Principles of Choosing Psychotropics

Brief Summary

This video outlines seven universal principles for choosing psychotropic medications to treat mental illness. The principles, presented in order of importance, include prioritizing medication safety, considering patient preferences, reviewing prior medication trials, assessing ease of use, evaluating side effects, identifying secondary benefits, and considering drug costs. The goal is to provide a framework for making informed decisions about medication treatment while minimizing harm and maximizing patient adherence.

  • Prioritize medication safety by avoiding medications where potential harm outweighs benefit.
  • Consider patient preferences to improve expectancy effect and therapeutic alliance.
  • Review prior medication trials to understand effectiveness, tolerance, dose, and duration.
  • Assess ease of use to improve adherence.
  • Evaluate side effects to improve adherence.
  • Identify secondary benefits by choosing medications that target multiple symptoms.
  • Consider drug costs by opting for cheaper generic options when available.

Safety Profile of Medications

The primary principle in choosing psychotropic medications is the safety profile. As a doctor, it's crucial to avoid medications where the potential harm outweighs the potential benefit. Factors to consider include the risk of serious or irreversible side effects like organ failure, the presence of comorbid medical illnesses that could increase the risk of serious side effects, and potential drug-drug interactions between the psychotropic medication and other medications the patient is taking.

Patient Preferences

The second principle involves considering the patient's preferences, which requires understanding their beliefs and opinions about medication and mental illness, potentially influenced by culture, upbringing, or treatment history. Even if these beliefs seem illogical, it's important to understand and consider them due to the expectancy effect, where a strong belief in a treatment's effectiveness can increase its likelihood of success, and the therapeutic alliance, which impacts treatment adherence. If two medications are similar in safety and effectiveness, choose the one the patient prefers.

Prior Trials of Medications

The third principle involves considering the patient's prior trials of medications. It's important to know what medications the patient has previously tried, including how effective it was, how well it was tolerated in terms of side effects, the highest dose that was tried, and the longest duration that was tried. An adequate trial refers to taking a medication consistently as prescribed for an adequate duration and at an adequate dose, specifically the highest dose of the medication that the patient is able to tolerate and is approved by the FDA, also known as the maximum tolerated dose. The minimum effective dose is the lowest dose of medication necessary to achieve the intended therapeutic effect or goal. In general, avoid using higher doses than the minimum effective dose to limit adverse effects.

Ease of Use

The fourth principle involves the ease of use, including the dosing schedule (how often the medication needs to be administered in a day) and the administration route (whether it is taken by mouth, injection, a skin patch, or another method). A once-per-day medication is easier to use than a twice-per-day medication, and an oral medication is easier to use than an injection medication.

Side Effects

The fifth principle involves considering side effects. A medication with fewer or easier-to-tolerate side effects is going to be easier to adhere to than one with worse side effects. Consider both the common side effects but also the side effects that may occur only rarely but are potentially serious, for example, organ failure, heart arrhythmias, or seizures.

Secondary Benefits

The sixth principle involves considering secondary benefits. If possible, choose a medication that targets multiple symptoms or accomplishes multiple goals. For example, if the patient wants to treat both their depression and their chronic pain, consider using an antidepressant that targets both.

Drug Cost

The seventh principle involves considering the drug cost. In most cases, newer medications for mental health problems, which are still unpatented and expensive, are no more effective than older medications that were developed many years ago, for which there are cheap generic options available and are more often covered by insurance plans. If you do need to use a more expensive medication, then be aware that there may be Financial assistant programs available for specific medications.

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

Full transcript of “Principles of Choosing Psychotropics”. Click a timestamp to open the video at that moment. Need another video? Use the YouTube transcript generator.

0:00 this talk is about the fundamental principles involved in choosing psychotropic medications to treat mental illness in this talk I'll outline seven principles that I consider to be Universal for making decisions about medication treatment for most psychiatric illnesses and for most types of psychotropic medication this talk draws significantly for my personal experience and different experts may have different views on the topic I'll outline each of the seven principles in order of importance the first principle involves the safety profile of medications remember as a doctor one of your fundamental obligations is to do no harm as such you should not recommend a medication where the potential harm outweighs the potential benefit specific factors to consider here are the medication's risk of serious or

0:45 irreversible side effects such as organ failure the presence of comorbid medical illness that could increase the risk of serious side effects or drug drug interactions between the psychotropic and any other medications the patient may already be taking second consider the patients preferences this is the most nuanced principle to master and involves taking into account the patients beliefs and opinions regarding medication and mental illness which could be based on the patient's culture upbringing treatment history or other factors sometimes these beliefs may be illogical or not based on scientific fact or majority opinion however even in these cases you need to do your best to understand them and take them into account in your clinical decision- making there are two major reasons why why this is important first is the

1:32 expectancy effect which essentially means that if someone believes strongly that a treatment is going to help them it is more likely to help them second is the concept of the Therapeutic Alliance and how this Alliance impacts treatment adherence in general a person is more likely to listen to their doctor and adhere to the treatment they recommend if the person feels that they are being listened to understood and cared for the simple takeaway from this principle is that if you are trying to decide between two different medic a options that are approximately the same in terms of safety and Effectiveness and the patient has a preference between one or the other then choose the medication that the patient prefers third consider the patient prior Trials of medications it is important to know what medications the patient has previously tried including how effective it was how well

2:19 it was tolerated in terms of side effects the highest dose that was tried and the longest duration that was tried here it is important to know the concept of an adequate trial an adequate trial refers to taking a medication consistently as prescribed for an adequate duration and at an adequate dose specifically the highest dose of the medication that the patient is able to tolerate and is approved by the FDA also known as the maximum tolerated dose for complete a sake a related concept is the minimum effective dose which is the lowest dose of medication necessary to achieve the intended therapeutic effect or goal in general you should avoid using higher doses than the minimum effective dose to limit adverse effects effects fourth consider the ease of use this involves the dosing schedule or how

3:05 often the medication needs to be administered in a day and the administration round that is whether it is taken by mouth injection a skin patch or another method for example a once perday medication is easier to use than a twice per day medication and an oral medication is easier to use than an injection medication fifth consider side effects in general a medication with fewer or easier to tolerate side side effects is going to be easier to adhere to than one with worse side effects consider both the common side effects but also the side effects that may occur only rarely but are potentially serious for example organ failure heart arrhythmias or seizures sixth consider secondary benefits if possible choose a medication that targets multiple symptoms or accomplishes multiple goals

3:52 for example if the patient wants to treat both their depression and their chronic pain consider using an anti-depressant that targets both finally consider the drug cost this is perhaps an overgeneralization but in most cases newer medications for mental health problems which are still unpent and expensive are no more effective than older medications that were developed many years ago for which there are cheap generic options available and are more often covered by insurance plans if you do need to use a more expensive medication then be aware that there may be Financial assistant programs available for specific medications that's the end of this talk I I hope this provides a useful framework for thinking about choosing psychotropic medications thank you

Share

More video summaries