The iPhone Battery Conspiracy

fern www.youtube.com

Brief Summary

The video examines how design choices, software restrictions and corporate control can make smartphones and other products difficult or expensive to repair. It traces the issue from Apple’s battery-throttling controversy and the experiences of independent repairers to lobbying over right-to-repair laws in the US and Europe.

  • Apple said it slowed some iPhones to prevent unexpected shutdowns, but the controversy raised concerns about ownership, repair access and the incentive to upgrade.
  • Parts pairing, restricted repair tools, high repair prices, unusual screws, adhesives and soldered components can obstruct independent repairs.
  • Right-to-repair legislation has faced lobbying and exemptions, though EU rules have introduced new repair requirements that may influence products worldwide.

The iPhone, BatteryGate and the Repair Business

The iPhone’s early success helped establish a cycle of annual launches and regular upgrades. In 2017, Tennessee teenager Tyler Barney noticed that his iPhone 6s became slower after an iOS update. Replacing its ageing battery made it faster, and his post helped expose Apple’s practice of slowing some phones when their batteries could no longer reliably provide peak power. Apple said this was intended to prevent unexpected shutdowns, not to push customers towards new phones, but the controversy became known as “BatteryGate”.

Apple apologised, reduced out-of-warranty battery replacement prices by $50 for a year, and added battery-health information to iOS. According to information attributed to a leaked staff meeting, the scheme led to 11 million battery replacements, though Apple did not verify that figure. iPhone revenue later fell by 15%; Tim Cook said battery replacements had hurt profits, and Apple cut its projected quarterly revenue. The company ultimately agreed to settlements of up to $500 million in the US and $113 million for cases brought by 34 state attorneys general, without admitting liability or wrongdoing.

The controversy also showed that consumers might repair phones rather than replace them if repairs were affordable and straightforward. Jessa Jones discovered this first-hand after her children damaged her iPhone. She taught herself board-level repair and micro-soldering, eventually opening a repair business with other local mothers. Their work became increasingly difficult as access to parts, software and repair information grew more restricted.

The Barriers Facing Independent Repairers

One major obstacle is parts pairing: software associates certain components, such as batteries, displays and cameras, with a specific device. A replacement part may trigger persistent warnings or disable features unless Apple’s systems authorise it. Apple says pairing supports calibration, performance, transparency, privacy and security, and introduced its Repair Assistant in 2024. Repair advocate Lewis Rossmann argues that repairers should not have to ask the manufacturer’s permission to maintain devices. The number of serialized iPhone parts reportedly rose from two in 2015 to nine in 2020, although Apple began relaxing some rules for certain models in 2024.

Independent repair shops also face difficulties accessing diagnostic tools, manuals and genuine parts. Before 2019, Apple did not provide these to unauthorised shops. Its Apple Authorized Service Provider programme offered access to official resources, but Rossmann said its rules often required shops to send devices back to Apple rather than carry out repairs themselves. A later Independent Repair Provider programme allowed more repair work, but a contract reported by Vice allegedly gave Apple broad audit powers, access to customer information and the ability to impose substantial fines. Apple did not dispute the reported contract terms, while describing its programmes as an expansion of repair options.

Repair costs can also be much higher through official channels. A 2018 MacBook Pro owner was quoted $1,200 by Apple to fix a black screen, while independent repairer Louis Rossmann found a bent pin and offered a free fix or a cable repair costing $75–$150. Similar differences were reported by a Wall Street Journal journalist in 2021. Apple said repairs performed by trained technicians using genuine parts were safest and most reliable. It also told a congressional subcommittee that it lost money on repairs, but did not provide figures to support the claim.

Product Design, E-waste and the Right to Repair

Other design choices can make repairs harder. Apple began using pentalobe screws in its laptops in 2009 and later added them to other products. iFixit reported that some iPhone 4s returned for service had their ordinary screws replaced with pentalobes, making them difficult to open with common screwdrivers. Third-party toolmakers reverse-engineered the screws, so they became more of a temporary obstacle than a lasting lock.

Adhesives can be more hazardous: batteries and screens are often glued into place, and prying out a lithium-ion battery can puncture it and cause a fire. Apple introduced a battery adhesive in the iPhone 16 that releases when a low-voltage current is applied. Soldering chips, memory and storage directly to a logic board also prevents straightforward component swaps. Together, these barriers can leave consumers dependent on manufacturers and make repairs more expensive.

The same conflict appears in other industries. John Deere and Taylor, which makes McFlurry machines, have used software locks or copyright rules to restrict independent repairs. During the COVID-19 ventilator shortage, iFixit published repair guides and its chief executive later said the manufacturer Steris threatened legal action. In 2024, the US Copyright Office approved an exemption to Section 1201 of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, helping McDonald’s stores repair their own ice-cream machines. These issues also contribute to growing electronic waste: the world produces about 62 million tonnes each year, equivalent to more than 6,000 Eiffel Towers.

Lobbying and the Fight for Repair Laws

Nebraska farmer Kyle Schwarting’s $250,000 Case IH tractor repeatedly sounded an alarm over a faulty hydraulic connector he did not use. Software encryption prevented him from silencing it himself, although Case IH said customers could access diagnostic and repair resources and buy an electronic service tool. John Deere has similarly argued that buyers own the tractor but not necessarily its software. Schwarting joined other farmers campaigning for change, and Nebraska lawmakers proposed a right-to-repair bill.

The proposal failed after Apple representative Steve Kester reportedly warned state senator Lydia Brasch that the law could make Nebraska a haven for hackers, offering to back off if phones were exempt. Brasch said she had never experienced lobbying like it. Right-to-repair bills have been introduced hundreds of times across US states, but only ten states had enacted them at the time described. New York passed its Digital Fair Repair Act by 145 votes to 10, but amendments made before it became law narrowed its reach. According to Grist, TechNet, a lobby group representing Apple, Samsung, Google and others, proposed changes that were incorporated almost word for word. TechNet said its recommendations addressed consumer privacy and safety risks; Apple said it supports repair policies balanced with performance and safety.

The European Union adopted battery and smartphone rules requiring batteries to be replaceable with commercially available tools, with free specialised tools where needed, and spare batteries to remain available for years. However, an exemption for batteries retaining at least 80% of their capacity after 1,000 cycles covered iPhone 15 and later models, as well as some other phones. Digital Europe denied improperly influencing EU institutions, saying it had raised potential regulatory overlap. Further exemptions later removed products such as smartwatches, fitness trackers and electric toys from some requirements.

Despite those limits, EU rules have encouraged manufacturers to consider replaceable batteries, and require access to certain spare parts and repair tools. They also restrict the use of software pairing as an arbitrary barrier, without banning parts pairing altogether. The EU’s right-to-repair directive requires manufacturers to repair certain products for five to ten years, with parts and tools offered at prices that do not deter repair. Through the Brussels Effect—the tendency for EU rules to influence global product standards—these requirements could benefit consumers beyond Europe as manufacturers adopt common designs for multiple markets.

Summarize any YouTube video in seconds

Get summaries like this one for any video, in your language, with the free Summ app.

Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play

Transcript

YouTube Transcript Generator

0:01 We want to tell you about a conspiracy theory, one that's been under your nose this entire time. It's about your iPhone. About the hidden trip wires locked deep within it. >> There's something way more interesting going on here. >> Work your way up the side. >> The persistent pursuit of profit by one of the world's most successful corporations. >> This is not a secret. Like there is actually a letter from Tim Cook. [music] >> A battle fought out in courts across the globe. >> So is that considered contraband? And if that's considered contraband, can you audit me? Can you fine me? I'm not going to have you looking through my store. That's insane. >> The creative design choice is preventing you from fixing your own tech. >> In 2023, something like 78 million Americans damaged their phones in some

0:46 way, and many of those people discovered a shitty little phenomenon. >> And the people who are trying to expose it all. >> It doesn't sound right to me. >> Much of this has been possible thanks to Aaron Perzanowski's thorough research in his book, The Right to Repair: Reclaiming the Things We Own. You'll find links in the description. Shout out to JerryRigEverything, whose videos helped us break down this topic. And Climate Town, too. They have a fantastic episode on this subject. Go check it out after this video. Two toddlers are playing with their mom's fancy new toy. Wait, that's not a toy. No, don't. [sighs and gasps] It's bad news for Jessa Jones. Neighbors look on as she takes a sledgehammer to the toilet to free her

1:33 iPhone. But it won't turn on anymore. Crap. She tries to repair it. The old rice trick doesn't work. She opens it up, cleans the board with alcohol, replaces the battery, and adds a new dock connector. It turns on. Oh. Now but won't charge. She doesn't know it yet, but Jessa, a stay-at-home mother of four, is about to embark on a two-year-long journey. A simple to fix her phone will see her fall down internet rabbit holes, chasing parts and repair manuals dangled just beyond her reach. She has a PhD in molecular genetics, but no experience in tech. Her dining room will become stuffed with microscopes, power supplies, and soldering stations, which will eventually morph into her very own

2:19 repair shop. All from the small town of Honeoye Falls in upstate New York. She'll become a YouTube star as people flock to her channel desperate to fix their own stuff. That toilet has just triggered an unstoppable chain of events. She'll take on a system designed to protect profits at all costs. >> Let me try to fix it. >> Chapter one. The Big Apple. It's 2007. The first iPhone has just launched. >> I just take my finger >> quickly become a cult gadget. >> [music] >> and I scroll. >> Fans camp out overnight to get their hands on one. >> Since 6:00 this morning. There's no physical keypad. It's virtual. >> Apple HQ, things are glorious. Sales are soaring and their profits are huge.

3:07 Within 74 days, Apple has sold a million iPhones. The iPhone will become Apple's best-selling product. And for a while, it seems like this could go on forever. But then three years later, things take a weird turn. Thanks to an unassuming Reddit post. It's 2017. A teenager from Tennessee thinks something's up with his iPhone 6s. His name is Tyler Barney. Since downloading the new iOS update, he swears his phone is draining his charge way faster. [music] Every day it gets slower and slower. Even just typing becomes painful. Wait for it. Could his battery be the problem?

3:52 He changes it and his phone speeds up instantly. So he takes his findings online. >> From what I can tell, Apple slows down phones when their battery gets too low so you can still have a full day's charge. This also means your phone might be very slow for no discernible reason. >> Turns out he isn't alone. His post goes viral. The story goes mainstream and will be called >> Battery Gate. >> If you have an older model iPhone and notice it's been working slower, Apple has finally admitted it did that on purpose. >> Well, they're telling us about it because [music] they got busted on Reddit right? >> Apple's belong in a fruit basket. >> I think that it's a well thought out plan by Apple to make sure the consumers come back and buy the latest and greatest phone. >> [music]

4:37 >> It makes it look like Apple is slowing down iPhones to push people to buy new ones. There isn't concrete evidence that this was its actual policy, and Apple's denied it ever since, stating that it only wanted to protect the devices from issues related to dying lithium batteries. [music] But it's a PR disaster nonetheless. Apple is forced to act. In December 2017, Apple issues an apology. The company writes, we know that some of you feel Apple has let you down. We apologize. It then goes on to stress that it has never and would never do anything to intentionally shorten the life of any product. The message outlined the steps that would be taken to regain the trust of anyone who may have doubted Apple's intentions. For those affected by the scandal, for a year, Apple cuts the price of an out of

5:23 warranty iPhone battery replacement by $50. According to leaked information from a staff meeting, Tim Cook is said to have admitted that Apple replaced 11 million batteries through the scheme. We asked Apple to verify this. It didn't address these figures in its reply. In 2018, Apple also rolls out a new iOS software update, giving users more insight into the health of their iPhone's battery. But to make things worse, shortly after, Trump escalates a trade war with one of Apple's biggest markets, China. [music] At the same time, customers love the battery replacement scheme, which is unfortunate for Apple. iPhone revenue falls by 15%. In late [music] 2018, Apple stops publishing iPhone sales separate from other products. In a letter to

6:09 shareholders, Tim Cook admits that battery replacements hurt Apple's profits. He reduces the company's projected revenue for the first quarter of 2019 to $84 billion. [music] That's a $5 to $9 billion drop from the previous estimate. The next day, when the markets open, they react badly. >> of the worst days in history >> Shares fall by almost 10% in a single day. This is bad, really bad. Battery gate will go on to haunt Apple for years. To this day, there is still ongoing class action lawsuits against the company, such as those in the UK. In the US, there have been multiple lawsuits. Apple eventually settled in 2020, agreeing to pay up to $500 million in compensation to its customers in the US, alongside [music]

6:54 $113 million to resolve cases raised by 34 state attorneys general. But despite forking out up to $613 million across these two separate settlements, Apple [music] never admitted any liability or wrongdoing as part of its settlement. It's always maintained that it slowed down iPhones to prevent unexpected shutdowns. In the run-up to battery gate, it was common to upgrade your phone before it actually needed to be replaced. A study found that between 2014 and 2015, the majority of Americans replaced their phones around the two-year mark. Glitzy marketing campaigns >> from here to here. >> Enticing phone contracts and tantalizing upgrades encourage consumers to flock to the latest model, while design tweaks ensure that older models stand out. It's the ultimate status symbol.

7:42 You have to keep up. >> Why is it so important for you to have the latest phone? >> This time they are in different color. >> To satisfy this, new iPhone models are launched annually to great fanfare, each marketed as even better than the last. >> is the most powerful >> the most precise thing we've ever done. >> Apple needs to keep this going, but the battery replacement program highlighted a new threat, the repair market. It demonstrated that if extending their phones lifespan were affordable and straightforward, millions of consumers would gladly choose that route rather than upgrading. But as Tim Cook warned, this puts their profits in jeopardy. Apple has to sell more products. So, would it theoretically help their bottom line if, just as a thought experiment, your phone started to break

8:29 in some way? Chapter two. David versus Goliath. Jessa Jones continues her mission to repair her iPhone. With the help of online guides, she opens it up, cleans [music] it, and dries it out. It turns on. Phew. But it won't [music] charge. She replaces the battery, then the charging port. It still won't work. So she ends up teaching herself how to fix whole motherboards, picking up micro soldering skills along the way. In her eagerness to learn, she makes the device much worse before she can make it better. But eventually, she sees a charging current start to flow into her beaten up iPhone 4S. It took her two years, but she's finally nailed it. Inspired, she starts a repair business,

9:15 recruiting other moms in her neighborhood to fix a mountain of broken tech. Time goes by, and for some reason, their jobs seem to be getting harder. They'll have to encounter restrictive diagnostic software, [music] parts pairing, and the pentalobe screw. But Jessa won't be defeated. Problem one. Parts pairing. It's 2019. You're at home trying to replace your iPhone XS's battery. Your friend dropped theirs and shattered the screen, but the battery is still good. It's the same model as yours, and they offer it to you. Suddenly, a message pops up. Apple has added a software check to the iPhone's code. It can detect when certain parts have been replaced. For

10:01 instance, the battery, the display, and the camera. You installed the battery correctly, but you're bombarded with warning messages. You You them, but they keep coming back. You go into settings. Maybe you'll be able to get rid of it there. Another warning. No matter how hard you try, you can't fix it. Eventually, they start to vanish from your home screen, but the annoying alert in your settings will never go away. And you won't be able to access certain functions, such as your battery's health information. This is known as parts pairing. Parts are given a unique serial number. These serialized parts are then paired with a specific iPhone using Apple software. If any of these parts need replacing, new parts won't be detected unless they're remotely paired with the device

10:46 via a software update from the manufacturer. If you try to replace, say, a broken display with a recycled one, even if it's from Apple, the software will flag this and keep sending error codes to your iPhone. But if you go to an Apple store, their technicians [music] can perform the software update. This officially authorizes the new parts on Apple's end, which banishes those pesky error messages. Apple says that parts pairing is critical to preserving iPhone users' privacy, security, and safety. This nightmare for independent repair workers has worsened over the years as Apple began to increase the number of serialized parts used in its phones. Right to Repair Europe reported that in 2015, only two of the iPhone's parts were serialized. In 2020, [music] that number had increased to nine. As the number of serialized parts grew,

11:32 so too did the frustration of customers and repair workers. In 2024, the company started to relax its rules around parts pairing, [music] at least for certain iPhone models. But Lewis Rossmann, a repair expert and advocate turned YouTuber, says this doesn't go far enough. >> If they don't give you access to the parts pairing tool, what they're saying is if you want to do maintenance on your own device, you [music] must ask us for permission. And if we don't give you permission, then you. And I think that that is highly inappropriate. I think that that is just one of many things that is leading to the death of the concept of ownership. >> He thinks any form of parts pairing should be stopped. [music] Samsung has also been caught engaging in parts pairing, but to a lesser degree that Apple We asked Apple about its parts pairing policy. Though the company didn't comment on our questions specifically,

12:19 it generally pointed out that the practice isn't intended to make customers come to Apple for repairs. The practice, Apple said, is necessary to enable calibration, ensure consistent performance, and ensure that repairs are transparent and critical security features are protected. In 2024, it launched a tool called the Repair Assistant to help customers and repair providers complete calibration following a repair. It said Apple will not actively disable third-party parts unless a component is a security or privacy risk. Despite these issues, Apple still has a devoted fan base. Part of that is the design, sleek, polished, and instantly recognizable. Beautiful things make us happy. That's true for our tech and even more so for our homes. This plate lets you bring your favorite franchises off

13:04 the screen and into your home with high-quality metal posters built to last. We chose a few of our favorite film worlds, from surreal sci-fi to iconic crime and heist films. The visuals make for great artwork beyond the screen. Choose from over 2 million designs, including officially licensed artwork from iconic films and TV shows. There are also over 40,000 designs by independent artists, or you can upload your own creations. Whether you're into films, gaming, or anime, there's something for you. [music] It also makes for a great gift. Installation is simple. Stick the mount to the wall, attach the magnet, and click your print into place. No drilling, no holes, no tools needed. And if you fancy a change, you can swap posters in seconds. Displate offers various finishes to

13:50 really make the designs pop. Displate's biggest sale of the year is on right now with 34% off one or two plates, 38% off three or four, and 42% off five or more. [music] Scan the QR code or click the link in the description. Problem two, Apple authorized service centers. Imagine you're an independent repair shop owner and someone walks in with a broken 2018 MacBook Pro. You aren't sure what's wrong with it. You'll need to open it up to run a diagnostic check. To do that, you'll need Apple's special tools. To open the laptop up, you'll need to use the notorious pentalobe screwdriver. For the check, you'll use Apple's catchily named diagnostic software, Apple Services Toolkit.

14:36 Okay, fine. Where do you buy or access these tools? Well, if you aren't a repair nerd, try a handy little shop called Nowhere. Up until 2019, there was no way Apple would sell its tools, design plans, or replacement parts to unauthorized repair shops. If you want a board view, for example, which is essentially a map of the motherboard, you may struggle. Apple doesn't usually publish them. These plans keep surfacing on the dark web from time to time, presumably from sources such as company employees or from other leaks or security breaches. By leaking information like this, employees risk their jobs and could even face prison time. There are no legal barriers to independent repair shops fixing devices, but if they want replacement parts, they have to source them from third parties or use second-hand Apple parts,

15:21 typically ones recycled overseas. But there is another way. In 2019, you could sign up to become an Apple Authorized Service Provider, or AASP, in order to fix Apple [music] products. Apple advertises this as a way for third parties to get access to genuine Apple parts, official tools, [music] training, and resources for performing certain types of repairs. Sounds great. But Lewis Rossmann has some notes. >> The reason that we are an independent service provider, rather than Apple Authorized Service Provider, is because if I was an Apple Authorized Service Provider, I would not be fixing things. I would be putting things in a box, mailing it back to Apple, and then getting a replacement or refurbished device for a customer. And I don't want to be doing that. I want to actually do repairs. I'm a repair person. And I would love nothing more than if the

16:07 Apple Authorized Repair Service program allowed me to get access to the things I need to do my job, but it doesn't. >> Apple didn't specifically reply on this matter, but generally pointed out that especially since 2019, it's expanded customer repair options and access to genuine Apple parts, tools, diagnostics, training, and repair information for independent repair providers and customers. Before that time, the repairs AASP's could undertake were limited. But in 2019, an additional scheme appeared, the Independent Repair Provider Program. This essentially allowed participants to conduct a wide range of repairs without needing to meet the full obligations of the AASP program. But according to Vice's reporting, there were rules. To join this new scheme, businesses had to sign a contract which Vice claims to

16:53 have seen. It gave Apple permission to conduct unannounced audits. These random inspections allegedly gave the company access to customers' personal information and the power to interview employees. After an audit, if Apple determined that more than 2% of a repair business's transactions involved with their contracts call prohibited products, it could fine the business $1,000 for every transaction that occurred during the audit period. If a business decided to withdraw from the program, Apple reserved the right to continue auditing it for up to 5 years. If you were still thinking about signing up, Vice says you'd have to sign an NDA to see the exact terms of the contract. For most, that price was just too high. Just under a year after the program began, only 140 independent [music]

17:40 repair companies across the US had signed up. We asked Apple to respond to the allegations raised by Vice. While it didn't answer our questions on the record, it didn't dispute the authenticity of any of these contractual terms. Generally, Apple said the program was a meaningful expansion of its repair options and that the scheme allowed repair companies of all sizes to access genuine Apple parts as well as tools, diagnostics, and [music] training. >> So in my opinion, a lot of these programs are designed to look like they are making something available to a legislator when it's not. Because if I was not an expert in this field and I saw the website that they put together and I saw this all these repair people just don't want to use these programs, I would think as a legislator, yeah, they're just never going to be happy. It's okay. Apple did what they needed to do. We don't need to make a law for this. And I would move on. I believe that's

18:26 what they're designed to do, and I believe they've been very effective at it. >> Problem three, costly repairs. Next, let's see your MacBook Pro's screen isn't working right. When you switch it on, the screen stays black. No matter which buttons you press, nothing lights up. It's 2018, so you go to the Genius Bar, Apple's in-store technical support and repair counter. They're taking a good look. And that's reassuring because these people are geniuses. Apple says so. You're in good hands. And then they tell you the price. $1,200. Are there any cheaper alternatives, you ask? No, it needs significant repairs. But as the employee points out, $1,200 could almost buy you a new laptop.

19:14 Yeah, no. You change tactics. Louis Rossmann has a repair shop on 1st Avenue in Manhattan, New York. He opens up the MacBook. Turns out the problem is just a bent pin. It got disconnected from your laptop's backlight, the feature that makes the screen light up. Louis offers to bend it back for free, or he can rework the cable for $75 to $150. Once he does, your screen flashes back to life. We didn't make this up. This actually happened to a CBC reporter who went undercover. >> To fix it entirely will cost more than $1,000? >> Yeah. >> And according to the editor in chief of Motherboard, it's not a one-off. In 2021, a reporter from the Wall Street Journal had a similar experience. Apple quoted her higher prices for repair than independent repair shops did.

20:00 In response, Apple told the Journal, we believe the safest and most reliable repair is one handled by a trained technician using Apple genuine parts. [music] And we continue to expand Apple's offerings to better meet our customers' needs. We also asked Apple about such incidents. Apple didn't comment. At some point, Congress took notice. In 2019, the House Subcommittee on Antitrust, Commercial and Administrative Law demanded answers from Apple as part of a wider investigation into anti-competitive practices. In its written response, Apple claimed it loses money on repairs. It didn't provide figures to back that up, and there's no way to fact-check its accounting based on its revenue reporting. But looking at the cost of spare parts and labor, experts question how Apple could not profit from repairs. >> It could be one of two options. Behind

20:46 door number one, you're lying and you're totally full of Behind door number two, you're telling the truth because you suck at your job that much. It's very likely that that they could be telling the truth, that Apple loses money off of doing repairs because they are so bad at their job. >> Again, Apple didn't comment when confronted with this allegation. Problem four, screws, glues, and more. Unfortunately, parts pairing, strict rules for authorized repair shops, and costly bills at the Genius Bar aren't the only barriers to repairs. Meet the pentalobe screw. It looks kind of like a five-petaled flower. No, not points. These are rounded. This feature distinguishes these screws from the ones most people recognize, Phillips standard and the six-point

21:31 torque shape. Apple began using these screws in the MacBook Pro in 2009. From the iPhone 4 era onward, it started adding them to many of its other devices. See these two tiny screws on either side of the charging port at the bottom of the phone? They are pentalobes. The controversial part was that Apple wasn't just using them on new phones. iFixit is a company that publishes free repair manuals and sells repair tools. In 2011, it reported that when some customers brought iPhone 4s into the Apple Store to be serviced, technicians would replace their ordinary screws with pentalobe ones, but only after asking their explicit permission. Just kidding. Apple didn't even tell them, at least according to iFixit. When we asked Apple about this, it declined to comment. Now, if you try to open the device after

22:16 a trip to the Genius Bar, your tiny Phillips screwdriver won't cut it, and Apple didn't sell you its new pentalobe screwdriver. iFixit described Apple's strategy as a diabolical plan to screw your phone. And it seemed to have made the iPhone unopenable. To add to the frustration, the pentalobe screws rounded recesses make them more prone to being stripped than other screws. Apple didn't respond to our questions about the pentalobe. But third-party manufacturers like iFixit simply reverse engineered the screwdrivers. Soon, pentalobe compatible screwdrivers were widely available. Today, they're cheap. So the pentalobe screw was ultimately more of a speed bump than a technological lock. But then there's the sticky issue of glue. Sorry. Apple likes to use either glue or strong

23:02 adhesive strips to secure its batteries and screens tightly in place. It and other manufacturers argued this streamlines products and increases their waterproofing and durability. But repair experts have disputed this. The use of glue over screws makes it very easy to puncture or break parts when you try to pry them open. Take your phone's lithium battery. If you puncture it while trying to unstick it, it could catch fire. And when that happens, it's not pretty. Starting with the iPhone 16 in 2024, Apple begins to make the process slightly easier. With a new adhesive technology, you can run a low voltage electrical current through it. This jolt of electricity debonds the adhesive, allowing the battery to release itself from the frame. >> The battery pops out all on its own. >> Another method used to secure parts

23:48 together is soldering, joining metal pieces together by melting metal into the joint. [music] If you want to detach these parts to make repairs, you basically need to heat the joint until it melts. Apple and other tech giants solder critical chips, RAM, and storage drives directly to the logic board. This is the case with many Apple products, and it prevents simple component swaps. Soldering aside, if you come to Apple with a repair that's deemed too complicated, forget it. According to experts from iFixit, Apple's geniuses sometimes tell customers that certain repairs simply can't be done. Guess what? Apple didn't comment on this when asked, but it did tell us that in general, it supports [music] customer choice. Designing products in a way that makes them harder to repair isn't a new concept. If manufacturers control who

24:34 can make repairs, they're that much [music] closer to a monopoly over the entire industry, one that ensures any profits flow right back [music] to them. In the past, Taylor Company, which creates McFlurry ice cream machines, and John Deere, the tractor company, have sought to control who repairs their products. Both companies have used copyright laws and software locks to stop independent repairs. You may own something, but if it breaks, it seems like your only option is to go back to the manufacturer to get it fixed. During the COVID pandemic, there was a worldwide shortage of ventilators. iFixit began publishing DIY guides on how to fix these life-saving devices. The CEO of iFixit later posted that he was legally threatened by Steris, the company that manufactures these ventilators.

25:20 There is good news for McFlurry lovers. Today, individual McDonald's stores can fix their own machines instead of calling out Taylor, the original manufacturer. In 2024, the US Copyright Office approved an exemption to Section 1201 of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, or DMCA. So far, these repair barriers point to one issue. Big corporations control over the repair market leads to less choice and more expense for consumers, which is especially hard for low-income and other marginalized people. Aside from that, there's another major issue. >> E-waste is one of the biggest growing waste streams uh both for Europe and globally. There's no doubt about the fact that the problem is still increasing. We're not you know, we're not on the other side. We're not yet

26:06 improving. Things are still getting worse at this point. >> This is Dr. Thomas Oppermann, a campaigner and repair policy engineer for iFixit. >> The rate of improvement that we have is completely insufficient to stop what is happening at the same time with AliExpress and Shein and Temu and all of this, you know, fast fashion and and fast tech just washing over us. >> The world produces approximately 62 million tons of e-waste every year. That's roughly equivalent to throwing away more than 6,000 Eiffel Towers. And the volume is only going up. >> Hey, before we continue with the video, we want to invite you to check out Roots. Roots starts with a completely free ad-free newsletter. It's full of

26:53 fascinating little stories that didn't make it into the videos, ranging from bizarre borders to New Kingdom Moon to Wendy's failure in Europe to the point compelling and packed with beautiful visuals and infographics. It's also the place to learn more about Fern and the team. You can find behind the scenes, personal [music] thoughts, and joint questionnaires to help us develop our content. You'll also be the first one to learn more about Roots as we build it out. Check it out at the link in the description. You receive this cute printable freebie monitor when you sign up. And now back to the video. >> Chapter three, the halls of power. Kyle Schwarting has a farm about 20 minutes outside Lincoln, Nebraska. He's driving his Case IH tractor. It's a beauty, bright red and 27 tons. It cost a small fortune, around

27:39 $250,000. Ugh, what is that? He stops and tries to do what four generations of his family before him have done, fix his own tractor. Turns out that sound is an in-cab alarm. It blares at 10-minute intervals to alert him to a faulty hydraulic connector, something he never even uses. It's no use. He can't turn it off. The tractor's software has encryption locks. He may own the tractor, but he doesn't have a license to get into the software to repair it. In a response to a request for comment, Case IH told Fern that it supports customers' ability to safely maintain and repair their equipment by providing access to diagnostic and repair resources. At the same time, it says certain systems and functions have safeguards

28:25 related to areas such as operator safety, data privacy, and emissions compliance. It also said that Case IH customers can purchase an electronic service tool, the same diagnostic and repair their equipment. Case IH isn't alone. Many agricultural giants do the same. John Deere told the US Copyright Office that when farmers buy one of their tractors, they may own the vehicle, but they don't necessarily own its software. If Kyle wants to silence the alarm, he'll have to pay for the privilege. Seems like he's found another way, hacking his own tractor to make the repairs himself. Kyle had to live with that intermittent alarm for almost a year. Kyle takes his story to the media,

29:10 joining a band of farmers pushing for change. Nebraskan lawmakers listen. They draft a right to repair bill which would allow farmers to fix the tech in their agricultural equipment. And suddenly, Apple takes an interest. [music] If manufacturers are forced to remove software blocks and make their specialized repair tools readily available, that could hurt its bottom line too. Apple sends its representative Steve Kester to pay state senator Lydia Brasch a visit. She sponsored the bill. According to Brasch, Kester says Nebraska will become a [music] mecca for bad actors if the legislation passes. He claims hackers will flood the state. But if she were to exempt phones from the legislation, then Apple will back off. The bill fails. It's postponed indefinitely.

29:56 Brasch later says that in her seven years in office, she never experienced lobbying quite like that. Other right to repair bills have also come up against big tech lobbyists. Repair legislation has been proposed hundreds of times in every state in America, but so far, only 10 states have made it law. New York passed the Digital Fair Repair Act. It was passed by the state assembly 145 to 10, blindsiding big tech. It would have given citizens the right to fix their [music] phones, tablets, and computers, but it didn't. Before the act could be signed into law, lobbyists drew up amendments and presented them to governor Kathy Hochul. The lobby group TechNet represents Apple, Samsung, Google, and many others. According to the online magazine Grist,

30:41 it muscled its way into working on amending the bill. Some of its edits were inserted into the bill pretty much word for word. In the original wording, products covered by the bill would include all digital electric equipment with a value of over $10. Apparently, TechNet suggested that this definition be narrowed, that value of over $10 be scrapped and the word hardware introduced. But value of over $10 was important. The phrase would hammer home that the bill covered the vast majority of electronic equipment. While the word hardware would imply that software wasn't covered within the scope of the bill. TechNet also said that the definition of digital electronic equipment shouldn't include professional, industrial, business to government, [music] or business to business equipment not sold

31:27 to consumers. And by and large, the resulting law was identical to TechNet's reworking. In a statement emailed to Grist, TechNet's executive director for the Northeast wrote that the bill passed by the legislature presented unacceptable risks to consumer data privacy and safety, and that his organizations recommended changes addressed the most egregious security issues. We asked Apple various questions about the alleged lobbying by TechNet but didn't receive a reply. In general, Apple said it was the first smartphone manufacturer to support federal right to repair legislation in the United States [music] and that it supports the belief that consumers and businesses benefit from policies that balance repairability with things like product performance and consumer [music] safety. It isn't looking too hot for the

32:12 American right to repair movement, but across the Atlantic, some people in suits have a plan. The EU has joined the fight and it's come up with two solutions. [music] The first was Regulation 2023/1670, which addresses ecodesign for smartphones. The second is Regulation 2023/1542. It covers pretty much [music] every other device with a battery. To a degree, the regulations overlapped. Both sought to make batteries user replaceable. The rules for both were simple. Buyers had to be able to remove and replace batteries at home with commercially available tools. If a specialized tool was necessary, manufacturers would have to provide it with the product for free. And spare batteries would have to be available for at least five years after the last unit of a model hit the market,

32:57 seven years for smartphones. It looked like the EU had turned the tables on big tech, rewriting how it manufactured its devices to protect the environment and consumers' right to repair. But there's a catch. Before the initial draft of the first regulation could come into effect, this new wording made its way into the legislation. It says that if a battery retains at least 80% of its charge after 1,000 cycles, the manufacturer is exempt. Conveniently, this happens to cover all iPhone models from the 15 [music] on up. Other smartphones hit this target too, including the Google Pixel 8a and later models. Why did these changes appear in the first place? Thomas Oppermann has a theory. >> Well, clearly big tech and one of the

33:43 biggest here are are Apple, obviously. They're they're the largest electronics company worldwide, but they're they're not alone. So these manufacturers are represented by an organization called Digital Europe, [music] who represents the interests of of the whole electronics industry. And so for sure, there will have been a lot of pressure from from their side. >> So it seems Apple has effectively engineered its way out of the legislation. We asked Digital Europe and Apple for their sides of the story. Apple, as you might [music] have guessed, didn't comment. In its statement, Digital Europe categorically rejected any [music] suggestion of having inappropriately influenced or in any way threatened EU institutions [music] in an attempt to sway its policies.

34:28 During the legislative process, it said it only provided its point of view and pointed out potential legal uncertainties. As smartphones were already subject to product-specific requirements under the Ecodesign Regulation, Digital Europe said its engagement with the European Commission sought to highlight the risk of regulatory overlap. So the eco design regulation may have been watered down, but there was still regulation 2023/1542 dealing with batteries. But in July 2026 six additional exemptions were introduced to that one. Key electronics previously covered by the ruling suddenly weren't. Things like smart watches, fitness trackers, and electric toys. So both EU right to repair bills [music] were watered down a lot. But there have been some positive changes. The EU's battery laws have prompted some

35:15 manufacturers to make changes. Amazon is planning to launch [music] Kindle e-readers with user replaceable batteries. Leaked images of an upcoming Xbox Elite 3 controller suggest it might have them too. And Nintendo has announced that in Europe it will begin rolling out new products with user replaceable batteries. The Switch 2 for example. Manufacturers now have to make certain spare components available including batteries displays cameras charging ports microphones speakers and buttons depending on the repair scenario. If you're clumsy, there's a great clause for you. Devices batteries have to satisfy minimum accidental drop requirements. Plus there's a very Apple specific issue hiding within the regulation. Parts pairing. Manufacturers have to provide professional repairs access to all

36:02 software, firmware, or other tools necessary to ensure the replacement part and device function properly subject to the regulations conditions. This doesn't kill parts pairing [music] entirely, but it does limit manufacturers ability to use software pairing as an arbitrary barrier to legitimate repair. And the EU keeps going. In July 2026 a huge piece of legislation started to apply across the EU. The EU right to repair directive. It applies to many electronics such as fridges, smartphones, and washing machines. Under it manufacturers will have to repair certain products for 5 to 10 years depending on the product and part. Spare parts and tools must be provided at a reasonable price, one that doesn't deter repair. Well, good for Europeans, you might think, watching this somewhere in the US

36:48 or elsewhere, but this might have a positive effect for you too. There's this phenomenon called the Brussels Effect. Often, EU regulation can effectively establish global product standards because multinational manufacturers don't want [music] to maintain completely different designs for every market. Here's hoping that someday we might just be allowed and enabled to repair the things we own again. Wouldn't that be nice? >> [music]

Share

YouTube Video Summaries