‘IT MAKES NO SENSE’ Harry Kane becomes 1st Ballon d’Or winner not to make FIFPRO World XI | ESPN FC

ESPN FC www.youtube.com

Brief Summary

The video discusses the announcement of the FIFA Pro World 11, highlighting the notable omission of Harry Kane despite his previous achievements, including winning the Ballon d'Or. The panel debates the inclusion of various players, particularly comparing Kane with Lionel Messi and others like Erling Haaland and Rodri. They also touch on the criteria for player selection based on performances over the year versus past reputations, especially focusing on midfield selections and goalkeeper opinions.

  • Harry Kane was excluded from the FIFA Pro World 11 despite significant achievements.
  • The panel debates the worthiness of players like Messi and Rodri in relation to their performances over the year.

FIFA Pro World 11 Announcement

The FIFA Pro World 11 was announced today, showcasing the voting results from FIFA Pro members, which are players worldwide. A significant surprise is the exclusion of Harry Kane, who had recently won the Ballon d'Or. Instead, the front four features Lamine Yamal, Lionel Messi, Erling Haaland, and Kylian Mbappé. The panelists are prompted to discuss whether Harry Kane deserves a place in the team and who, if anyone, should be replaced in favour of Kane.

Debate Over Player Selection

The discussion centres around the panelists' arguments about Harry Kane versus Lionel Messi. Stevie suggests that Kane deserves to be included based on his overall performance, reasoning that Messi’s recent play in the MLS diminishes his candidacy despite his historical greatness. Shaq supports this view by arguing that Kane’s contributions over a year outshine those of Messi, despite the latter leading Argentina to the World Cup final.

Historical Influence in Voting

The conversation continues with various panelists questioning why players still picked Messi over Kane, suggesting that history and legacy play a crucial role in voting. They highlight that Messi's long-standing influence in football might sway opinions, leading voters to prioritise his past achievements over recent performances like those of Kane.

Midfielder Selections and Critique of Rodri

The panel discusses midfielder selections, particularly Rodri's inclusion stemming from his World Cup performance, despite a lacklustre club season. They compare him to Declan Rice, who had a standout year in club football and influential performance for England. Panelists argue that Rice’s consistent contributions should warrant him a spot over Rodri, who only shone during a short World Cup stint.

Disagreement on Midfield Players

As they continue to discuss prospective midfielders, Robbo mentions his preference for Jude Bellingham and Pedri over Rodri. There is contention regarding the inclusion of players like Vitinha, indicating a disagreement over who ranks among the top midfielders based on overall contributions during the season.

Goalkeeper Discussion

The panel finally addresses the goalkeeper position, discussing David Raya's selection. Shaka acknowledges that while Raya may not be deemed the best goalkeeper in Spain, he fits well within the current team dynamics under coach De La Fuente. The conversation also hints at alternatives like Joan Garcia, showcasing the ongoing debate over the best available goalkeeping talent.

Final Thoughts

As they wrap up, Mario shows enthusiasm for Vitinha, suggesting that his achievements, including winning back-to-back Champions League titles, should not be overlooked. The discussion highlights differing opinions within the panel about player significance and reflects the complexities of player selection based on both recent form and historical influence.

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

YouTube Transcript Generator

0:01 The FIFA Pro World 11 was announced today. Remember, this is voted only by members of FIFA Pro, who are players all around the world. And the big surprise is admission of Harry Kane. You may remember he won the Ballon d'Or uh last month. He's not in. Lamine Yamal, Messi, Haaland, and Mbappé make up the front four. Uh Mario and Robbo are still with us. Uh with Harry Kane, Stevie, does he deserve to be there? Who would you have in his place? >> Well, I would have Harry Kane over Messi. It's simple as that. I mean, Messi had seven or eight games in the World Cup, right? But you can't Because you can't You can't pick him in this team because of what he's doing in MLS.

0:47 So if you're going to pick Messi for for what he did in the World Cup, then then it makes no sense. And he's not the only one, by the way. What Rodri is Rodri >> not talking about Rodri at the moment. We're talking about Harry Kane. >> Yeah. Well, Harry Kane has to be in there. 100% Messi should be out. As great as Messi is, as he's been, sorry Messi, you're out. Harry Kane's in. >> Shaq, do you concur? >> I do. Um listen, uh >> This is the the voting and of course top four get in. [music] Harry Kane missing out to Erling Haaland. >> Yeah, I I listen, I I I get it. Um that's the voting, but if we're talking on performances over over the course of a year, yeah, I'm I'm I'm with Stevie here. I think Harry Kane has done more over the course of of 12 months at a higher

1:35 level. Yes, Lionel Messi led Argentina to a World Cup final, but I still give I still give Harry Kane that nod of a Lionel Messi in this context. >> Mario? >> [snorts] >> Yeah, yeah, it's a difficult one, but I I I understand, you know, like it's easy maybe to look at and say like, why would you touch the diamonds? You understand? But yeah, Messi now, yeah. You know, now we also have to be honest. Sometimes, you there comes a time you understand he will look at it too, because have we seen Messi at the best as we normally would not even consider his name? No. So that's why that was the obvious choice. >> Uh Rob, are you going to say the same, yeah? I imagine. >> Yes, I was going to say the same, but the person down at 7.5 Raphinha, I would

2:20 put him in place of Haaland at the moment because I think he's a better player than Haaland. >> at the moment. This is voting over for last season. >> But but but [laughter] but we're all you we're all we're all you're all ex-players. So why have all these players picked Messi instead of Harry Kane? Is there a theory, Mario? Why? >> No, I you know, I think it's also a history going on, yeah? Because if you look at the situation, you know, it's still Messi. It's still look look you know you one you don't want to disrespect it. The other part is also saying like there are guys there watching Messi and what Messi has done over the period of the time the journey that he played football was admiring for everybody. So it's normal that you're then going to be like, okay, if I have to pick someone,

3:06 okay, you know, Messi has to be in that because that's my idol. And sometimes you go for the idol and sometimes you don't go for what really have happened in the period. >> Right. Do you want to complain about Rodri now? >> It's exactly the same position that that that Messi's in. Rodri in club football had a had a bang average year. >> He was first. >> Yeah, but because of what he did in the World Cup. But are you going to choose somebody who again had seven or eight games and was fantastic over that period of time against against somebody like Declan Rice who for 12 months was one of the main reasons that Arsenal won the Premier League and got to the Champions League final. He was also one of the driving forces that England got to the semis in a World Cup. So how can you possibly put Rodri ahead

3:53 of somebody like Declan Rice when when Rodri's had seven or eight games? Again, that doesn't make sense to me either. >> Pedri? Pedri didn't have a >> particularly good World Cup. >> You said the World Cup doesn't count a minute ago, when you're talking about Messi. >> Well, Pedri had a full Pedri had a full year. You're talking hell about a year. Hold on a minute. Let me finish. If you're going to ask me, let me finish. >> sure. >> You're talking you I'm talking about Rodri having seven or eight games, and Pedri had a had a had a great season with Barcelona, but he wasn't You take you take Declan Rice out of Arsenal, that's a far bigger hole than taking Pedri, who missed a few games with injury as well, by the way, for Barça. You take him out of Barça. >> If Declan Rice is so great, why didn't England get into the final? >> It's a team game, Dan. It's not a one-man >> you are then. That's the whole point, isn't it? >> him to take up tennis then, and

4:39 [laughter] that will count on his own. >> if it's doubles? >> Oh my god. [laughter] Uh Mario, who should have been in that three midfield? >> No, I love what you just said, man. If football was that easy, man, we all would be Oh my god. I would be playing next to Messi, and I'd be wearing the armband instead of Messi. Come on, armband. [laughter] No, come on. [laughter] The midfield for me like Okay, if I look at the you know, like Look, it's I understand what they say about Rodri because you know, the the injury and everything that he came back, so that 's why he's probably at the top. But I like There's so many young boys. I like Vitinha a lot. I think you

5:24 understand winning the the Champions League back to back, that's a probably [music] very interesting situation for him. Um and I'm a Jude Bellingham fan, so for me it's normal that I'm going to look at him. You understand to be >> Mario, BUT WHAT ABOUT RODRI? >> NO. NO. NOT YET. I JUST SAID it to you. I know the injury. He's been through it. If you talk about the World Cup, Rodri, I say yes, but I'm not talking about the World Cup, Rodri. >> who's in? >> Well, I I would put in Declan Rice. I would put in Bellingham, and I would put in Pedri. They're the three players I'd have in central midfield above anybody else at the moment because Rodri over the course of the year had wasn't good enough. >> But what about Vitinha?

6:11 >> Oh, very good player, but I just said who I would have in the team and it would be Bellingham, Pedri, and the other player I mentioned, I can't remember who it was now. >> You you forgot about Vitinha, didn't you Robbo? >> No, I didn't. No, I Declan Rice and and Pedri. I picked Declan Rice and Pedri over Vitinha. I love the two players. Declan Rice has been absolutely brilliant as Stevie Nichol said over the course of the year, and I also think that Pedri is the most the player with the greatest awareness in midfield to wriggle away from situations and create opportunities. That's why one of the reasons Barcelona score so many goals. >> Uh, Shaka's not having it, are you? He gave you three different names and you still you still banged on your drum. >> one and he don't What do you mean what drum? I said RODRIGO DRUM. [laughter]

6:56 >> YOU'RE TRYING TO CONVINCE everybody that Rodri's the right fit. >> mention Rodri at all in that conversation with Robbo, did I? If you were listening. >> Yeah, right. >> Eh? >> Yeah. >> What? >> You don't know what you're saying half the time. >> He said Pedri he said Pedri, Bellingham, and Rice, didn't he? >> Yeah, you and you're still arguing with him. >> that's exactly. >> Yeah, no exactly. I'm arguing >> All he's doing is giving you other names apart from Rodri and you're arguing with him. >> Rodri. Vitinha was my first pick. >> Rodri. Why are you arguing with him? >> Because he didn't mention Vitinha. >> I didn't want to mention Vitinha because I don't think he's in the top three. >> ALL RIGHT, ALL RIGHT. >> [laughter] >> ROBBO, HE'S NOT INTERESTED. >> STAY OUT of this, Robbo. >> He's not interested in what you GOT TO SAY. >> [laughter] >> WELCOME TO THIS, SHAKA.

7:42 >> NO, I WAS ENJOYING IT. HE WAS IN MIDFIELD. >> HUH? >> [laughter] >> I'm I'm afraid not to say Vitinha at this point. I'm with Robbo. >> [laughter] >> I'm with Rice, Pedri. >> Okay. Now what's Vitinha done to you? >> Huh? Not a thing. >> No. He won the Champions League. Rice didn't. >> Well done, Vitinha. >> Yeah. >> Okay. All right. >> Mhm. >> And what about goalkeeper, Shaka? David Raya. I have >> no issue with David Raya at all. I I >> Not the best goalkeeper in Spain? >> No. No. Well, not the best goalkeeper for Spain. I I I'll put it that way. I think there's an argument that can be made that both David Raya and Joan Garcia are better goalkeepers out and out than than Unai Simon. Unai Simon is

8:27 just a perfect fit for for how they play under under De La Fuente and and will not lose his spot anytime soon. But you can't again, you can quite easily make an argument that either of those two are actually better all-round goalkeepers. I have no issue with David Raya being chosen here. No. >> would be second? >> Joan Garcia. >> Right. Okay. Thank you very much. Just for laughs, shall I go back to Mario? Any final thoughts, Mario? >> VITINHA! HOW GOOD VITINHA IS MY [laughter] COME ON. COME ON, VITINHA. Two Champions LEAGUE. COME ON, MAN. I WANT YOU. Come on. Go and get what you need. [laughter] >> Robbo hates him. >> you go. That's to me. >> Robbo always trying to curry favour with Arsenal fans. That's embarrassing. Just very much. [laughter] Extra time is available over on our YouTube channel. Be sure to check it

9:15 out.

Share

YouTube Video Summaries