you said that shaan-e-nazool also Meaning he has said that he is probably the pride of That was Nazool, we will talk about Shan-e-Nazool later First he will answer my question We say that Ahl-e-Bait was divided into five yes this is also this is also this is also this is also These are the only ones who say this, these are the people If it happens then this is what you should argue great and the other thing is that I said that Nabi as-Sala, you give from Quran and we give from Hadith Both are ready to accept from Quran Do you want the evidence of the Hadith or not? This is what I think Sunny bhai this is a big

18:49 It's a simple thing isn't it because you If you file a case then you must understand its logic You will bring that proof of it, rest of the I will answer everything you said later First of all he is right in saying that this is Hasar's These are only five Ahl-e-Bait and the rest it's not there, just put some emphasis on it Daleel ji I am really surprised I was chatting with the maulana while keeping yes brother what is called hasar ask maulana You say, let me write, everyone says Yes sir, this is the only personality that I have I am narrating the hadith that Hazrat Umm Salma is making a statement

19:35 The verse was revealed in my house, I said Which one Ila shaane nazool a verse about which it is raining what does it mean The rest of the people were not present at that time, Bivia She was not present B used to say that we are also included We are also in the conversation, that is why I said that He himself is a Hazar Makki and he is the question mark why is he making the statement he says see Al bat maas is meant here and it I mean what does Mufti saheb call it? Answer what does it mean and write for a minute listen you keep on writing keep on writing You will tell me what I want to say in seconds through speech Your conversation will not reach me with peace I will listen, I will not say anything for 10 minutes Ofcourse it will take time, okay now this verse should be revealed

20:21 and I was surprised at first Rasul Taban says give me a verse of the Quran and the Qur'an The Fahadhi has been done, well what do you say now Hazrat Sal remained or I accept the hadith which I have written now Brother, if I, as a Shia, refuse then you would say You might be taking it out of your pocket I will also refer to your book Mana Nek Saab what do you say to salma The verse was revealed in my house and what did I do said or I am not one of the rasaat

21:08 Ewala you are saying that wife is a reality you are doing ab inadvertently in ab inadvertently it is from A it is not from what you say all of you are among the unknown Rasool is not saying anything, you are the voice of the prophet, Ajwa Rasool hey rasul why are you saying this awa Further Harat Umm Salma says Who is Rasoola Ali Fatima Hasan Hussain? The limit is right and they say this with another certificate also If the Hadith is copied then it is written below by them themselves One should have the opportunity to come, they say this verse is special This Hasar Bismillah is for the people, it is not

21:56 don't see the point, listen to me when we are together We are debating, one person says one thing if it is there then instead of referring to it refer to the next lets start that means we just If you just sit down to tell your story When you sit down to tell your story, you both sit down and make a complete recording and move on Let's see, the meaning of debate is that a guy is talking about one thing without referring to it he said it like this he said it like this he said it like this He said it like this, you should also say this, it is not a matter yes you can negate them give when I speak in between oh let's see a guy now he is talking about me He further started saying that in such and such book it is mentioned like this I am asking him for the book Hasar open it, this is it, there is only one, this is theirs

22:44 So there's no denying it, there's no denying it the way you are is fine but when I If I refuse, then will you talk about it? When my point is only on Hasar that only this So just this argument is needed now that thing yes I have come here I have come here I have come here Brother, we accept it, we don't deny it We believe in Ahle Bayt Syedna Ali R Ale Bait Hai Syedna Fatima Zehra Razala Ale Bait Hai Sadna Hasan Ra Ale Bait Hai Sadna Hussain And they are Ahl-e-Bait, they are Ahl-e-Bait from the Prophet Kareem Sir, there is no doubt about it, just this The thing is, he just says this about himself This is what happened in this verse, it was revealed in his

23:30 what if it became known about it only This is the argument that the next thing you need to do is While talking he said that which the lord has said that you should raise your voice You are no longer one of the Ahle Bayt He is not from Ahle Bayt, show your shame Let me show you my job, hasar happens in a way that this is only Ahle Bayt, absolutely fine The second problem is that this is not Ahle Bait Show any of the two words from the Hadith and what amazes you again and again And the anger is there only because of this It is being said that today some person of knowledge is in front of you The one who is sitting with you on your words is a broker If I walk on the path you take If I keep following the street, it will close You will go inside the street and be happy, I will tell you

24:16 I want to bring it to the crossroads and present it in front that what you have said is that only these people It is a lie, we need the argument of Hasar in this I don't need a broker about this thing If I deny it then let me tell you, I am their I am also convinced by others but I am jealous of them The argument is important to me and I am waiting for it now If it starts giving its second broker again go this is also there this is also there this is also there so then I will speak in the middle because the purpose is this I am not going to listen to your speech for half an hour The point is that the point which is being discussed That point will continue until that point is resolved we will not move forward shibas bhai i let me make things a little easier Atiq Raman Alvi sahab says that these five The situation which you established that five people

25:02 Now the question is what are the wives If he is not Ahle Bayt then what is he classification they are just saying this He says that the Prophet (peace be upon him) has said that this is not They are saying that okay five, so we will accept it. So, we accept what you are saying There are five Ahle Bayt, you are saying that this you are not ahle bayt like you said you are They are wives, Ahle Bait, they are not good wives What happens if there is no Ahle Bayt then What is it that they want to know, please tell them Do you not believe in Ahle Bayt? Then what? believe and if you say the same that the people If these are five Bait then they are not Ahl-e-Bait what is the argument that it is the same again and again The questions are saying what you are saying she is absolutely fine she is so tall There is a point but you can leave this point in it and This time you are leaving this topic behind and moving on I am not telling that who is not Ahle Bayt

25:48 Then who is he what is he doing with the prophet you have to tell me this that whoever If you have lived your whole life in the Prophet's cell If he is not Ahle Bayt then what is he who also why is she staying then you are with salam They are repeatedly asking this question answer What is needed is the statement that comes to mind Now they will do what is in Quran Majeed Of Listen, we will not believe until we remember what They used to say that we will not believe until Allah You will not show us brother Allah Show me we will bring faith again, I started I said something which is weird I also gave you examples, brother, this is a very easy thing There's no rocket science in this Al Bait

26:34 I said you have wives too, who said no That is not my argument, we are in the verse Arguing or else the wife is in the house See in our books from So I've In this thousand steps we walk in such a way as if you are You accepted that the wives are Ahle Bait that the wives are Ahle Bait now only a dot It remains that in this verse the wives are referred to as Ahle Bayt Is it not true that you are rejecting this verse Let us argue this matter This is a very strange thing that I have done J Maulvi sahab will not let me speak in the meantime I will speak, speak your words, I can also talk to you, catch your words So the game is brewing

27:21 No, I am not here, I am not rich brother. Look, they are showing non-Muslims that brother When two Muslims exchange pleasantries One does this while staying under such polite guard listen to others and show respect want on your title You have said a small thing in life, by the way Is The best topic is general ale To save the life of a saint, give me the example of a saint I did not say anything I did not say anything I told Maulvi saheb if you give me just two minutes I would be grateful if you could control it, Ji Ji My point is that in the beginning I tied up a case that probably passed by here and there

28:06 I said that Ahl-e-Bayt has a common meaning He also has wives who live within those four walls Bukhari is alive, you can pick him up and see But there is a hadith that Rasulallah goes to one of his Salute to wife's house and there we salute Alaq or Ahl al-Bait are saluting there If my brother Ahl Bait agrees then it is basically a debate no the locality is not private whenever There is a conversation, first of all the privacy is decided It is done in the palace, therefore Maulvi Sahab also he was saying in the beginning that the verse is Our palace is our own palace, our overall palace is a great palace There is no rule as to which Kan A Bait comes in Who all own such palaces and how many do I have? it is not Nija you are saying that take it out Brother, give me your argument so first include me Rasool is not accepting this Hadith, verse by verse When it was revealed, to which personalities did the Rasool

28:51 Which personalities were included by Hazrat Hazrat Tell me that Hazrat Ayesha ever said that in these in this verse which verse There is Tahir in this; I am among the Ahl-e-Bait I am included, Maulvi Sahab, please present a Hadith They say yes Hazrat Umm Salma wali is mine I have read the narration on this I had also replied to a Maulana and this He did not say at all that the show Where has it been said that you loved Hazrat Umm Salma Rasool said that you are not from Ahle Bayt Hey brother, what is the prophet saying, in a hadith There is a tradition, there is a small knife Human being should not even have understanding of Hadith Should it be there Asif Bhai, you are the one understand a little what is there He said, am I not one of the Ahle Bayt What did the Rasool say, name is not a curse in this way

29:38 There is no sentence of Russell said Oh, you are one of my voices, tell me more Who has separated me from the voices? tell me ok Shaba Shahbaz brother ok my I have a request from this person because when I told you the intro We will also mention in the intro that According to Ahlul Bayt that what you said about Salam Daughters were like those from your school of thought It is said that there was only one, the rest took whatever was there was spinach and the way I re- That gazir of Hazrat Zaid bin Rakam who was There is a narration in which it is also mentioned that the people of The scope of the Bait was further expanded when it was Let's talk about it brother this is my other side in it If Ahl-e-Ja'far is also mentioned then we are Ahl-e-Bait In the broader perspective, we are talking about

30:23 Ayat Tathheer is also a part of that that you say that in the verse Tathheer this is their I am sorry, I just talked about it further I am just a small fool to tease you I am saying that I am from the people of Tashu I just want to know one simple thing what is the view of the Ahle Tashu, is that He is in favor of classification in Ahle Bayt actually I am not able to understand it right now You say that wives are also Ahle Bait and this There is also Ahle Bayt but this means something else It is not clear which five these are Their status has come, wives are less but men the question is this, he wants to know that this Is this the whole world? There are only five wives So what does that mean, what is the classification? Atiqur Rahman is talking only about this Alvi sahab and I are also from Ahle Bait

31:10 I am talking about the General, we will add more to this We will discuss things regarding Ahle Bait You are my father in law now and after that you will be my Salam then it is also related to the daughters of Ahl Abbas is the people of Ja'far and the people of Aqeel There will be talk about them as well, right? This is Ahle Bait and this is also different yes sir i know the topic So what I said at the beginning is a What you are describing is considered the Ummu of Ahl-e-Bait There is a family of Aqeel, there is a family of Abbas, there is Fala Fala is included in the Umu Mana Ale Bat Our private palace is where is our distance from I have a place in that world, don't ignore this thing well what i said is that cat is ale bait Your verse is among those revealed in His name It has happened well Aswani bhai I just want one thing

31:56 ok no don't tell me i will tell you I ask you are having two friends with me Now I am chatting with two people I'm asking you too I'm asking you please tell me the meaning of this hadith of Rasool Suppose you consider me to be a hadith of the Rasool I just explain the meaning of this hadith You said that when Hazrat Umm Salma said what I am from the Ahl-e-Bait, the prophet said, you Please tell me the meaning of the voice being from the prophet You tell me Shaibaz brother, see I have always nor do I ask you for guidance It is a little bit complicated so that I am your guide even if you are far away Not at all, they walk with great fun Just understand the joke but don't go because hey look please tell me the meaning of hadith The meaning of Hadith, brother tell me the meaning of Hadith Don't look, this is a public question, brother, okay What is the meaning of Hadith? Should I ask what is the meaning of Hadith? I am sharing with you a Hadith for the people

32:42 Hadith for angels is not the limit for you Why mom tell me I am reading it, please read it again I am for you Rasool, your tomorrow will be called a hadith means I don't understand what Asking in contact and Atiq Raman Alawi sahab is sitting, so am I not a scholar It's my job to let you ask questions In the meanwhile you were asking me See Amani Bha you were asking me that I You make them quiet for two minutes, I'll ask you I want to ask you just now that you said this Asif is asking the question of why Brother I am asking you this, I have a Hadith I will tell you again that Its main place is Hazrat this verse Hazrat Umme Salma is saying which verse was revealed This is just this piece that I got from them in the beginning asked that brother this 33rd verse or From Nisa Anbi to the end do I need a

33:27 Hadith can present its Shan-e-Nuzul What is a hadith, can you present it, write it down Please answer my question, present a hadith Please correct me by saying what is the meaning of this verse bro ok i want to ask you one minute I ask you, are you guys aware of this It is not the issue that the verse is for you people According to the verse, it is for Hazrat Abu Bakr the name did not appear there you say sahib If he comes then he should be considered as the son of Rasulallah This one is the companion of Hazrat Yusuf Now it has come for the people with him too You people should also agree brother, he is a very big gentleman If there is virtue of the Sahib then there are dozens of them in the Holy Quran The maqama has come on the aat, it has also come in the majhama mana yes it has come in mamu mana also then you say no here we see shaane nazul shaane I saw Nazul and found out that the person who was going to leave Hazrat Abu Bakr was Siddiq do you believe this Why is the thing here called the Nazul

34:13 Ibn Taymiyyah himself is saying that he is not going Brother, when the hadith of Rasool comes you sit and say what is it you sit and say that sir for this you Give me an argument from the Quran and the Hadith of the Prophet You are not even touching it, this is what you are saying I am agreeing that you should do it yourself If you believe me in this Hadith of Rasool If you can't do it I'll ask him Now note down my questions, this asanar bait wali We will refer to the Hadith here, he claimed The first thing to do is to prove it The second thing that is from the Sahaba Ahle Bayt cancel it, reply to that companion You are saying how did you become one of Al-Bait yes they have wives you say so Uncle, uncle, father, uncle, uncle, everything is the same How did you become one of the Ahle Bayt? The second question Brother I am asking you about

34:58 nine two questions done third third question and The third and last question which Maulana saheb should note down take it and reply on this i said That a hadith narrated from the mouth of one of the Prophet's wives State the plaintiff, lazy cow, that this Ayat Tahir which is the reward, these are the people who are There is Bait in them, in Ahle Bayt, in Ummu, so it is I am not doing anything for you and me in Umu It is a coincidence that Ibn Hajre Mukki Haimi I agree with Ibn Hajre Makki Hammy is not Shia brother, he is saying that Now if you believe what he says, he is saying that this In the verse Tatir, it is believed that the main intention is Hasar Wali And then we are ahead towards Manvi sahab f in one line g third question in one line that brother please show it to some prophet's wife that Please present any authentic hadith, you are an authentic hadith

35:45 So come and narrate the hadith in front of the people You narrate the denial of al-Hadith (hadith) I am reading the hadith, they say Yes, why are you narrating this hadith? what are you asking you who had to commit the crime Why has Rasool created a boundary? brother, he would have left the accounts open If the book was open, everybody would have joined in, okay? Why are you forcing everyone to join? You people are not forcing Rasool to join If she is being included then she is the wife of some prophet He should narrate a correct hadith from You may have said, brother, I am also in this Ahle Bayt I am included, please narrate a hadith, Bismillah Come on Atik Manavi sir, we are proud of this Why do we keep talking again and again We have come here many times and want to know a little about it Let's debate on the beauty of Nazul and the coming of Tahir So let us just go a little bit over it They are saying that there is some tradition Make a statement that where has it been said that brother we are his

36:31 Some voice was part of the Mujhara If you have ever made this claim then the first thing you should do is I understood, sorry if you said something No, you just noted down the question. I have to answer, see the thing is that when the debate if it happens then its method is that when I listened to his whole point, he said Yes, don't stop my issue in between Listen to it again, he started over again narrated the whole Now we asked him two questions regarding that claim He just answered one question immediately, Jawad took out Musan Ahmed, I took out everything I have written it and I have written its reply too. but I haven't given it yet I have not yet responded to the narration because I'm in another answer right now until I get to

37:18 I will not get any other reply from there. don't know I'll give it a go if you recommend it I will let it go, otherwise the fact is that As long as that issue is there, remember this and our Then again coming back to my question I have to remember this even after one and a half hours no we do but I keep the beauty in us I know, but you can answer their question too. He keeps giving references to the verses of Tahir He is saying that brother I will give you money for this import I will give everything and then there is also that Aayat-e-Mubadala I will give you everything, I will also tell you the Ayat-e-Mubadala everything But the thing is that when a person said something that he has done this or give some argument for his success

38:05 Or accept that I made a mistake and move on Jane ji, there is no hasar, this is also there, that is also a matter I will accept it but they are saying believe it it is and the first thing is that the cat If you talk about the tradition then the tradition The crowd is standing on the top of the temple of Sanad Look how wrong it is written I won't call it dishonesty, but it is not appropriate I will definitely say this thing that the crowd is my It is open in front of you, this is written inside it It is narrated that its narrator has taught The fruit of this dish is made from many things The issue is written above according to the narration It is written there that this Ravi what is the statement of muddus muddus ravi when it is said

38:50 If there was a Kareeva then at least they would have been given a place up there you were giving me the money then you should have seen the matter there Anyway, he put this point on you in a way It's a joke about my body that it doesn't affect me that this is my tune for Ahl-e-Bait I don't care about these people of Ahl-e-Bait There is a tune above and he has also said a sentence further I said what I said but I remained silent in the meantime But he has committed the audacity that the plaintiff A lazy witness is active, which means the plaintiff is lazy He has said this sentence to Ahle Bayt that Today he is very lazy and can't say anything about himself and this witness is smart about them When I spoke he spoke only rhetorically but I I have been silent because of the Aadaab Majlis but Anyway, listen to my question till the end. It is certain that sir you feel that this

39:38 There is only this in the rectangle so I just We need an argument, we just need an argument, otherwise we will talk This thing will not go further, if someone says this again I have come here remembering what I have to say brother Who is this who has to tell you what you remember It is something that you have remembered I have to tell you what I have remembered, I have to tell you If it is then it is a good thing, let's learn a lesson Have you come after remembering me or not? If not, then why not without remembering? You didn't come, you didn't get any leave today, today is a lesson remember now we are ahead in another place that one There is a tradition, there is a vision, now there is one There is a tradition that is one You should understand the opinion of the opinion then you You should understand the Hadith and now ask me these three questions I am asking these three questions, Inshallah I will tell them that sir about whom is the Shan-e-Nazool

40:25 What is Shan-e-Nazool about and Some lady may have said that we are These are the misconceptions of the verse; I answer these two questions I give it like this but it still remains the same You consider the Panjtan Pak as Ahle Bayt is it that one of the five is saying that this The verse came just about us if you I include Awaz Mutah, you question If you raise your voice for Mutara then I will also appeal to you I wish you would include five. yes you can prove with just five that they Said this verse is only about us Prove it for us When it was over then what he said was that shaane I would have challenged them again even if Nazul went away I am above this that it is proved by these five only

41:12 Make him say that this is revealed regarding us It has happened and you should also understand that there is a thing called shaane Nuzul still doesn't know that Shane What is Nazool? Definition of Shan-e-Nazul brother Understand what is Shan-e-Nazool, understand teeth it will not come by taking it out sorry sorry look sorry understand the matter this is the matter Shan-e-Nazool an incident happened because of that This verse came exactly as before Because of him that verse came, this is Shan-e-Nazool The reason behind the revelation is like Hazrat Ayesha's statement appeared in the Quran that When the sentence came, the verse came exactly You please present it yourself that this incident took place

42:00 Prove that this verse was revealed after that I also need Shivas to answer both the questions. So now he has asked a very important question I have asked you the same question that you said this that the wife should prove to him that he said yes that for us they are saying that prove with these five that he You said that this is for us, this is only for us The thing is the same, then the question is on both sides It is parallel, this is one thing and the other is the other This is Shani Asif Bhai, I should ask him Are Shias asking from the books or Ahl al-Din You are asking Sunnah books from where I have to prove that he is absolutely right When is Sunnah they are talking to Ahle Sunnat Say it with the correct authority from Ahle Sunnat I prove it by asking you from your Al-Bayt How many narrations are there in Bukhari? Well, listen to them.

42:46 Are you interrupting me with an interpreter? You can make it like this and we know Come on, how much did you feed the bull is that what you are demanding for an all bull is astonished Yes, this is not the case, just see now We are talking, didn't I tell you brother, see you challenged listen to me listen to me you challenged I have given it to you, from where should I show it to you after choosing it I took it and showed it from here, now you can deny it we will start what happened here Let's talk to you first, Asif Bhai, Asif Bhai Ji Now listen to the answer which he demanded The first thing I did was to present a hadith from the Rasool They say no to me from Ahl-e-Bayt You should ask why people do not believe in the hadith of Rasool I did not say that, I did not say that He said what you talked about that

43:33 Janaab are you from Syeda Ayesha Raz Allahu Aha or Show it to some lady about us In reply to him, I said that Anyone from among the Ahlul Bayt whom you consider as your Ahl You just accept their promises and you laugh at them Show that it's just about us your question is wrong I was going to answer, no problem, answer Mufti saheb, reverse and go now, Mufti Sahab said that Rasulallah is also in Ahle Bayt Are Rasulallah from the Ahl-e-Bait or There is no Ahle Bait, everything is because of them All the Ahle Bayt are near us All the Ahl-e-Bait are near us when they are not there The love is near us, all the people are near us It is the Bait, Rasulallah is also Ahle Bayt, but You said that you have nominated Awaz Mutara You nominated me so did I

44:18 I have nominated you to contest from Syedna Ali R You can go from Sadna Hasan R to Sadna Hussain Razla Tell them that it is not with these four, then I will proceed with the conversation I will give you this, let's tell you, let's talk to you if you are not doing it before then It may or may not stop, [ __ ], cool it down Sir, he just said in a cool tone that Show me one of the Al Bayt in A Bayt Someone may have told me that he just said this People will see and you will know later It has been revealed brother that this Rasool is also from the Abait I am surprised when the Rasool himself is saying Brother, it is Ahl Hadith that you are the messenger saying that These people are included in this Ahle Bayt no bhimini bhaiya see all this ahle baith

45:06 Because of all you Salam he is the nucleus And the rest of it is their centre, okay, that means Everyone is Ahle Bait, who will tell the story who is it come brother you will do it no you will do it Why am I narrating the hadith? We are not believing when Rasu is narrating it in Hadith then no Your question was that someone from Awaaz Mutah should say that we are more delicate than him My answer is that Syedna Ali Raz Allah Sadna hassan raja alla sadna hussain razala sada fatima Zahra Raz Allah Aha he says that only our If you are related to any of these four If you can't show it then if the voice is from Mutara Even demanding just one thing was wrong on your part

45:51 I want to prove that I saw you brought me with juice and I opened up I brought Bismillah from the prophet Bismillah He asked Rasool about my wives Rasool said look here look here and listen to what I am saying Listen to the claim, then give your answer quickly Why are you hurrying to get difficult She is going, you see, now we are with you we have reached a platform okay let's say yes i am surprised by the question that brother is saying Ahle Bayt are showing us other Shia books Brother Pak in your books you have mentioned the downfall What is written, Badruddin Zar Sahib says There is a belief that the people of Hujra are with us The Bait agrees on any issue and that is the argument Fakhruddin is not happy with you sir Badruddin Zar Sahib everybody says that I am a

46:38 First of all you should not believe in Hadith in your religion The consensus of Ahle Bait is not just an argument there is no argument, you don't believe them This has been written by your own Ulama so I Coming to a destination with you is very easy I gave you such an open field Brother, there is Ahl Hadith, isn't it a true Hadith of the Prophet? Narrate it as if the Rasool had said that brother this and Bring my Hadith against it Hadith is not going, I am not touching it and that Ravi Now I will listen to that answer too I am repeating the question again, now you said no That sir, show me one of these from Ahl-e-Bait Asif saheb ijma calls it coincidence that Let them agree, what can their scholars say There is Ijma al-Bait issue page number 349 I told him the name of the book, he says Ahle Bait agreed on some issue There is no argument for us when their

47:24 Coincidence is not an argument for you people Neither do you people take hadith from him nor do you people if it has anything to do with them then I am your From the books, these Jews used to call Allah Show it to us, then we will accept that it is the same one Now my Babana has spoken to Mufti saheb I request you, you were talking about fate again and again You are talking about Hasr, I read the Hadith On the fate that the Rasul told Hazrat Umm Salma It was announced by the voice of one of the Ahle Bayt I did not agree, you should have said yes, you are also a man That hadith is from the Bayt but has not been touched yet He did it and then he said that yes Noor Wali Hadith Full Story Read Full Story Read Mufti sahab, come and do not present yourself do what you are saying it is written there that This means that it is written there, Sikka Mudas It's a coin, it's a matter of Mudas, Sabi Sir says it is a fever, keep it with your head

48:10 All Bukhari Abu Huraira sahab is your scholars According to this and in its context I asked for the Tasat I will add here that Bukhari sahab Who all have said Mudas and this Maulvi Sahab I ask Maulvi sahab tell me this How many sections are there and what belongs to whom? Whose hadith is accepted and not like this If you lose your life due to the mudas then the fever is still burning It will be placed on the side, I will keep it with me I give side to Bukhari sahib, what is the point? what did Bukhari sahab do at many places Rays used to change their names intentionally If Rabi saheb has a buckle then yours is Bukhari If it's a mood brother then it's not your mood Do that, Ravi has taught me and I have taught this to him I presented the hadith of your Ulama while sitting like this it is not jaf this is also jaf this is also jaf Hamza Ahmad Jain has called him Hasan and himself He also has your own group, Hasmi sahab They are saying that its Rizal has been learned but this

48:57 That is, this is Sika Mudas and not Kajb The narrator is a Hadith which is forgotten, it would not have happened like this If there is a Hadith then it will be on Bukhari side So I am repeating my question again Mufti sahab is not answering Mufti sahab The question I am asking you in Ahl-e-Bait He is a messenger, a hadith has to be narrated from him Ibn Taymiyyah is saying that what he is saying is Let us assume that Ibn Taymiyyah is saying that When the hadith of the Rasool comes regarding something If it goes, we will take it, why don't you take it Be kind to him, a hadith from the Prophet State it now, we have left the field open that the prophet said that out of the wives There is a correct hadith, Atiq Maan Alvi Sahab I just want to tell you a question before I go to the I'll leave that question for when your turn comes You should answer that because see this You have given the statement Asani Bhai that you

49:43 From whose book should I prove that I am a Sunni from the book or from the book of Ahl-e-Tayo He said that you are reading the book of Sunnis If you do so, you presented a hadith in reply to it. that he doesn't accept any argument You have accepted the words of Ahle Bayt and that of Sunnis You ended the book by negating it You did not provide any brokers from inside, you just In the competition a hadith was presented that he was a man of What did Abhi Asif say about the Bait Sir, I have told you my story in Urdu. It has been said that according to Ahle Sunnat, Ahle Bayt This is not a coincidence or an argument, which one this was the language this is this is what I am saying yes, I did not do it, he did it himself He himself netted the matter of Ahle Bayt Honey Bhaani brother you said that I am from a I am narrating to you from the Sunnah what you have told me and you have just asked for this argument to that brother I asked him which books

50:28 So he said show it to me from the Sunnah Then I asked how can you say this is that you should show it from the Sunnah books The claim is that according to the claim, first bring the argument Your claim is that you don't take anything from the bus He doesn't even ask where should I bring it from Cha Cha you are here sir, first thing is this I will answer your question, brother. Answer: Now calm down a bit and listen to the answer. no in the middle First one person spoke, now you spoke first you gave us the choice where please present it to us then we will give you immediate reply That from the books of our Ahle Sunnat And when you know you can't prove it So you have come to the other side, let's come to the other side now You are deviating from the topic, I will not deviate

51:14 I wanted to stick to my question, but Now since you have started a very wrong topic have done it and they said that Badruddin Zarakh has written Ijma Ahl Bayt It was a joyous sound that the coincidence of our love This is a close argument between the Sunnis and their people It is an occasion for Sunnah, their Ijma, not argument So how will their books and their diyas arrive? They have no respect for you Bhaijaan, according to you he is a Momin no you are not a muslim How do you understand their recognition near you If you will argue then Ahl-e-Bait will be called Muslim do not understand Syeda Fatima Zehra Muslims do not understand Syeda Hasan Syedna Hasan Syedna Husain Ra does not consider R as a Muslim Those who are not Muslims do not understand this as Muslims You don't understand and you are telling us how is this

52:01 You people are talking about it sir, I am cite this cite this cite this I give Bhaiya I have said a very big thing and their I did it from the book, not from my words Hayatul Quloob of Mullah Baqer Ali Majlisi It is written on page 923 that Only four people after Rasulallah S I remained a Muslim, all the others became dead, yes This is you too, if you are the idiot of those four It's done now, then where did Sada Fatima go, Raj Allah Sadna Hasan where did you go Sadna Hussain Raz Where did Hazrat Abbas Raj go where did Ajwa go Where did Mutara go? What does this say about all this? You are asking us for an argument regarding Ijma Who are the four Muslims I am talking about? sadna salman syedna ali razala syedna abuzar

52:49 Raj Allah Sadna Makda Rajla, this was written by him It is fine if those who taunt us about Ijma They do not believe in Islam, this is for them Muslims do not believe this, they consider them idols I am silent, you understand the matter and are not in the middle Now you have remembered the certificate, now you have kept it in between I don't say anything, I don't want to talk in between do not talk in between this is yours The whole truth has come out now You came forward and told me about me later don't say anything in between, now you understand I remembered you, don't say anything in the meantime don't speak in between stay silent in between I will not say anything, remain silent and you are silent And when your turn comes you remember it It's our turn to speak in the middle of the conversation You say you should be silent, now you are not silent This is absolutely fine with our Ahl-e-Bait

53:34 love demands that you love them If you don't consider them Muslims then they are Kafirs Do you understand, do you understand the murtad and their Ijma what are you talking about you take note you take note Levani brother, you should note down your words In turn you will say that Mullah Bakar Ali Majlis Majlisi sahab has said something wrong Issue a fatwa of Kufr against those who Call Ahl-e-Bait infidels, call him infidel then I will assume that you accept his authority or not. If you agree, write another reference to Tafseer Burhan Volume 2, Page 308 is the commentary of the Quran It is said in your Tafseer Burhan Only four are Muslims and all others are murtad Write the third reference Tafseer Ayashi Volume 1 On page 181 it is written that there are only four Muslims I ask all the other mortuaries three I have given you 40 references if you ask.

54:20 I can give it to you sir, you can give me 40 as well yes we are giving you only three references You talk about them but you don't respect them you believe and then you say that the Jews said We would believe in seeing Allah It is the habit of your elders that you too This is what you will do if you teach such things If you do then I like you a lot more But I have answered you on this third touch. I didn't answer you on the first two. So the point is that the hadith which you presented Just look back and he said that I have presented the hadith from Syeda Umm Salma The same issue with Rajla came up again, so our And their difference of opinion is that this is one thing and There is one word Hasar Hasar show this it is not Hasar If yes, then we do accept this fact

55:08 show it okay the second thing is this He said that Ibn Taymiyyah accepted it We will talk about everything later, first you are a fool Show your face, otherwise our case will be proven If there is any problem then your case will be proved If there is no Hasar then our case is proved Then they say that Bukhari is also from Mudal All these things are deleting from the topic Inshallah we will answer all these later. Let us give some time to come to our topic that you told us that it is proved from Ahl al-Bait Should I do it, I said, you asked Ahle Sunnat from the books of or from the Shia books we have He told us from the books of Ahle Sunnat that you Presenting us from the books of Ahle Sunnat Tell me what was the question Syedna Ali

55:54 Razi Allahu hi Syedna Hasan Razi Allahu hi syedna hussain razi allah anho syeda Fatima Zehra Razi Allahu aha among these four Someone may have said that the verse which is included in Surat Ahj That's just the thing about us prove it or else our question was that You should understand the definition of Shan-e-Nuzul and this Prove that any one of these four It may be said that it was revealed regarding us and Shan-e-Nuzul means the cause, the cause Whatever happened during the revelation, the verse was revealed You can present anything, we will give you open time yes awani brother now its your matter Whatever he had to tie his knot, and they tied you to themselves

56:39 I also gave three references from the book, okay now You can tell what is on top of it this is right what is it and now yours now this Atik Manvi sahab there is no root at all in between You will be your own thing Hail Bismillah Rama Rahim Dekhi Nazreen I said that there is no hadith from Rasool Present the Hadith, I did not present even one Hadith It's a hadith brother, it's al-Hadith, see it all Viewers are not narrating even a single hadith today It has been quite a while since the third or fourth time, some one hadith I present to you Muslim I am not accepting it Hazrat Umm Salma The Hadith was presented from which we are not believing I believe he is shouting out loud that whatever is happening here Ahl-e-Bait brought Maulvi Sahib in front of me Please complete the frame, I can see Maulvi sahab

57:24 You are not coming, okay, you will come right now Come let me give it in the window I am here in the window, take this, yes, Molly saheb Maulvi sahab, I don't know what to say after seeing him Why are I not presenting three hadiths? The questions that were asked by our host They make me remember a lot but there We forget to remind you that brother Ifni sahab had asked some questions and answered them why are you not giving it, okay then say I will talk about the mood later, why? you also claimed brother why later I will hand over this to your Maulvi's habit They give the wrong amount and then go away and say later Get it done from me, I am on this TV channel Your Ahle Hadith Maulvi is a slave here Mustafa Zaheer Aman Puri said this till today His brother is missing, he could not be found, he disappeared after claiming So whatever you want to talk about here is cash I have to act like I'm talking cash Tell me brother give me reference to this thing

58:10 Should I tell you about this thing here and there? don't do that i will go and see Where will I go, I will give it to the good prophet From the Hadith till now this is on my side, Hazrat Hadith presented from Ayesha, Muslim has no answer I gave a hadith from Hazrat Umm Salma What is Hazrat Umm Salma saying after screaming What question are you asking Hazrat Umme That's why I am saying Rayat's Yes brother, no person becomes a scholar by having the name Hadith Even if one is able to understand the Hadith I want the hadith brother al man a bat what does it mean am I a person, am I a person Maulvi sahab knows that I am not from the Bait Hazrat U Salma has understood this thing This is a very understudied thing about you Everybody knows, okay, for this, someone has to do it This thing is not rocket science, it is easy

58:56 The thing is Hazrat Um Salma did not know that Why are you asking me if I am from Ahl-e-Bait? because they knew that a special There is virtue which is being talked about only then He asked then Hazrat U Umme Salma Rasulallah's most beautiful wife after Hazrat Khadija Afzal's wife is asking if I I am not one of the Ahle Bayt, the Rasool said, you If they are among the wives then they are among the wives and Hadith: Rasool is creating separation among Ahle Bayt Search, you will find it, if not then I tell me the reference again Well, you should also write down the thing about Mu. If he doesn't answer the question, then you remind him of it Correct hey u bo answer this question Riva and talk also You did not reply Saba how can I be your brother

59:43 Hazar wrote, if you say so, I will do it with all my heart Let me read it in Irshad Saar by Kalani sahab They have written lies, they don't know, tell them I don't agree, what do I say to everyone?

…